US History › Section G · Reform and a decade of crisis › Topic G.1
Religious revival and individualism
Between about 1800 and 1850, a wave of Protestant revivals and a small circle of New England thinkers both taught Americans that the individual could change their own life. That belief powered almost every reform movement of the age.
A fast-changing country looks inward
The United States of the early 1800s was changing at speed. Its population grew from about 5 million in 1800 to about 17 million in 1840, settlers poured west, canals and markets reached remote farms, and most white men gained the vote. Rapid change brought anxiety as well as opportunity. Two answers to it stand out. The Second Great Awakening offered personal salvation through religious conversion. Transcendentalism offered spiritual insight through the self and nature. Both put the individual at the centre, and both fed the reform movements covered in the rest of this section.
The Second Great Awakening
The Second Great Awakening was a wave of evangelical Protestant revivals that ran from about the 1790s to the 1840s. (The First Great Awakening had swept the colonies in the 1730s and 1740s.) It began on the frontier of Kentucky and Tennessee, where outdoor camp meetings lasted for days. At Cane Ridge, Kentucky, in 1801, an estimated 10,000 or more people gathered to hear preachers. Methodists and Baptists grew fastest, helped by travelling ministers called circuit riders who served scattered settlements. Revival preaching was emotional and direct: sinners were urged to feel their guilt, repent and be born again, committing to a new, righteous life.
Free will, democracy and the millennium
Older Calvinist teaching held predestination: God had already chosen who would be saved, and nothing a person did could change it. Revival preachers stressed instead that anyone could choose salvation. Historians often link this to Jacksonian democracy, since both trusted the ordinary person's judgement and both distrusted elites. Many Methodist and Baptist preachers had no college training, and in many congregations women made up most of the new members. Many converts also embraced millennialism, the belief that a thousand-year reign of Christ on earth was coming. Some expected to help prepare the world for it, which turned personal faith into a duty to improve society.
Charles Finney and the burned-over district
Charles Grandison Finney, a lawyer who converted in 1821 and became a Presbyterian preacher, was the best-known revivalist of the age. His new measures included meetings held night after night, an anxious bench where people close to conversion sat before the crowd, and women praying aloud in mixed gatherings. His greatest success came in Rochester, New York, in 1830 and 1831, a boom town on the Erie Canal. Western New York saw so many revivals that it became known as the burned-over district. Finney later led Oberlin College in Ohio, one of the first colleges to admit women and Black students.
Faith, slavery and Black churches
Many enslaved people converted. Slaveholders often promoted a Christianity that stressed obedience, but enslaved people built their own faith, sometimes meeting in secret, and drew hope from the Exodus story of a people freed from bondage. Free Black Christians in the North formed their own churches after facing discrimination in white congregations. Richard Allen, a formerly enslaved Methodist preacher in Philadelphia, founded the African Methodist Episcopal Church as an independent denomination in 1816. Slavery divided white churches too: the Methodists split into northern and southern churches in 1844, and Baptists followed in 1845.
From revival to reform
Converts organised. A network of voluntary societies, sometimes called the benevolent empire, spread the evangelical message: the American Bible Society (1816), the American Sunday School Union (1824) and the American Tract Society (1825). Historians estimate that the share of Americans who belonged to a church roughly doubled between the Revolution and 1850. Many believers concluded that a saved soul should help perfect society. That impulse fed campaigns against drinking, for public schools, led by Horace Mann, and for better care of the mentally ill, led by Dorothea Dix, as well as abolition and women's rights.
Worked example: why revivals blazed in western New York
Explain why the burned-over district produced so many revivals. 1. Economic cause: the Erie Canal, finished in 1825, turned quiet farm country into a busy commercial corridor almost overnight. 2. Social effect: newcomers, wage workers and new businesses loosened old ties of family and village, leaving many people unsettled. 3. Religious fit: revival preaching promised that each person could take charge of their own salvation, which matched a society where people were making their own way. 4. Outcome: in historian Paul Johnson's influential reading of Rochester, the new middle class embraced revivals and the self-discipline they encouraged, such as sobriety and hard work. 5. Check: the pattern fits Rochester, Finney's most famous success.
Transcendentalism
Transcendentalism was a philosophical and literary movement centred in Concord and Boston, Massachusetts, from the 1830s. Its members believed that every person could grasp spiritual truth directly, through intuition, beyond what the senses and logic reveal, and that nature was a place to meet the divine. Ralph Waldo Emerson, a Unitarian minister who left the pulpit in 1832, became its leading voice. His essay "Nature" appeared in 1836 and "Self-Reliance" in 1841. Drawing on European Romanticism, Emerson urged readers to trust their own minds rather than tradition or the crowd. Alexis de Tocqueville, a French visitor, similarly warned of a tyranny of the majority in democratic America.
Thoreau, Fuller, Whitman and the critics
Henry David Thoreau lived in a cabin by Walden Pond for about two years and described the experiment in Walden (1854). After a night in jail for refusing a tax, in protest at slavery and the war with Mexico, he wrote the 1849 essay later known as "Civil Disobedience", which influenced Gandhi and Martin Luther King Jr. Margaret Fuller edited the transcendentalist journal The Dial and argued for women's equality in Woman in the Nineteenth Century (1845). Walt Whitman celebrated the self in Leaves of Grass (1855). Critics pushed back: Herman Melville's Moby-Dick (1851) is often read as a warning about where obsessive self-will can lead.
Worked example: reading Emerson as a source
In "Self-Reliance" (1841), Emerson wrote: "Whoso would be a man, must be a nonconformist." 1. Source: a published essay by an educated Boston writer, aimed at literate middle-class readers. 2. Meaning: a person of real character follows their own conscience, not the crowd. 3. Context: Jacksonian America celebrated majority opinion and mass politics, which Emerson saw as pressure to conform. 4. Comparison: like revivalists, Emerson trusted the individual, but he looked to inner insight rather than churches or ministers. 5. Limits: the essay speaks of men and reflects the views of a small elite, not most Americans.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, do not confuse the two awakenings: the first came in the 1730s and 1740s, the second from about the 1790s. Second, predestination was the older Calvinist idea that revivalists challenged, not the idea they promoted. Third, transcendentalism was a small intellectual movement, not a church or a mass revival. Fourth, religion did not speak with one voice on slavery: evangelicals inspired abolitionists, but many southern churches defended slavery, and major denominations split over it. Fifth, Thoreau's essay was first titled "Resistance to Civil Government"; "Civil Disobedience" is its later name.
Key takeaways
The Second Great Awakening, from about the 1790s to the 1840s, spread through camp meetings and circuit riders and taught that anyone could choose salvation, rejecting predestination. Charles Finney's revivals made western New York the burned-over district. Black Americans shaped their own Christianity, and Richard Allen founded the AME Church in 1816. Voluntary societies and millennial hopes turned faith into reform. Transcendentalists such as Emerson, Thoreau and Fuller sought truth through intuition and nature and prized nonconformity.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A wave of evangelical Protestant revivals from about the 1790s to the 1840s
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which teaching most clearly separated Second Great Awakening preachers from older Calvinist ministers?
Question 2 of 5
Why did western New York become known as the burned-over district?
Question 3 of 5
What did Richard Allen found as an independent denomination in 1816?
Question 4 of 5
Which statement best describes transcendentalism?
Question 5 of 5
Thoreau spent a night in jail for refusing to pay a tax. What was he protesting against?
