US History › Section H · Civil War and Reconstruction › Topic H.8

The collapse of Reconstruction

Within about ten years of the war's end, white Southern Democrats had regained power across the South through economic pressure, terror and a weakening Northern commitment. Reconstruction collapsed in 1877, but the amendments it left behind would later become the legal foundation of the civil rights movement.

Why did Reconstruction end?

No single cause ended Reconstruction. In the South, landowners used their economic power over Black workers, and paramilitary groups used terror against Black voters and their white allies. In the North, an economic depression, party splits and scandals drained support for continued federal action, and many white Northerners had never been committed to racial equality. The Supreme Court narrowed the new amendments. One by one, Southern states fell to Democrats who called themselves Redeemers, and a disputed presidential election in 1876 ended federal support for the last Republican governments.

Land, labour and sharecropping

Freed people built families, churches and communities with remarkable speed, but almost none received land. After Johnson returned confiscated land to its former owners, most freed families had to work land owned by others. Freed people rejected gang labour under overseers, which recalled slavery, and planters were short of cash for wages. Sharecropping emerged as the compromise: a family farmed its own plot of a landowner's land and paid with a share of the crop, often half. Families bought seed, food and tools on credit from a merchant or the landowner, under a crop lien, a claim on the coming harvest. Some poor white farmers fell into the same system.

Worked example: the debt cycle

A hypothetical sharecropping family in 1870, traced step by step. 1. In spring, the family has no cash, so it buys supplies on credit at the landowner's store, pledging its cotton as security. 2. Prices are marked up and interest is high, often charged on the whole debt for the full season. 3. At harvest, half the cotton goes to the landowner as rent, and the family's share goes to pay the store. 4. Cotton prices fell for much of the period, so the share often did not cover the debt. 5. The family ends the year still owing, and lien laws bind it to the same landowner for another year. 6. Conclusion: workers were free in law but trapped by debt.

Terror: the Klan and its allies

The Ku Klux Klan was founded in Pulaski, Tennessee, around 1865-1866 by Confederate veterans, and Nathan Bedford Forrest soon became its leader. It spread as a loose network of local groups that whipped, burned and murdered to stop Black people voting, learning or prospering, and attacked white Republicans, teachers and Black officeholders. In 1868 Klansmen killed a Republican congressman from Arkansas. Later groups such as the White League in Louisiana and the Red Shirts acted openly as armed wings of the Democratic Party. At Colfax, Louisiana, in April 1873, white paramilitaries killed an estimated 60 to 150 Black men, many after they surrendered.

The federal response

Congress and President Grant did fight back at first. The Enforcement Acts of 1870 and 1871 made it a federal crime to interfere with voting by force or intimidation, and the third act, known as the Ku Klux Klan Act, let the president use troops and suspend habeas corpus against conspiracies. A congressional committee gathered testimony from hundreds of victims. In 1871, Grant suspended habeas corpus in nine South Carolina counties, and federal prosecutors won many convictions. The first Klan was largely broken by 1872. But the government lacked the will to sustain the effort, and terror returned under new names.

The North loses interest

In 1872, Liberal Republicans broke with Grant, calling for smaller government and an end to federal intervention in the South, though Grant was re-elected. A financial panic in 1873 began a long depression, and voters turned to economic worries. Scandals, including Crédit Mobilier, a railway construction fraud that involved members of Congress, and the Whiskey Ring of tax fraud, damaged the Republicans. In 1874, Democrats won the House for the first time since before the war. Meanwhile, Southern states fell to the Redeemers; in Mississippi in 1875, open intimidation at the polls overturned a Republican majority, and Grant declined to send troops.

The courts narrow the amendments

The Supreme Court limited the new protections. In the Slaughterhouse Cases of 1873, it read the Fourteenth Amendment's protection of citizens' privileges narrowly, leaving most rights to the states. In United States v. Cruikshank in 1876, arising from the Colfax massacre, it ruled that the amendment restricted only states, not private individuals, overturning convictions of the attackers. United States v. Reese, the same year, weakened federal enforcement of the Fifteenth Amendment. Congress passed a Civil Rights Act in 1875 banning discrimination in public places such as inns and theatres, but the Court struck it down in 1883.

The disputed election of 1876

In 1876, the Democrat Samuel Tilden won the popular vote by about 250,000 votes over the Republican Rutherford B. Hayes and was one electoral vote short of a majority. Twenty electoral votes were disputed, from Florida, Louisiana, South Carolina and Oregon, with rival sets of returns amid fraud and intimidation on both sides. Congress created a fifteen-member Electoral Commission, which voted 8 to 7 along party lines to give all twenty votes to Hayes. Democrats accepted the result. Soon after taking office in 1877, Hayes withdrew the federal troops protecting the Republican governments of South Carolina and Louisiana, and both collapsed.

Worked example: was there a deal?

Question: was the Compromise of 1877 a formal bargain? 1. Traditional account: in 1951 the historian C. Vann Woodward described a deal in which Southern Democrats accepted Hayes in return for troop withdrawal, a Southern cabinet member and federal aid for internal improvements such as a Texas railway. 2. Evidence for: Hayes did withdraw the troops and appointed a Southerner as postmaster general. 3. Evidence against: other historians found that Hayes had already favoured withdrawal, and the railway aid never came. 4. Conclusion: most now see an informal understanding rather than a single bargain. Either way, the outcome was the same: the federal government stopped defending Black citizens' rights in the South.

What came after

Once in power, Redeemer governments cut taxes and school spending. From 1890, beginning with Mississippi, Southern states used poll taxes, unfairly applied literacy tests, grandfather clauses and white primaries to strip most Black men of the vote. Segregation laws, known as Jim Crow, spread, and in Plessy v. Ferguson in 1896 the Supreme Court upheld "separate but equal", a ruling that stood until 1954. Lynching rose; the journalist Ida B. Wells documented it from the 1890s. Booker T. Washington urged economic self-help, while W. E. B. Du Bois demanded full equal rights and helped found the NAACP in 1909. Black Southerners began moving north and west, the roots of the Great Migration. Yet the Fourteenth and Fifteenth Amendments remained in the Constitution, and the civil rights movement of the 1950s and 1960s used them to win back the rights Reconstruction had promised.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, saying Reconstruction failed because Black officials were incompetent or corrupt; it was overthrown by violence and abandoned by the federal government. Second, treating sharecropping as fair tenancy, ignoring the debt it created. Third, assuming the Klan acted alone; other armed groups served the Democratic Party openly. Fourth, describing the Compromise of 1877 as a proven written deal. Fifth, thinking disenfranchisement and Jim Crow arrived in 1877; most came in the 1890s and after.

Key takeaways

Without land, most freed families became sharecroppers trapped by crop liens and debt. The Klan and later groups such as the White League used terror to drive Black voters and Republicans from power. The Enforcement Acts broke the first Klan, but Northern support faded after the Panic of 1873, scandals and Democratic gains in 1874. The Supreme Court narrowed the amendments in cases such as Cruikshank. The disputed 1876 election led Hayes to withdraw troops in 1877, ending Reconstruction. The amendments survived to power later civil rights struggles.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Redeemers

White Southern Democrats who retook state governments from Republicans

Claimed to "redeem" the South.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Why did sharecropping so often leave freed families in debt?

Question 2 of 5

What did the Supreme Court rule in United States v. Cruikshank (1876)?

Question 3 of 5

Which development in the North most weakened support for Reconstruction in the mid-1870s?

Question 4 of 5

How was the disputed election of 1876 resolved?

Question 5 of 5

How do most historians now describe the Compromise of 1877?

← Previous topicNext topic →