US History › Section H · Civil War and Reconstruction › Topic H.1
Origins and outbreak of the Civil War
Between November 1860 and June 1861, eleven slave states left the Union and formed a new nation built to protect slavery. Understanding why they went, in their own stated words, is the starting point for understanding the war that followed.
An election that broke the Union
As the previous topic showed, Abraham Lincoln won the presidency in November 1860 with about 40% of the popular vote in a four-way race, taking a clear majority in the Electoral College without a single electoral vote from the slave states. The Republican Party promised to keep slavery out of the western territories, though not to touch it in the states where it already existed. For many white Southern leaders, a president elected entirely by the North on an antislavery platform was a threat they would not accept.
Decades of conflict over slavery
The election lit a fuse that had been burning for forty years. The Missouri crisis of 1819-1821, the war with Mexico, the Compromise of 1850 and the Kansas-Nebraska Act of 1854 all turned on one question: would slavery spread into the West? Popular sovereignty, the idea that settlers should decide, produced violence in Kansas rather than peace. The Fugitive Slave Act angered many Northerners, and the Dred Scott decision of 1857 seemed to open every territory to slaveholders. Each crisis hardened opinion.
The Lower South secedes
South Carolina moved first. On 20 December 1860, a state convention voted unanimously to leave the Union. Within about six weeks, six more states followed: Mississippi, Florida, Alabama, Georgia, Louisiana and Texas, the last on 1 February 1861. Taken together, the people of these seven states were nearly half enslaved in 1860. Elsewhere the conventions were often divided, with some delegates urging delay. Still, by the time Lincoln took office, seven states claimed to have left.
In their own words
Four seceding states, South Carolina, Mississippi, Georgia and Texas, published formal declarations explaining their decision. All four put slavery at the centre. South Carolina complained that Northern states had refused to return people who escaped from slavery, and that a president hostile to slavery had been elected. Georgia's declaration surveyed decades of conflict over slavery's expansion. Texas defended slavery as essential to its economy and its racial order. Near its start, Mississippi's declaration stated, "Our position is thoroughly identified with the institution of slavery". Historians treat these documents as the clearest evidence of why secession happened.
Worked example: reading a secession declaration
Source: Mississippi's declaration of causes, issued early in 1861. 1. Author and purpose: the state convention that voted for secession, writing to justify its act to the public at home and abroad. 2. Content: it identifies the state's interests with slavery and calls slavery the greatest material interest of the world. 3. Context: Mississippi had more enslaved than free people in 1860, so slavery was the base of its wealth and social order. 4. What is missing: tariffs and abstract constitutional theory play little part; the grievances concern slavery. 5. Conclusion: the writers themselves made slavery the reason for leaving, which is strong evidence because it comes from the secessionists, not their opponents.
States' rights and the defence of slavery
Secessionists also claimed a legal right to leave. In their compact theory, the states had created the Union and kept the sovereignty to withdraw from it. But historians point out that states' rights was the means, not the goal. The declarations attacked Northern states for using their own rights, through personal liberty laws that obstructed the return of freedom seekers. Southern leaders had welcomed strong federal power when it served slavery, as in the Fugitive Slave Act and the Dred Scott decision. The later "Lost Cause" story, which played slavery down, was written mainly after the war.
Founding the Confederacy
In February 1861, delegates from the seven states met in Montgomery, Alabama, and created the Confederate States of America. They chose Jefferson Davis of Mississippi as president and Alexander Stephens of Georgia as vice president. The Confederate Constitution copied much of the 1787 document, but it named and protected slavery outright: no law could impair property in enslaved people, and slaveholders could take them into any Confederate territory. It also gave the president a single six-year term. In a speech in Savannah in March 1861, Stephens said the new government rested on the belief that Black people were naturally inferior and that slavery was their proper condition.
Last attempts at compromise
Senator John J. Crittenden of Kentucky proposed constitutional amendments in December 1860 that would extend the Missouri Compromise line, 36°30′, to the Pacific, protecting slavery south of it, and bar Congress from abolishing slavery where it existed. Lincoln and most Republicans rejected the plan because it would allow slavery to expand, and it failed in the Senate. In early March 1861, Congress passed the Corwin Amendment, which would have shielded slavery in the states from federal interference. Only a few states ratified it, and no seceded state returned.
Fort Sumter
In his inaugural address on 4 March 1861, Lincoln said he would not interfere with slavery where it existed, but declared the Union perpetual and secession legally void. He promised to hold federal property. Most forts in the seceded states had already been seized; Fort Sumter, in the harbour of Charleston, still held a garrison of fewer than a hundred men under Major Robert Anderson, and its food was running out. Lincoln announced that he would send supplies only, leaving the choice of war to the Confederacy. On 12 April 1861, Confederate batteries opened fire. Anderson surrendered the next day; no one was killed in the bombardment itself.
Worked example: from Fort Sumter to a wider war
Cause and effect, April to June 1861. 1. Cause: the attack on Fort Sumter. 2. Effect in the North: on 15 April, Lincoln called for 75,000 militia to put down the rebellion, and Northern opinion rallied to the Union. 3. Effect in the Upper South: Virginia's convention voted to secede on 17 April, and Arkansas, North Carolina and Tennessee followed between May and early June, refusing to supply troops against fellow slave states. 4. Limits: the slave states of Delaware, Maryland, Kentucky and Missouri stayed in the Union, and the western counties of Virginia broke away to become West Virginia in 1863. 5. Further effect: leaders of the Cherokee, Chickasaw, Choctaw, Creek and Seminole nations, many of them slaveholders, signed treaties with the Confederacy, although the Cherokee, Creek and Seminole were deeply divided.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, treating states' rights as a cause separate from slavery: the seceding states said the right they were defending was the right to hold people in slavery. Second, thinking Lincoln was elected promising to abolish slavery everywhere; he pledged only to stop its spread. Third, assuming all eleven states left together: seven went after the election and four only after Fort Sumter. Fourth, counting the border states as Confederate. Fifth, forgetting that about four million enslaved people were not consulted, and that their freedom was what the crisis was about.
Key takeaways
Lincoln's election in 1860 on a platform of stopping slavery's expansion triggered secession. Seven Lower South states left between December 1860 and February 1861, and their own declarations named slavery as the cause. The Confederate Constitution, written at Montgomery, explicitly protected slavery. The Crittenden plan and the Corwin Amendment failed to reunite the nation. Confederates fired on Fort Sumter on 12 April 1861; Lincoln's call for troops drove four Upper South states out, while four border slave states stayed loyal.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Lincoln won with about 40% of the popular vote and no electoral votes from slave states
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What did the declarations of causes issued by South Carolina, Mississippi, Georgia and Texas give as the central reason for secession?
Question 2 of 5
Which states left the Union only after the attack on Fort Sumter and Lincoln's call for troops?
Question 3 of 5
Why did Lincoln and most Republicans reject the Crittenden Compromise?
Question 4 of 5
How did the Confederate Constitution differ most clearly from the 1787 US Constitution?
Question 5 of 5
A student says, "The South seceded over states' rights, not slavery." Which piece of evidence best challenges this claim?
