US History › Section I · The West and big business › Topic I.7
Industrial labor and unions
Industrial growth created millions of wage-earning jobs that were long, dangerous and insecure. Workers organised in new ways, but employers, courts and governments defeated most of their great strikes before 1900.
A new working class
By 1900 most American workers no longer owned farms or shops; they worked for wages set by someone else. Average real wages rose over the period as prices fell, but the gains were uneven and fragile. A typical factory week ran ten hours a day, six days a week, and many steelworkers worked twelve-hour shifts, seven days a week. Machines broke skilled crafts into simple repeated tasks, so employers could replace workers easily. There was no unemployment insurance and little compensation for injury, and accidents killed thousands of railway workers and miners every year. Severe depressions in 1873-1879 and 1893-1897 threw millions out of work.
Women, children and divided workers
Roughly five million women earned wages by 1900, most of them young and single. Domestic service remained their largest occupation, followed by textile and garment work. Women were paid far less than men doing similar work. The 1900 census counted roughly 1.7 million children aged 10 to 15 at work, in mills, mines, fields and city streets. Workers were also divided by race, ethnicity and religion. Many unions shut out Black workers, and employers sometimes hired Black or newly arrived immigrant workers as strikebreakers, deepening those divisions.
The weapons of employers
Employers had powerful tools. They kept blacklists of union activists, made workers sign "ironclad" contracts, later called yellow-dog contracts, promising not to join a union, and locked workers out of plants. Private detective agencies, above all the Pinkertons, supplied spies and armed guards, and strikebreakers kept plants running. Courts increasingly issued injunctions, orders forbidding strikes or boycotts, and governors and presidents sent militia and troops. Newspapers often linked unions to foreign radicals, so public opinion usually turned against strikers once violence began, whoever started it.
Violence in the 1870s
In the Pennsylvania coalfields, mine owners blamed a series of killings on the Molly Maguires, a secret society of Irish miners. A Pinkerton detective, James McParland, infiltrated the group for the Reading Railroad, and twenty men were hanged between 1877 and 1879 after trials run largely by company lawyers; historians still debate how much of the organisation was real. In July 1877, after the Baltimore and Ohio cut wages again, railway workers at Martinsburg, West Virginia, walked out. The Great Railroad Strike spread to Baltimore, Pittsburgh, Chicago and St Louis, and an estimated 100 people died.
Worked example: why the 1877 strike spread and failed
Analyse the causes and outcome of the Great Railroad Strike. 1. Background: four years into the depression after 1873, railways cut wages repeatedly while paying dividends. 2. Spark: a fresh wage cut on the Baltimore and Ohio. 3. Spread: rail lines linked cities, and unemployed people and townsfolk who resented the railways joined the crowds. 4. Escalation: in Pittsburgh, militia fired on a crowd, and rioters burned railway property. 5. Response: President Hayes sent federal troops to several cities, the first major use of the army against strikers. 6. Outcome: the strike collapsed within weeks. 7. Lesson: spontaneous protest could not beat organised employers and the state.
The National Labor Union and the Knights
The National Labor Union, founded in 1866, was a federation of local unions and reform groups that pushed for an eight-hour day; Congress granted one to federal workers in 1868, but the NLU faded after the Panic of 1873. The Knights of Labor, founded in 1869 by the Philadelphia garment cutter Uriah Stephens, grew under Terence Powderly, who preferred arbitration to strikes, from 1879. It welcomed workers of almost every trade and skill, including women and Black workers, and sought cooperatives and an end to the wage system, though it excluded Chinese workers and backed their exclusion. After winning a strike against Jay Gould's railways in 1885, it peaked at about 700,000 members in 1886.
Haymarket, 1886
On 1 May 1886, hundreds of thousands of workers struck for an eight-hour day. In Chicago on 3 May, police killed strikers at the McCormick Harvesting Machine works. At a protest meeting in Haymarket Square the next evening, police moved in to break up the dwindling crowd and someone threw a bomb. The blast and the gunfire that followed killed seven police officers, several from their own side's shots, and at least four civilians. Eight anarchists were convicted, on little evidence linking them to the bomb; four were hanged in 1887. In 1893 Illinois governor John Peter Altgeld pardoned the three still in prison. The Knights, though not involved, lost most of their members.
Gompers and the AFL
In 1886, craft unions formed the American Federation of Labor, led almost continuously by Samuel Gompers, a cigar maker born in London, until 1924. The AFL took a different path from the Knights. It organised skilled workers by trade, accepted capitalism and focused on "bread and butter" gains: higher wages, shorter hours and safer conditions, won through collective bargaining and, when necessary, strikes. Skilled workers were hard to replace, which gave AFL unions bargaining power. Membership reached about half a million by 1900, but the AFL left out most unskilled workers, and many member unions barred women and Black workers.
Homestead, 1892
At Carnegie's Homestead steelworks near Pittsburgh, the skilled Amalgamated Association of Iron and Steel Workers was one of the strongest unions in the country. In 1892, with Carnegie in Scotland, his partner Henry Clay Frick demanded wage cuts and, when the union refused, locked the workers out. On 6 July about 300 Pinkerton guards arrived by barge on the river, and a gun battle left about ten men dead, most of them workers. Pennsylvania's governor then sent some 8,000 militiamen, and strikebreakers restarted the mills. An anarchist's attempt to assassinate Frick turned opinion further against the strikers. By November the union was broken and steel stayed largely non-union for decades.
Worked example: how the Pullman boycott was broken
Trace the federal role in the Pullman Strike of 1894. 1. Cause: during the depression, George Pullman cut wages by around a quarter but did not lower rents in his company town of Pullman, Illinois. 2. Strike: workers walked out in May. 3. Boycott: in June, Eugene V. Debs's American Railway Union refused to handle trains carrying Pullman cars, halting traffic across much of the country. 4. Federal action: Attorney General Richard Olney won a court injunction, arguing that the strike obstructed the mail and interstate commerce. 5. Troops: President Cleveland sent soldiers to Chicago over Governor Altgeld's objections. 6. Outcome: the boycott collapsed, dozens died, Debs was jailed, and in 1895 the Supreme Court upheld the injunction.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming the Knights and the AFL had the same strategy; the Knights welcomed almost all workers and sought broad reform, while the AFL organised skilled crafts for practical gains. Second, believing the Haymarket defendants were proven bomb throwers; the bomber was never identified. Third, treating Homestead as Carnegie's personal battle alone; Frick ran it, though Carnegie backed him. Fourth, thinking the federal government stayed neutral; troops and injunctions broke the 1877 and Pullman strikes. Fifth, forgetting that unions themselves often excluded women, Black workers and Chinese immigrants.
Key takeaways
Industrial wage work brought long hours, danger and insecurity, and depended heavily on women and children. Employers used blacklists, yellow-dog contracts, Pinkertons, injunctions and troops. The Great Railroad Strike of 1877 showed the power and limits of spontaneous protest. The Knights of Labor rose to about 700,000 members, then collapsed after Haymarket in 1886. The AFL under Gompers survived by organising skilled crafts. Defeats at Homestead in 1892 and Pullman in 1894 left most workers unorganised by 1900.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Working for pay set by an employer rather than owning a farm or shop
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
How did the Knights of Labor differ most from the American Federation of Labor?
Question 2 of 5
Why did the Haymarket affair badly damage the Knights of Labor?
Question 3 of 5
What made the AFL's craft unions more durable than earlier labour groups?
Question 4 of 5
What was the main role of the federal government in ending the Pullman Strike of 1894?
Question 5 of 5
Which event began the Great Railroad Strike of 1877?
