US History › Section J · Cities and Gilded Age politics › Topic J.5
Patronage, tariffs, and the money question
Three issues dominated national politics in the Gilded Age: who should get government jobs, how high tariffs should be, and whether the dollar should rest on gold alone or on silver too. Each one decided who gained and who paid.
Three questions that divided the nation
With elections so close, national politics turned on a few repeated questions. The first was patronage: should government jobs reward party workers, or go to qualified people chosen by examination? The second was the tariff, the tax on imported goods, which protected some industries and raised prices for consumers. The third was money: should the currency be backed by gold alone, or should silver be coined freely to expand the money supply? Each question pitted regions, classes and industries against one another, and each shaped the farmers' revolt that followed.
Spoils versus merit
The spoils system gave government jobs to a winning party's supporters. An earlier topic showed Andrew Jackson defending this rotation in office in the 1820s and 1830s. By the early 1880s more than 100,000 federal posts, most of them in the post office, were filled this way, and officeholders had to pay assessments to their party. New presidents spent months besieged by office-seekers. Reformers, many of them educated Northeastern professionals, wanted a civil service, in which permanent employees would be hired by competitive examination and protected from dismissal for political reasons.
Stalwarts, Half-Breeds and Hayes
Republicans split over patronage. The Stalwarts, led by Senator Roscoe Conkling of New York, defended the spoils system and had backed Ulysses S. Grant. The Half-Breeds, a mocking name for followers of James G. Blaine of Maine, were more open to moderate reform. President Hayes ordered in 1877 that federal officers should not manage party campaigns, and in 1878 he removed Chester A. Arthur, a Conkling ally, as head of the New York Custom House, the richest source of patronage in the country. Conkling's faction never forgave Hayes, who had already pledged to serve only one term.
An assassin's bullet
In 1880 the Republican convention deadlocked between Grant and Blaine and chose a compromise candidate, James A. Garfield of Ohio, with Arthur as his running mate. Garfield narrowly beat the Democrat Winfield Scott Hancock. On 2 July 1881, Charles Guiteau, a mentally unstable man who had sought a diplomatic post in Paris, shot Garfield at a Washington railway station and reportedly declared himself a Stalwart. Garfield died on 19 September, most probably from infections his doctors caused by probing the wound with unwashed hands. Guiteau was hanged in 1882. Many Americans blamed the spoils system for the murder.
The Pendleton Act
Arthur surprised critics by backing reform. In 1883 he signed the Pendleton Civil Service Act, which created a Civil Service Commission and required competitive examinations for about 10% of federal jobs. It also banned forcing federal employees to give money to parties. Later presidents could extend the classified list, and they did, often to protect their own appointees before leaving office. Parties now relied more on business donations. In 1884 reform-minded Republicans called Mugwumps refused to back Blaine, whom they considered corrupt, and helped the Democrat Grover Cleveland win narrowly.
The tariff debate
The tariff and taxes on alcohol and tobacco supplied most federal revenue, and in the 1880s they produced large surpluses. Republicans defended high protective tariffs as shields for American industry and wages. Democrats, strong among Southern farmers, called them a tax on consumers. Arthur's tariff commission recommended deep cuts, but the Tariff of 1883 lowered rates only slightly. Cleveland devoted his entire annual message of 1887 to reducing tariffs. In 1888 he won the popular vote but lost the Electoral College to Benjamin Harrison. The McKinley Tariff of 1890 raised average rates to about 50%, and voters punished Republicans in that year's elections.
Worked example: who pays for a tariff?
Consider hypothetical woollen blankets in 1890. 1. A British blanket can be landed in New York for $4.00; an American mill needs $4.80 to make one at a profit. 2. Without a tariff, buyers choose the cheaper British blanket. 3. A 40% tariff adds $1.60, so the import now costs $5.60. 4. The American mill can sell at $5.50, profit, and keep its workers employed. 5. The buyer now pays $1.50 more than the free-trade price. 6. A Kansas farmer gains nothing, because wheat sold abroad gets the world price. 7. Conclusion: protection helped manufacturers and some workers, while farmers paid higher prices without any protection of their own.
Greenbacks, gold and silver
During the Civil War the Union printed paper dollars called greenbacks, not backed by gold. After the war, creditors and bankers wanted sound money. The Coinage Act of 1873 stopped the minting of silver dollars, and from 1879 the Treasury exchanged greenbacks for gold, putting the dollar on a gold basis. As huge Western silver strikes later helped drive silver's price down, silver supporters called the 1873 act the "Crime of '73". They demanded free silver, unlimited coinage at 16 ounces of silver to 1 of gold. The Bland-Allison Act of 1878, passed over Hayes's veto, and the Sherman Silver Purchase Act of 1890 required limited silver purchases.
Worked example: deflation and debt
Why did the money question matter so much to farmers? 1. The money supply grew more slowly than the economy, so prices fell for much of the period from the 1870s to the mid-1890s. 2. Suppose a farmer borrowed $1,000 when wheat sold at $1.00 a bushel, so the debt equalled 1,000 bushels. 3. If wheat fell to 60 cents, repaying the same $1,000 would take about 1,667 bushels, ignoring interest. 4. Lenders, by contrast, were repaid in dollars that bought more than before. 5. Conclusion: debtors favoured silver because more money would raise prices, while creditors and many wage earners feared inflation and defended gold.
Railways, trusts and voting rights
In the Wabash case of 1886, the Supreme Court ruled that states could not regulate railway rates for traffic crossing state lines. Congress responded with the Interstate Commerce Act of 1887, which required railway rates to be reasonable and banned secret rebates, but its commission lacked enforcement power and the courts narrowed it. The Sherman Antitrust Act of 1890 outlawed combinations in restraint of trade, yet it was rarely enforced against companies in its first decade. In 1890 Republicans also proposed the Lodge bill to let federal officials supervise elections to protect Black voters, but it passed the House and died in the Senate.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, saying the Pendleton Act ended patronage; it covered only about 10% of federal jobs at first. Second, confusing the factions: Conkling led the Stalwarts and Blaine the Half-Breeds, while the Mugwumps left the party in 1884. Third, assuming tariffs helped farmers; crops sold abroad got no protection. Fourth, thinking free silver meant free money; it meant unlimited coinage of silver at 16 to 1. Fifth, believing the Interstate Commerce and Sherman Antitrust Acts were strongly enforced at first; both were weak.
Key takeaways
The spoils system rewarded party workers with jobs, and reformers wanted a merit-based civil service. Stalwarts under Conkling clashed with Half-Breeds under Blaine. Garfield's assassination in 1881 led to the Pendleton Act of 1883, which began competitive examinations for about 10% of federal jobs. Republicans defended protective tariffs, culminating in the McKinley Tariff of 1890, while Democrats called them a tax on consumers. Falling prices under the gold standard hurt debtors, who demanded free silver at 16 to 1. The Interstate Commerce Act (1887) and Sherman Antitrust Act (1890) began federal regulation, but weakly.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Giving government jobs to the winning party's supporters
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What did the Pendleton Act of 1883 do?
Question 2 of 5
Which event did most to push Congress to pass civil service reform?
Question 3 of 5
In the blanket example, a $4.00 import faces a 40% tariff. What does the import now cost?
Question 4 of 5
Why did indebted farmers favour the free coinage of silver?
Question 5 of 5
Why did the tariff give little help to wheat farmers in Kansas?
