US History › Section E · Industry and Jacksonian democracy › Topic E.4
From John Quincy Adams to Jackson: mass democracy
In the 1820s American politics changed from a contest among gentlemen into a mass competition for votes. More white men could vote, parties learned to organise them, and Andrew Jackson rode the new style to the presidency, while women, free Black men and Native peoples were pushed further outside.
The politics of deference
The founders expected voters to defer to a natural aristocracy of educated, propertied and virtuous men. Early presidents fitted that mould: apart from John Adams of Massachusetts, all of them, from Washington to Monroe, were wealthy Virginia slaveholders. After the War of 1812 the Federalist Party faded, and it never ran a presidential candidate after losing to James Monroe in 1816. With the Democratic-Republicans dominant, congressional caucuses chose nominees with little popular input. By the early 1820s many Americans resented this as rule by insiders, and deference began to give way to the idea that the majority should rule.
Widening the vote for white men
Most original states had limited voting to property owners or taxpayers. New western states such as Indiana (1816), Illinois (1818) and Alabama (1819) allowed white men to vote regardless of property, partly to attract settlers, and older states followed: New York dropped its property test for white men in 1821, and by about 1840 nearly every state had removed property requirements, though some kept a small tax or militia rule. Rhode Island was a late exception. States also moved the choice of presidential electors from legislatures to voters, and by 1832 only South Carolina still let its legislature choose them.
Who was shut out
The same years narrowed the vote for others. New Jersey, where some property-owning women and free Black men had voted, limited the franchise to white men in 1807. Connecticut did the same by law in 1814 and in its 1818 constitution, Pennsylvania in 1838, and other states, including North Carolina and Tennessee, in the 1830s. New York's 1821 constitution kept a $250 property requirement for Black men only, which disqualified almost all of them. No state let women vote, and Native peoples were treated as members of separate nations. In effect, race and sex replaced property as the main tests of who belonged in the electorate.
Worked example: one constitution, two directions
Analyse New York's constitutional convention of 1821. 1. The change: white men no longer needed significant property to vote, and later amendments removed even the small tax and service requirements. 2. Who gained: tens of thousands of white tenant farmers, labourers and craftsmen. 3. The new barrier: Black men had to own property worth $250 and pay tax on it, a test most white men no longer faced. 4. The effect: the number of eligible Black voters fell to a small fraction of its former level. 5. Conclusion: the convention widened democracy for one group while deliberately narrowing it for another. Check: both outcomes came from the same document, so neither alone describes it fairly.
Parties and machines
Democracy needed organisation. In New York, Martin Van Buren led the Bucktail faction of the Democratic-Republicans, which built a disciplined party that rewarded loyal workers with government jobs and demanded that members support the party's choices. Van Buren argued that permanent parties gave voters clear choices, a sharp break from founders who had seen parties as dangerous factions. Party newspapers, local committees and, from the early 1830s, national nominating conventions, first held by the small Anti-Masonic Party in 1831, replaced the old caucus system.
The election of 1824
With the caucus discredited, four major candidates ran in 1824, all Democratic-Republicans: John Quincy Adams of Massachusetts, the secretary of state; Andrew Jackson of Tennessee, hero of the Battle of New Orleans; William H. Crawford of Georgia, the caucus nominee, weakened by a stroke; and Henry Clay of Kentucky, Speaker of the House. John C. Calhoun ran for vice president instead and won. Jackson led the popular vote with about 41 percent to Adams's 31 percent. In the Electoral College, Jackson won 99 votes, Adams 84, Crawford 41 and Clay 37. With 261 electors, a majority meant 131, so no one had won.
Worked example: why Adams became president
Follow the constitutional steps. 1. No candidate had a majority of electoral votes, so the Twelfth Amendment sent the election to the House of Representatives. 2. The House could choose only among the top three, so Clay, in fourth place, was out, but as Speaker he had great influence. 3. Each state delegation cast one vote, and a winner needed 13 of the 24 states. 4. Clay, who shared Adams's support for a strong national economic programme and disliked Jackson, backed Adams, who won exactly 13 states in February 1825. 5. Adams then named Clay secretary of state. Check: the process was legal, but Jackson's supporters denounced it as a "corrupt bargain".
Adams's troubled presidency
Adams supported Clay's American System: a protective tariff, a national bank and federally funded internal improvements. He also proposed a national university and a naval academy, which opponents attacked as costly, elitist and unconstitutional. Congress gave him little, though the National Road was extended and work on the Chesapeake and Ohio Canal began in 1828. That year Adams signed a steep new tariff that southerners called the Tariff of Abominations, which the next topic examines. Meanwhile Jackson's allies spent four years preparing for a rematch.
The campaign of 1828
The 1828 contest is often described as the first fought by modern-style party organisation. Jackson's supporters, soon called Democrats, built a national network of newspapers, committees and Hickory Clubs (after his nickname, Old Hickory), with rallies and barbecues to draw new voters. They cast Jackson as a plain man of the people against a corrupt elite, though he was a wealthy slaveholding planter. Both sides slung mud: Adams's backers attacked Jackson's violent temper and his marriage to Rachel Jackson, while Jacksonians called Adams an aristocrat. Turnout roughly doubled from about 27 percent of eligible voters in 1824 to about 57 percent, and Jackson won decisively, 178 electoral votes to 83.
Jackson in office
Crowds at Jackson's inauguration in March 1829 surged into the White House, thrilling supporters and horrifying critics. Jackson defended rotation in office: ordinary men could do public duties, and long tenure bred corruption. Critics called it the spoils system, after Senator William Marcy's 1832 phrase "to the victor belong the spoils of the enemy." Historians estimate Jackson replaced roughly a tenth to a fifth of federal officeholders, more than earlier presidents. He leaned on informal advisers, the Kitchen Cabinet. Then the Petticoat affair split his official cabinet: Washington wives, led by Floride Calhoun, shunned Peggy Eaton, wife of the secretary of war. Jackson defended her; Van Buren, courteous to her, won his trust, and Calhoun lost it.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, Jacksonian democracy did not give everyone the vote; it widened voting for white men while removing it from many free Black men. Second, Adams did not steal the 1824 election: the House chose him legally, although the "corrupt bargain" charge stuck. Third, the House could not consider Clay because he finished fourth. Fourth, Jackson did not invent patronage, and he did not replace most federal officials. Fifth, Jackson the common man was a campaign image; he was a rich planter and slaveholder.
Key takeaways
Between about 1815 and 1830, deference gave way to majority rule. Property requirements fell for white men, while race and sex became the tests of voting. Van Buren's New York machine showed how disciplined parties could mobilise voters. In 1824 Jackson won the most votes but not an electoral majority, and the House chose Adams, prompting the "corrupt bargain" charge. In 1828 Democratic organisation and a doubled turnout carried Jackson to victory. Rotation in office and the Petticoat affair shaped his first term and raised Van Buren.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Voters' habit of leaving government to educated, propertied gentlemen
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Why was the presidential election of 1824 decided by the House of Representatives?
Question 2 of 5
Henry Clay was Speaker of the House in 1825. Why could the House not choose him as president?
Question 3 of 5
What did New York's constitution of 1821 do to voting rights?
Question 4 of 5
How did Jackson justify rotation in office?
Question 5 of 5
What was one political result of the Petticoat affair?
