US History › Section F · Westward expansion and the cotton South › Topic F.9
Filibusters and the push for new slave states
Even after the Mexican Cession, many slaveholders wanted more land for slavery, and they looked south: to Cuba, Mexico and Central America. When diplomacy failed, private armies called filibusters tried to seize territory by force, and the attempts widened the gulf between North and South.
Why the South looked south
By the early 1850s, slaveholders saw that the remaining western territories were mostly too dry or too cold for plantation crops, and California had entered as a free state. Every new free state threatened the South's position in the Senate. Southern expansionists therefore dreamed of a slave empire around the Gulf of Mexico and the Caribbean, where sugar and cotton grew well. Cuba, Mexico's northern states and Central America all appeared on their maps. Some Democratic leaders in Washington shared these hopes, and the 1850s became the high point of efforts to expand slavery beyond the existing borders.
What a filibuster was
In the 1850s the word filibuster meant a private adventurer who raised an army to invade a country at peace with the United States, usually hoping to take over its government or bring it into the Union. Such expeditions broke the Neutrality Act of 1818, which banned organising military expeditions on American soil against friendly nations. Federal officials sometimes stopped them, but many slipped out of ports such as New Orleans and San Francisco. When leaders were put on trial, juries in the South and West often refused to convict. Filibusters were celebrated in newspapers, songs and plays as heroes of manly courage.
Worked example: why Cuba?
1. Economy: Spanish Cuba was the world's leading sugar producer, worked by several hundred thousand enslaved people. 2. Politics: annexed, it could form one or more slave states and add southern senators. 3. Fear: slaveholders worried that Britain, which had abolished slavery in its colonies in the 1830s, would press Spain to free Cuba's enslaved people, creating a second Haiti just off the coast. 4. Opportunity: Spain was weak, and some wealthy Cuban creoles favoured annexation to protect slavery from Spanish reform. 5. Conclusion: for proslavery expansionists, Cuba combined profit, political power and security, which explains their persistence.
Narciso López and the Cuban expeditions
Narciso López, a Venezuelan-born former officer in the Spanish army, wanted to free Cuba from Spain and won backing from southern expansionists, including former Mississippi governor John Quitman. After one expedition was stopped by federal authorities, López landed briefly in Cuba in 1850 before retreating. In August 1851 he sailed from New Orleans with a few hundred men, many of them Americans. The hoped-for popular uprising never came. Spanish forces captured the invaders; López was publicly executed in Havana and about fifty Americans were shot. The banner López carried later became Cuba's national flag.
The Ostend Manifesto
President Franklin Pierce, elected in 1852, promised not to be held back by "timid forebodings" about expansion and tried to buy Cuba. In October 1854 three American diplomats in Europe, James Buchanan, John Mason and Pierre Soulé, met at Ostend in Belgium and sent a confidential report to Washington. It urged that the United States offer Spain a large sum for Cuba and argued that if Spain refused, the United States would be justified in seizing the island. The report soon leaked. Northern outrage forced Pierce's secretary of state to disown it, and the plan collapsed.
Worked example: reading the Ostend Manifesto
1. Authors: three Democratic diplomats, two of them southerners and all supporters of expansion. 2. Audience: the secretary of state, in a private message not meant for the public. 3. Argument: Cuba was vital to American security, and taking it by force would be justified if Spain would not sell. 4. Timing: details leaked late in 1854, the year of the Kansas-Nebraska Act, when northern anger at the Slave Power was already high. 5. Reception: northerners saw a slaveholders' plot and Europeans saw a threat of aggression. 6. Conclusion: a document meant to advance expansion instead hardened northern resistance to it.
William Walker in Nicaragua
William Walker, a Tennessee-born journalist and lawyer, first invaded Baja California and Sonora in 1853 and declared a republic, but Mexican forces drove him out. In 1855 one faction in a Nicaraguan civil war invited him in with a small band of American fighters. Walker seized control, had himself declared president in 1856, and won brief diplomatic recognition from the Pierce administration. Seeking southern support, he legalised slavery in Nicaragua, which had abolished it decades earlier. Nicaragua mattered because its rivers and lake offered a short route between the Atlantic and Pacific, used by travellers heading to California.
Walker's downfall
Walker's rule united his enemies. He seized the property of Cornelius Vanderbilt's transit company, which carried passengers across Nicaragua, and Vanderbilt helped arm his opponents. Costa Rica led an alliance of Central American states against him; Costa Ricans still honour Juan Santamaría, a young soldier killed in an 1856 battle against Walker's forces. Walker surrendered to the US Navy in 1857 and returned home to a hero's welcome in parts of the South. He tried again, and in 1860 the British navy captured him and handed him to Honduras, where he was executed by firing squad.
Other routes to expansion
Not all expansion was private. In 1853 the Gadsden Purchase bought a strip of northern Mexico, now southern Arizona and New Mexico, for $10 million, partly for a southern railroad route to the Pacific. Some southern radicals also campaigned to reopen the African slave trade, banned since 1808, to lower the price of enslaved labour. Smugglers defied the law: in 1858 the ship Wanderer landed about four hundred captive Africans in Georgia, and in 1860 the Clotilda brought more than one hundred to Alabama, the last known slave ship to reach the United States.
Common mistakes to avoid
Do not confuse the 1850s meaning of filibuster, a private invader, with the later Senate tactic of talking to delay a vote. Do not assume filibusters acted for the United States government; their expeditions were illegal, even when officials sympathised. Do not overlook the perspectives of Cubans and Central Americans, who fought these invasions and remember them today. And remember that the Ostend Manifesto was a confidential report, never adopted as official policy.
Key takeaways
In the 1850s proslavery expansionists sought new slave territory in the Caribbean and Central America. Filibusters, private invaders breaking the Neutrality Act of 1818, led the way. Narciso López's Cuban expeditions ended with his execution in 1851. The leaked Ostend Manifesto of 1854 argued for seizing Cuba if Spain would not sell and provoked northern outrage. William Walker ruled Nicaragua briefly, legalised slavery, and was defeated by a Central American alliance. These schemes deepened northern fears of a Slave Power.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A private adventurer who invaded a country at peace with the United States
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
In the 1850s, what was a filibuster?
Question 2 of 5
Why did many slaveholders want to annex Cuba?
Question 3 of 5
What did the Ostend Manifesto argue?
Question 4 of 5
What did William Walker do in Nicaragua in 1856 to win support in the American South?
Question 5 of 5
Which statement about these expansion schemes is accurate?
