US History › Section C · Toward independence › Topic C.6
The course of the war, north and south
Britain had the stronger army and navy, yet it lost the war. Following the fighting from New York to Saratoga, and from Charleston to Yorktown, shows how Americans survived early defeats, won a crucial ally and wore down an empire.
Two strategies
After leaving Boston in 1776, British commanders aimed to crush the Continental Army, seize the main cities and rally Loyalists, whom they believed were numerous. A favourite plan was to control the Hudson River and cut off New England, seen as the heart of the rebellion. The Americans faced a different problem. They did not need to conquer anything; they needed to avoid losing. As long as Washington kept an army in the field and Congress kept functioning, the rebellion survived, and Britain had to keep paying for a war fought 3,000 miles from home.
From New York to Trenton
In summer 1776 General William Howe and his brother Admiral Richard Howe brought about 32,000 troops to New York, one of the largest forces Britain had ever sent overseas. They routed Washington's inexperienced army on Long Island in August, took New York City in September and drove the Americans across New Jersey. Thousands of captured Americans later died in British prison ships in New York harbour. With enlistments expiring and morale collapsing, Thomas Paine opened the first of his essays called The American Crisis with "These are the times that try men's souls." On the night of 25 December, Washington crossed the icy Delaware River and at dawn surprised the Hessian garrison at Trenton, capturing about 900 men, then won again at Princeton on 3 January 1777.
1777: Philadelphia and the northern plan
For 1777 the British planned to split the colonies along the Hudson. General John Burgoyne would march south from Canada down Lake Champlain, while Colonel Barry St. Leger led Loyalists and Haudenosaunee (Iroquois) allies east along the Mohawk Valley; they were to meet at Albany. But Howe chose instead to take Philadelphia, the seat of Congress. He shipped his army to the Chesapeake, beat Washington at Brandywine in September and occupied the city, while Congress fled. Taking the rebel capital did not end the rebellion, and it left Burgoyne without support from New York.
Saratoga
St. Leger besieged Fort Stanwix and fought a bloody battle at Oriskany, where Oneida warriors fought beside the Patriots against Mohawk and Seneca allies of Britain, splitting the Haudenosaunee Confederacy. He then retreated. Burgoyne took Fort Ticonderoga but moved slowly through forest, while New England militia defeated a detachment of his army at Bennington. Near Saratoga, an American army under General Horatio Gates, with Benedict Arnold prominent in the fighting, blocked his path in two battles. Surrounded and short of supplies, Burgoyne surrendered about 6,000 men on 17 October 1777.
Worked example: why Saratoga was the turning point
1. The immediate result: an entire British army was lost, and the plan to isolate New England collapsed. 2. The audience abroad: France had secretly supplied the Americans since 1776 but would not risk open war on a losing cause. 3. The proof it needed: Saratoga showed that the Americans could defeat a British army in the field. 4. The decision: in February 1778 France signed a treaty of alliance with the United States, recognising its independence. 5. The widening war: Spain joined France against Britain in 1779, and Britain went to war with the Dutch Republic in 1780. 6. Conclusion: Saratoga turned a colonial rebellion into a global war, forcing Britain to defend the Caribbean, India and its own coasts as well as America.
Valley Forge and a remade army
Washington's army spent the winter of 1777 to 1778 at Valley Forge, outside occupied Philadelphia. Food, clothing and shoes were scarce because of weak supply systems and Congress's lack of money, not because the countryside was empty. Disease, rather than cold alone, did the most damage: about 2,000 soldiers died. In early 1778 Friedrich Wilhelm von Steuben, a former Prussian officer, began drilling a model company that then trained others, giving the army common drill and discipline. The young French noble the Marquis de Lafayette served as a major general. In June 1778 the British left Philadelphia, and at Monmouth the Continentals fought them to a draw in open battle.
The southern strategy
With the north stalemated, Britain turned south, where it expected strong Loyalist support and could recruit enslaved people seeking freedom. British forces took Savannah in December 1778. In May 1780 General Henry Clinton captured Charleston, and General Benjamin Lincoln surrendered more than 5,000 men, the largest American surrender of the war. General Charles Cornwallis then routed Gates at Camden in August 1780. Thousands of enslaved people escaped to British lines. In the backcountry, the war became a savage civil war between Patriot and Loyalist neighbours, while partisans such as Francis Marion harried British posts.
Greene's war of attrition
The tide began to turn in October 1780, when Patriot backcountry militia destroyed a Loyalist force at Kings Mountain. In December General Nathanael Greene took command in the south. Knowing he could not afford to lose his army, he avoided decisive defeat and wore the British down. He split his forces, and in January 1781 Daniel Morgan won a striking victory at Cowpens. At Guilford Courthouse in March 1781, Cornwallis held the field but lost about a quarter of his army. Exhausted, he marched into Virginia, while Greene and local militia reclaimed most of South Carolina and Georgia.
Worked example: how Yorktown was won
1. The British position: in summer 1781 Cornwallis fortified Yorktown, a tobacco port on the York River, expecting the Royal Navy to supply or evacuate him. 2. The naval factor: a French fleet under Admiral de Grasse reached Chesapeake Bay and, in September, drove off a British fleet sent to help. 3. The land factor: Washington and the French general Rochambeau marched their armies from New York to Virginia, joining Lafayette's force. 4. The siege: more than 16,000 allied troops, nearly half of them French, trapped some 8,000 British and German soldiers. 5. The outcome: Cornwallis surrendered on 19 October 1781. 6. Conclusion: victory needed both armies and, above all, French sea power.
The Treaty of Paris, 1783
Yorktown broke Britain's will to continue. Lord North's government fell in March 1782, and the new ministry opened talks. Benjamin Franklin, John Adams and John Jay negotiated for the United States, and the Treaty of Paris was signed on 3 September 1783. Britain recognised American independence, with boundaries running to the Mississippi River in the west, roughly the Great Lakes in the north and Spanish Florida in the south. Americans gained fishing rights off Newfoundland. Congress promised to recommend that states return confiscated Loyalist property, and debts to British creditors were to be honoured. Britain's Native allies were not consulted, though their lands lay within the new borders.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, Yorktown did not end all fighting: British troops held New York until November 1783, and frontier warfare continued. Second, Saratoga mattered diplomatically as much as militarily. Third, most deaths at Valley Forge came from disease, not freezing. Fourth, Greene lost several battles yet succeeded, because his goal was to keep his army alive and exhaust the British. Fifth, capturing cities such as New York and Philadelphia did not defeat the rebellion, because its strength lay in the countryside and the army.
Key takeaways
Britain tried to destroy the Continental Army, hold cities and rally Loyalists, while Washington's aim was to survive. After defeat in New York in 1776, victories at Trenton and Princeton revived the cause. In 1777 Howe took Philadelphia, but Burgoyne's surrender at Saratoga brought France into the war in 1778. Steuben trained the army after Valley Forge. Britain's southern strategy won Savannah, Charleston and Camden, but Kings Mountain, Cowpens and Greene's war of attrition wore it down. French troops and sea power made possible the victory at Yorktown in 1781, and the 1783 Treaty of Paris recognised independence.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Keep the army in the field and outlast Britain rather than win every battle
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Why was the American victory at Saratoga in 1777 so important?
Question 2 of 5
Which statement about Valley Forge in the winter of 1777 to 1778 is accurate?
Question 3 of 5
What was Nathanael Greene's main approach in the southern campaign?
Question 4 of 5
Which factor most directly prevented Cornwallis from escaping Yorktown by sea in 1781?
Question 5 of 5
Which was a term of the Treaty of Paris of 1783?
