US History › Section C · Toward independence › Topic C.7

Identity and the Revolution's limits

The war for independence forced millions of people to choose, or to try not to choose, a side. For Loyalists, enslaved people, Native nations and women, the Revolution's promise of liberty looked very different, and its limits shaped the new nation.

A revolution of many civil wars

The Revolution also set neighbours, families and peoples against one another. Historians cannot count allegiance exactly, and older claims that colonists split into equal thirds are no longer accepted. Many now estimate that roughly a fifth of white colonists were Loyalists, perhaps two-fifths were committed Patriots, and the rest tried to stay neutral or changed sides as armies came and went. Allegiance often depended on local rivalries, religion, trade ties and who seemed likely to win. The middle colonies and the southern backcountry were the most bitterly divided.

Who were the Loyalists?

Loyalists came from every rank. Royal officials and many Anglican clergy stayed loyal out of duty and conviction, and some merchants depended on British trade. Others feared that rebellion would bring mob rule. Local grievances also mattered: tenant farmers in New York's Hudson Valley who resented their Patriot landlords, backcountry settlers at odds with coastal elites, and recent immigrants such as Scottish Highlanders who had sworn loyalty to the king. Many saw themselves as the true defenders of the British constitution. One famous Loyalist was William Franklin, royal governor of New Jersey, who was imprisoned by Patriots and never reconciled with his father, Benjamin.

The price of loyalty

Patriot governments treated open Loyalists as enemies. States required men to swear oaths of allegiance, and those who refused could be fined, jailed, barred from professions or driven out. Confiscation acts allowed states to seize Loyalist land and property, and the 1783 peace treaty only recommended its return. Crowds sometimes tarred and feathered suspected Tories. Tens of thousands of Loyalists served in British provincial units or militias. When the war ended, perhaps 60,000 to 80,000 Loyalists left the United States, along with thousands of enslaved people some of them took with them. The largest share went to Nova Scotia and Quebec, helping create a more English-speaking Canada, while others settled in Britain or the Caribbean.

Patriots and the strain of war

Patriots, also called Whigs, included farmers, artisans, sailors, merchants, lawyers and planters, a broad alliance held together by a common cause. Sustaining it was hard. The army was chronically short of food, clothing and ammunition. Congress could not tax, so it paid its bills largely by printing paper money, the Continental currency. As more was printed, it lost value rapidly; in 1780 Congress officially revalued it at forty paper dollars to one in silver, and it soon became almost worthless. Hence the phrase "not worth a Continental". Soldiers often went unpaid for months.

Black Patriots

Black men fought on the Patriot side from the start, at Lexington and Bunker Hill. In late 1775 Washington and Congress barred new Black recruits, but Washington soon allowed free Black veterans to re-enlist, and manpower shortages later overcame resistance in most northern states. In 1778 Rhode Island raised a regiment that promised freedom to enslaved men who enlisted. Historians estimate that about 5,000 Black soldiers and sailors served the Patriot cause. Enslaved people in Massachusetts also petitioned the legislature for freedom in the 1770s, using the Revolution's own language of natural rights. Some northern states began to end slavery, a change covered in a later topic.

Freedom behind British lines

For many enslaved people the best chance of freedom lay with Britain. After Dunmore's offer of 1775, General Henry Clinton's Philipsburg Proclamation of 1779 promised freedom to any enslaved person of a rebel who escaped to British lines, without Dunmore's demand for military service. Historians estimate that tens of thousands fled, perhaps 20,000 or more, including people held by Washington and Jefferson. Many died of smallpox and typhus in crowded camps, and some were re-enslaved or sold. In 1783 British officers in New York refused to return those who had reached their lines, and about 3,000 Black Loyalists sailed for Nova Scotia. In 1792 about 1,200 of them moved on to Sierra Leone in West Africa.

Worked example: reading Boston King's memoir

Boston King, born into slavery near Charleston, escaped to the British during the war and later published an account of his life in 1798. 1. Identify the source: a memoir written years afterwards by a Black Loyalist who had become a Methodist preacher in Sierra Leone. 2. What he describes: in New York in 1783, rumours spread that people who had escaped slavery would be handed back, and former enslavers came to seize them in the streets. 3. The turning point: British officers issued certificates of freedom, and he sailed for Nova Scotia. 4. Limits of the source: written later, for a religious audience, so we should check its details against other records. 5. Conclusion: for King, the British side, not the Patriot side, meant liberty.

Native nations' war

Most Native nations that took part sided with Britain, judging land-hungry colonists the greater threat. The Haudenosaunee Confederacy split: Mohawk, Seneca, Cayuga and Onondaga warriors largely fought for Britain, while many Oneida and Tuscarora backed the Patriots. The Mohawk leader Joseph Brant, or Thayendanegea, led raids on frontier settlements. In 1779 a Continental expedition under General John Sullivan destroyed some forty Haudenosaunee towns and their crops. Cherokee attacks in 1776 brought devastating retaliation, while the Catawba fought with the Patriots. Whichever side they chose, Native nations lost. The Treaty of Paris ignored them, and Brant and many others resettled in Canada.

Women in the Revolution

Women ran farms and businesses while men were away, nursed the wounded and endured occupation. In March 1776 Abigail Adams urged her husband John to "Remember the Ladies" in the new laws and to curb husbands' unlimited power over wives; he dismissed the idea. In 1780 Esther DeBerdt Reed founded the Ladies Association of Philadelphia, which raised about $300,000 in inflated paper money and sewed shirts for soldiers. Thousands of poorer women followed the army as cooks, laundresses and nurses. A few fought: Deborah Sampson enlisted in disguise as Robert Shurtliff and served from 1782 to 1783. Women gained new public roles, but not the vote or legal equality.

Worked example: whose liberty?

Did the Revolution expand liberty? 1. White male Patriots: they gained self-government and an end to rule from London. 2. Loyalists: many lost property, homes and country. 3. Enslaved people: thousands won freedom, mainly by joining the British; slavery itself survived in the new nation. 4. Native nations: they lost British protection, and their lands now lay within an expanding republic. 5. Women: they took on vital public roles, yet law and politics remained male. 6. Conclusion: the Revolution produced powerful ideals of equality and consent, but their benefits were unevenly shared, and excluded groups would use those same ideals to press their claims.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, colonists did not split into neat thirds; allegiance was fluid, and estimates vary. Second, Loyalists were not all wealthy officials; many were farmers, tenants, immigrants and enslaved people. Third, Black Americans fought on both sides, and far more sought freedom with the British than served the Patriots. Fourth, Native nations were not united: the Haudenosaunee themselves split. Fifth, women's wartime work did not bring political rights: Abigail Adams's appeal was set aside.

Key takeaways

The Revolution was also a set of civil wars. Perhaps a fifth of white colonists were Loyalists, from officials to tenants and immigrants, and they faced oaths, confiscation and, for tens of thousands, exile. Patriots struggled with shortages and collapsing Continental currency. Black Americans served the Patriots, about 5,000 of them, but far more sought freedom behind British lines, and some Black Loyalists went on to Nova Scotia and Sierra Leone. Most Native nations allied with Britain, the Haudenosaunee split, and all lost ground. Women took on new roles, but the Revolution's ideals were not extended to them or to enslaved people.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Loyalists

Colonists who stayed loyal to Britain; perhaps a fifth of white colonists

Also called Tories by their opponents.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which statement about Loyalists is best supported by current scholarship?

Question 2 of 5

Why did many enslaved people flee to British lines during the war?

Question 3 of 5

How did the Haudenosaunee Confederacy respond to the Revolution?

Question 4 of 5

What does Abigail Adams's 1776 appeal to "Remember the Ladies" show?

Question 5 of 5

What happened to the Continental currency during the war?

← Previous topicNext topic →