US History › Section I · The West and big business › Topic I.8
A new consumer culture
By 1900, factories, railways and new ways of selling had turned many Americans from people who made most of what they used into consumers who bought it. Department stores, chain stores, mail-order catalogues, brands, advertising and credit shaped a culture that still defines American life.
From making to buying
In the early 1800s, most rural families made much of their own clothing, soap and food and bought the rest at a general store, often on credit, with little choice. By 1900 that had changed. Mass production lowered the price of goods from shoes to soap, and railways carried them everywhere. A growing middle class of clerks, managers, teachers and professionals had steady salaries and some spare money. Even wage earners, whose pay was low, gained from falling prices. The topics on industrial growth and labour showed how goods were made; this topic follows how they were sold, and how buying became part of identity.
Department stores
Large city stores gathered many departments under one roof: Macy's in New York, founded in 1858, Marshall Field's in Chicago and John Wanamaker's in Philadelphia among them. Wanamaker popularised fixed, marked prices instead of haggling, along with money-back guarantees. New technology made these stores palaces of display: plate-glass windows, electric lights, elevators and tall open floors. Shopping became a respectable leisure activity for middle-class women, who could browse without buying, take tea in the store's restaurant and rest in its lounges. The stores also employed thousands of saleswomen, often young and poorly paid, who had to dress and speak like the customers they served.
Chain stores
Chain stores brought similar goods to smaller towns. The Great Atlantic and Pacific Tea Company, known as A&P, grew from a New York tea business founded in 1859 into a national grocery chain, buying in bulk to undercut local grocers. In 1879 Frank Woolworth opened a successful five-cent store in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, after an earlier attempt in Utica, New York, failed; his "five-and-ten" stores spread across the country. Chains relied on high volume, low prices and cash sales rather than credit. Local merchants complained that chains drained money from their towns, an argument that would grow louder in the twentieth century.
Mail order reaches the countryside
Most Americans still lived in rural areas, far from city stores. In 1872 the Chicago salesman Aaron Montgomery Ward began selling goods by mail, starting with a single sheet aimed at farmers in the Grange movement. Richard Sears began by selling watches in 1886, and Sears, Roebuck and Company, named in 1893, soon published catalogues of hundreds of pages offering everything from ploughs to pianos at clearly printed prices. Rural Free Delivery, begun experimentally in 1896, brought mail to farm households, and parcel post from 1913 made shipping cheaper. Some small-town merchants, losing customers, urged people to burn the catalogues.
Worked example: reading a mail-order catalogue
Analyse a page from a typical 1890s mail-order catalogue offering sewing machines, stoves and clothing. 1. Origin: a Chicago firm wrote it to sell goods. 2. Audience: rural families, shown by farm equipment and plain-language instructions on how to order. 3. Methods: printed prices, detailed drawings and money-back guarantees aimed to overcome distrust of distant sellers. 4. What it shows: the range of goods and the prices that factories and railways made possible. 5. Limits: a catalogue shows what was offered and hoped for, not what families actually bought or could afford. 6. Conclusion: it is strong evidence of the new national market and weak evidence of typical living standards.
Brands and advertising
Goods once sold loose from barrels began to arrive in boxes and tins with brand names. Ivory soap, launched in 1879, Coca-Cola in 1886, Kodak cameras in 1888 and Campbell's condensed soup in 1897 promised the same quality everywhere, which helped customers trust distant makers. Brands needed advertising. Agencies such as N. W. Ayer and Son, founded in 1869, wrote and placed ads for clients, and cheap magazines such as the Ladies' Home Journal, founded in 1883, were paid for largely by advertisers. Kodak's slogan, "You press the button, we do the rest", showed a new style that sold convenience and feelings, not just the product.
Buying on credit
Many families could not pay for costly goods at once. From 1856 the Singer company sold sewing machines on instalments, a small payment down and regular payments after, and the method spread to pianos, furniture and stoves. A sewing machine could be justified as an investment that saved hours of hand-stitching or earned money from home sewing. A piano in the parlour signalled respectability. Credit let working families reach for a middle-class lifestyle, but a lost job, an illness or a wage cut could mean missed payments and repossession. Many Americans still thought debt for everyday goods shameful, a view that weakened only slowly.
Who could take part?
Consumer culture promised that anyone could buy the same goods, but access was unequal. Low-paid workers bought little beyond necessities, and many immigrant families spent most of their income on rent and food. In the South, Black customers often faced insults, segregation or cheating in white-owned local stores; historians note that mail-order catalogues let some Black rural families shop without facing a hostile merchant. Women, who did most household buying, gained a new public role as consumers. Writing about 1920s advertising, the historian Roland Marchand called the promise that everyone could share in the same products a "democracy of goods"; its roots lay in this period.
Leisure for sale
Industry also sold experiences. Professional baseball's National League began in 1876, and crowds paid to watch. Vaudeville theatres offered cheap variety shows to working-class and middle-class audiences, and the safety bicycle set off a craze in the 1890s, giving young women new freedom of movement. At Coney Island in Brooklyn, amusement parks such as Steeplechase Park, opened in 1897, sold thrilling rides for a few cents. For many urban workers, who had won slightly shorter hours in some trades, Sunday and evening leisure became something bought rather than made at home or in church.
Worked example: why a national market emerged
Trace the causes of the new consumer culture. 1. Production: factories using machines and cheap steel turned out standard goods in huge quantities at falling prices. 2. Transport: a national railway network moved goods anywhere quickly and cheaply. 3. Communication: the telegraph, the postal service and cheap printing let sellers reach customers far away. 4. Selling: department stores, chains and catalogues offered fixed prices and wide choice. 5. Persuasion: brands and advertising built trust and desire. 6. Credit: instalment plans let families buy before they had saved. 7. Effect: by 1900 Americans increasingly measured success and identity by what they could buy.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming consumer culture began in the 1920s; its foundations, from catalogues to brands and instalment credit, were laid by 1900. Second, imagining everyone shared equally; low wages, rural distance and racial discrimination limited access. Third, confusing chain stores, many branches selling standard goods, with department stores, single large stores with many departments. Fourth, thinking mail-order customers ordered by telephone; they sent written orders by post. Fifth, treating advertising as simple information; it increasingly sold feelings, status and convenience.
Key takeaways
Mass production and railways made cheap, standard goods available nationwide. Department stores such as Macy's and Wanamaker's turned shopping into leisure, while chains such as A&P and Woolworth's reached smaller towns. Montgomery Ward and Sears sold to rural America by mail, helped by Rural Free Delivery. Brands and advertising agencies built trust and desire, and instalment credit spread from Singer sewing machines to pianos. Access remained unequal, but buying had become central to American life.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Way of life in which buying goods shapes daily life and identity
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
How did mail-order catalogues change shopping for rural Americans?
Question 2 of 5
Which feature best describes a chain store such as Woolworth's?
Question 3 of 5
Why did brand names become important in this period?
Question 4 of 5
What risk did instalment buying create for working families?
Question 5 of 5
A historian uses an 1890s catalogue page to argue that most farm families owned pianos. What is the main weakness of this argument?
