US History › Section H · Civil War and Reconstruction › Topic H.7
Radical Reconstruction
From 1867, Congress took control of Reconstruction. It placed most of the former Confederacy under military supervision, impeached a president, added the Fifteenth Amendment to the Constitution and, for a few years, made the South the scene of an experiment in interracial democracy.
Congress takes charge
With veto-proof majorities after the 1866 elections, Republicans could now write Reconstruction policy themselves. Its most determined leaders were Representative Thaddeus Stevens of Pennsylvania and Senator Charles Sumner of Massachusetts. Stevens argued that the seceded states were conquered territory that Congress could reorganise as it chose, and he proposed breaking up large plantations to give land to freed families. Sumner pressed for equal rights in voting, schools and public places. Most Republicans were more moderate: they would not confiscate land, but they agreed that Black men needed the vote to protect their freedom and to keep former Confederates from returning to power.
The Reconstruction Acts
Beginning in March 1867, Congress passed a series of Reconstruction Acts over Johnson's vetoes. The ten former Confederate states that had rejected the Fourteenth Amendment were divided into five military districts, each commanded by a Union general with troops to keep order and protect freed people. Tennessee, already readmitted, was excluded. To return to Congress, each state had to hold elections in which Black men could vote, write a new constitution guaranteeing Black male suffrage, and ratify the Fourteenth Amendment. The army registered voters. By 1870 every former Confederate state had been readmitted; the last few also had to ratify the Fifteenth Amendment.
Impeaching a president
Congress also tried to limit Johnson directly. The Tenure of Office Act of 1867 barred the president from removing officials whose appointment had needed Senate approval unless the Senate agreed. In February 1868, Johnson dismissed Secretary of War Edwin Stanton, an ally of the Radicals. Days later, the House impeached him, the first time a president had been impeached, charging him in eleven articles, most of them about violating the act. At the trial in the Senate, seven Republicans voted with the Democrats to acquit. The vote to convict was 35 to 19, one short of the two-thirds needed. Johnson served out his term with little power left.
Grant and the Fifteenth Amendment
In 1868, the Republicans nominated Ulysses S. Grant, who defeated the Democrat Horatio Seymour. Republicans reminded voters of Democrats' links to secession and the war, a tactic called waving the bloody shirt. Grant's popular majority was only about 300,000 votes, and Black voters in the South, newly enfranchised, supplied a large share of his support. That lesson helped persuade Republicans to protect Black voting nationally, including in Northern states that still denied it. Congress passed the Fifteenth Amendment in February 1869, and it was ratified in February 1870.
Worked example: reading the Fifteenth Amendment
Source: "The right of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any State on account of race, color, or previous condition of servitude." 1. What it forbids: denying the vote for the three listed reasons. 2. What it does not do: it gives no positive right to vote and does not ban other tests. 3. Debate: some Republicans wanted a broader ban that would also cover property, literacy or birthplace, but a narrow version was easier to ratify. 4. Consequence: later Southern states used poll taxes, literacy tests and other devices that never mentioned race. 5. Missing: sex is not listed, so women remained excluded.
Women's suffrage and a divided movement
Many women's rights activists had worked alongside abolitionists for decades, and in 1866 they joined Black and white men in the American Equal Rights Association to seek votes for all. The Fourteenth and Fifteenth Amendments split that coalition. Frederick Douglass and Lucy Stone argued that Black men's need for the vote was urgent and that women's suffrage would have to follow. Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Susan B. Anthony opposed the Fifteenth Amendment without women, at times using racist arguments. In 1869 two rival groups formed: Stanton and Anthony's National Woman Suffrage Association and Stone's American Woman Suffrage Association. That year, Wyoming Territory let women vote.
Black political power
Hundreds of thousands of Black men registered to vote, organised often through Union Leagues, Republican clubs that also helped build schools and churches. Historians have identified roughly 1,500 or more Black officeholders during Reconstruction, from sheriffs, justices of the peace and school board members to state legislators and a lieutenant governor of Louisiana. Sixteen Black men served in Congress. Hiram Revels of Mississippi became the first Black senator in 1870, and Blanche K. Bruce, also of Mississippi, later served a full Senate term. Joseph Rainey of South Carolina became the first Black member of the House; Robert Smalls, who had escaped slavery by seizing a Confederate ship, later joined him there.
What the new governments did
Reconstruction governments were coalitions of Black voters, white Northerners who had moved south, whom opponents called carpetbaggers, and white Southern Republicans, whom opponents called scalawags. Black men held a majority only in South Carolina's lower house. These governments created the first statewide public school systems in most Southern states, open to Black and white children though usually in separate schools. They funded hospitals and orphanages, rebuilt railways, and repealed the Black Codes. To pay for this they raised property taxes, which angered landowners. Some officials were corrupt, as many were in Northern cities of the same era.
Worked example: how historians judged Reconstruction
Question: why has the reputation of Reconstruction changed? 1. Early twentieth century: historians of the Dunning School, named after William A. Dunning, portrayed it as a tragedy of corrupt carpetbaggers and incapable Black officials. 2. Their evidence leaned on white Southern sources and assumed Black people were unfit to govern. 3. Challenge: in 1935, W. E. B. Du Bois's Black Reconstruction showed freed people as active builders of democracy. 4. Later research by historians such as Eric Foner confirmed that the governments were no more corrupt than others of the time and achieved real reforms. 5. Conclusion: the older view reflected the prejudices of its authors, and helped justify segregation.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, believing Black officials dominated the South: they were a minority of officeholders almost everywhere. Second, repeating the old claim that Reconstruction governments were uniquely corrupt. Third, thinking Johnson was removed from office; he was impeached but acquitted by one vote. Fourth, reading the Fifteenth Amendment as a guarantee of the vote; it only banned denial on account of race, colour or previous servitude. Fifth, forgetting that freed families never received the land Stevens proposed.
Key takeaways
From 1867, the Reconstruction Acts put ten Southern states under military districts and required Black male suffrage and the Fourteenth Amendment for readmission. The House impeached Johnson in 1868, and the Senate acquitted him by one vote. Grant won in 1868, and the Fifteenth Amendment, ratified in 1870, banned denying the vote on account of race. It split the women's suffrage movement. Black men voted and held office in large numbers, and Reconstruction governments built public schools and services. The Dunning School's hostile view has been overturned.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Radical leader in the House who proposed giving plantation land to freed families
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What did the Reconstruction Acts of 1867 require before a former Confederate state could be readmitted?
Question 2 of 5
What was the outcome of Andrew Johnson's impeachment?
Question 3 of 5
Which weakness of the Fifteenth Amendment did Southern states later exploit?
Question 4 of 5
Why did the women's suffrage movement split in 1869?
Question 5 of 5
How have historians since Du Bois revised the Dunning School's view of Reconstruction governments?
