US History › Section J · Cities and Gilded Age politics › Topic J.4
Political corruption after the Civil War
After the Civil War, closely balanced parties, loyal voters and fast-growing fortunes produced a politics full of scandal. Mark Twain called the era gilded: gold on the surface, cheaper metal underneath.
A gilded surface
In 1873 Mark Twain and Charles Dudley Warner published The Gilded Age: A Tale of Today, a satirical novel about speculators and bribe-taking politicians in Washington. Something gilded has only a thin coat of gold over base metal, and the title captured how dazzling growth covered poverty, inequality and corruption. Historians later used the phrase for the whole period from the 1870s to about 1900. The label is useful but loaded: it suggests the era's politics were only a show, a view that historians now question, as this topic explains.
A politics of stalemate
National politics between 1876 and 1896 were unusually close. Republicans were strongest in the Northeast and Midwest, and Democrats dominated the South, called the Solid South, along with many Northern cities. No president elected from 1876 to 1892 won a majority of the popular vote, and two of them, Hayes and Benjamin Harrison, lost the popular vote but won in the Electoral College. Control of Congress was usually divided: one party held the presidency and both houses for only a few brief stretches. With every election a gamble, parties avoided bold programmes and rewarded loyal workers with government jobs.
Loyal voters and the bloody shirt
Voters were not apathetic. Presidential turnout often reached about 80% of eligible men, with torchlight parades, picnics and fiercely partisan newspapers. Many historians argue that party loyalty followed religion, ethnicity, region and memories of the war more than economic policy. Republicans waved the bloody shirt, reminding Northern voters that Democrats had led secession. Union veterans, organised in the Grand Army of the Republic, mostly voted Republican, and Congress repeatedly expanded Civil War pensions, most generously under Republican control, until, by the early 1890s, they took more than a third of federal spending. Democrats attacked Republican scandals and federal power.
Scandals in Washington
The previous section described Crédit Mobilier, the railway construction fraud exposed in 1872 that involved members of Congress, and the Whiskey Ring of tax fraud uncovered in 1875. Vice President Schuyler Colfax was among those tied to Crédit Mobilier. In 1873, in the so-called Salary Grab, Congress raised its own pay by half and made the raise retroactive for two years; public anger forced a repeal the next year. In 1876 the House impeached Secretary of War William Belknap for taking kickbacks from a trading post on the frontier; he resigned, and the Senate failed to convict him.
Business and influence
Corruption flourished where public power met private money. State legislatures, not voters, chose United States senators until 1913, so railways and other corporations could win a Senate seat by influencing a few dozen legislators. Railways gave free passes to lawmakers and judges, and lobbyists offered cash, stock and favours. Parties paid for campaigns partly by assessing their own officeholders, who had to return a share of their salaries, and partly with gifts from business. Many Americans believed in laissez-faire, the idea that government should leave the economy alone, which made business influence seem normal.
The Tweed Ring
The most notorious urban corruption was in New York City, where William M. Tweed led Tammany Hall, the Democratic machine described in the previous topic. In the late 1860s, Tweed and his allies controlled the city and county governments and stole public money through padded bills. A new county courthouse cost around $13 million, much of it fraudulent. Estimates of the ring's total theft range from about $30 million to $200 million. In 1871 the New York Times published leaked accounts, and Thomas Nast's cartoons in Harper's Weekly ridiculed the ring. Tweed was convicted in 1873, escaped to Spain, was returned and died in jail in 1878.
Worked example: reading a Nast cartoon
In November 1871, Nast's cartoon The Tammany Tiger Loose showed a tiger mauling a woman representing the republic in a Roman arena, while Tweed watched as emperor. 1. Creator and venue: Nast, a German-born artist, drew for Harper's Weekly, a Republican-leaning magazine. 2. Message: the Tammany machine was devouring self-government. 3. Technique: the tiger, a symbol Tammany later adopted itself, made the ring look savage. 4. Bias: Nast often drew Irish Catholic immigrants, Tammany's voters, as ape-like brutes. 5. Conclusion: the cartoon is strong evidence of anti-Tweed opinion, and also of anti-Irish prejudice among Protestant reformers.
1876 sets the tone
The previous section covered the disputed election of 1876 and the Compromise of 1877. Its lessons for Gilded Age politics were clear. Both parties nominated reformers: the Republican Rutherford B. Hayes, untouched by scandal, and the Democrat Samuel Tilden, who had helped prosecute the Tweed Ring. Democrats in the South used open intimidation by groups such as the Red Shirts, and both sides were accused of fraud. Hayes entered office by an electoral commission's party-line vote, and Democrats mocked him as "His Fraudulency", weakening his authority from the start.
Worked example: a do-nothing government?
Older textbooks describe Gilded Age government as idle and corrupt. Is that fair? 1. Evidence for: presidents were weak, Congress passed few major laws, and patronage and bribery were common. 2. Evidence against: the federal government ran a vast pension system, set tariffs that shaped the economy, began civil service reform in 1883, and created the first federal regulatory commission in 1887. 3. States regulated railways and built schools and asylums. 4. Limits: Washington offered almost nothing to the jobless and abandoned Black Southerners' civil rights. 5. Conclusion: historians argue that government was more active than its reputation, but narrow in whom it helped.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming voters did not care; turnout was higher than in any recent presidential election. Second, thinking one party dominated; elections were close and Congress was usually divided. Third, treating Tweed as a national officeholder; his power was in New York City and State. Fourth, believing senators were elected by voters in this period; state legislatures chose them until 1913. Fifth, accepting the do-nothing label uncritically; the government acted on pensions, tariffs, civil service and railways.
Key takeaways
Twain and Warner's The Gilded Age (1873) named an era of glittering growth over deep corruption. From 1876 to 1896, elections were close, Congress was usually divided, and presidents were weak. Voters were intensely loyal, turnout was about 80%, and Republicans waved the bloody shirt. Scandals included Crédit Mobilier, the Whiskey Ring, the Salary Grab and the Belknap affair. Senators chosen by legislatures and party assessments invited business influence. Tweed's ring looted New York until the press and Nast exposed it. Historians now see government as more active than its reputation.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Satirical novel by Mark Twain and Charles Dudley Warner that named the era
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What did the title The Gilded Age suggest about the United States in the 1870s?
Question 2 of 5
Which feature best describes national politics from 1876 to 1896?
Question 3 of 5
Why was the Senate especially open to corporate influence in this period?
Question 4 of 5
A student uses Thomas Nast's Tammany Tiger cartoon (1871) as evidence. What should she also notice?
Question 5 of 5
Which piece of evidence most challenges the view of Gilded Age government as do-nothing?
