US History › Section H · Civil War and Reconstruction › Topic H.2
Early mobilization and war
In 1861 both sides expected a short war and a quick victory. By the end of 1862, after battles bloodier than any Americans had imagined, it was clear the struggle would be long, and that its outcome would depend on resources, strategy and the actions of enslaved people themselves.
A war everyone expected to be short
When Lincoln called for 75,000 militia in April 1861, he asked them to serve for only ninety days. Volunteers rushed to enlist on both sides, often in companies raised from a single town. Northerners hoped one decisive blow would end the rebellion; Southerners believed Northern soldiers would not fight hard for a Union that did not threaten their homes. Both sides were wrong. The war would last four years, and the armies of 1861 had to be rebuilt with longer enlistments, then with conscription.
The Union's advantages
On paper, the Union was far stronger. Its states held roughly 22 million people, against about 9 million in the Confederacy, of whom about 3.5 million were enslaved and not trusted with arms. The North produced roughly nine-tenths of the nation's manufactured goods and had about 70% of its railway mileage. It had a navy, an established government and farms that fed its cities and armies throughout the war. These advantages mattered most over time: they could replace losses that the South could not.
The Confederacy's advantages
The Confederacy did not have to conquer the North; it only had to survive until the North gave up. Fighting on the defensive, on home ground, it had shorter supply lines, local knowledge and a supportive white population. The Union, by contrast, had to invade and occupy an area of roughly 750,000 square miles. Many of the most experienced officers, including Robert E. Lee, sided with the South. Confederate leaders also trusted in "King Cotton": they expected Britain and France to intervene to protect their textile industries. That hope failed, largely because Britain had large stocks of cotton and found new supplies in Egypt and India.
Worked example: reading the balance sheet
Question: why did the Union's greater resources not bring a quick victory? 1. Evidence: the North had more than twice the free population and most of the industry and railways. 2. Counter-evidence: the South needed only a stalemate, while the North needed total military success followed by occupation. 3. Mechanism: defenders on interior lines could shift troops by rail and fight from prepared positions, which made attacks costly. 4. Leadership: in the east, cautious Union commanders faced bold Confederate ones. 5. Conclusion: resources decided the war in the long run, but only once the Union was willing to use them fully and for years, and political will in the North held.
The Anaconda Plan and the blockade
General Winfield Scott, the Union's senior officer, proposed a strategy that the press nicknamed the Anaconda Plan. The Union would blockade the Southern coast, cutting off cotton exports and imports of weapons, then seize control of the Mississippi River to split the Confederacy in two, and squeeze until it collapsed. Lincoln proclaimed a blockade in April 1861. At first the navy had too few ships to seal more than 3,000 miles of coast, and fast blockade runners slipped through. As the fleet grew, the blockade tightened, and shortages and inflation spread across the South.
First Bull Run
Under pressure to take the new Confederate capital at Richmond, Union general Irvin McDowell marched his inexperienced army into Virginia. On 21 July 1861, near Manassas Junction on Bull Run creek, about 30 miles from Washington, his attack at first drove the Confederates back. But Thomas J. Jackson's brigade held firm, earning him the name "Stonewall", and Confederate reinforcements arrived by train. The Union retreat became a panicked flight towards the capital, tangled with civilians who had come out to watch. The defeat ended Northern dreams of a ninety-day war; Congress authorised far larger, long-service armies.
The war in the West, 1862
The Union's real progress in 1862 came in the West, where the prize was control of the rivers. In February, Ulysses S. Grant captured Fort Henry and Fort Donelson in Tennessee, opening the Tennessee and Cumberland rivers. On 6 and 7 April, Confederate forces surprised Grant at Shiloh, near Pittsburg Landing, Tennessee. Their commander, Albert Sidney Johnston, was killed, and Union reinforcements drove them back on the second day. The two sides together lost about 23,000 killed, wounded or missing, a shock to both. Meanwhile, Admiral David Farragut's fleet forced its way past the forts below New Orleans, and the South's largest city fell in late April; Memphis followed in June.
Stalemate in the East
In the East, General George B. McClellan built the Army of the Potomac into a disciplined force but was reluctant to risk it, repeatedly overestimating enemy numbers. In spring 1862 he moved it by sea to the Virginia peninsula and advanced slowly towards Richmond. After the Confederate commander was wounded, Robert E. Lee took over what became the Army of Northern Virginia. In the Seven Days Battles, 25 June to 1 July, Lee drove McClellan away from the capital. In late August, Lee defeated another Union army at Second Bull Run, then invaded Maryland, hoping a victory on Northern soil would win foreign recognition.
Worked example: why Antietam mattered
Cause and effect, September 1862. 1. Event: on 17 September, McClellan's army met Lee's at Antietam Creek, near Sharpsburg, Maryland. 2. Scale: about 23,000 men were killed, wounded or missing, making it the bloodiest single day in American history. 3. Military result: a draw on the field, but Lee withdrew to Virginia, ending his invasion; McClellan did not pursue. 4. Political effect: Lincoln used the result to issue the preliminary Emancipation Proclamation on 22 September. 5. Diplomatic effect: Britain and France held back from recognising the Confederacy. 6. Afterwards: Lincoln removed McClellan; his successor, Ambrose Burnside, suffered a heavy defeat at Fredericksburg in December.
Freedom seekers and divided nations
Enslaved people did not wait for Washington. From the war's first weeks, they escaped to Union lines. In May 1861, General Benjamin Butler at Fort Monroe, Virginia, refused to return three men, calling them "contraband of war", and thousands more followed. Their flight drained Confederate labour and pushed Congress to act: in 1862 it abolished slavery in the District of Columbia and the territories, and barred the army from returning freedom seekers. In Indian Territory, the war split the Cherokee, Creek and other nations; the Cherokee leader Stand Watie led Confederate troops, while many Creeks loyal to the Union fled to Kansas under Opothleyahola.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming the Union's resources made victory quick or certain: they mattered only over a long war. Second, thinking the Confederacy needed to conquer the North; it needed only to outlast it. Third, calling Antietam a clear Union victory; it was a tactical draw that became a strategic success. Fourth, ignoring the West, where the Union's most important early gains were made. Fifth, describing emancipation as something done only by Lincoln and Congress, when enslaved people's escapes forced the question from 1861.
Key takeaways
Both sides expected a short war, and First Bull Run in July 1861 ended that hope. The Union had far more people, industry and railways; the Confederacy had the defensive advantage and hoped in vain for European help through King Cotton. The Anaconda Plan aimed to blockade the coast and take the Mississippi. In 1862, Grant won in Tennessee and New Orleans fell, while Lee held Richmond. Antietam, the bloodiest single day, ended Lee's first invasion and led to the preliminary Emancipation Proclamation.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Lincoln's first call for 75,000 troops, April 1861
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Why did the Union's larger population and industry not bring a quick victory in 1861-1862?
Question 2 of 5
What were the two main parts of the Anaconda Plan?
Question 3 of 5
Why did Confederate leaders expect help from Britain and France, and why did it not come?
Question 4 of 5
Which statement best describes the Battle of Antietam?
Question 5 of 5
In May 1861, what did General Benjamin Butler do when three men escaping slavery reached Fort Monroe?
