US History › Section K · Progressives and empire › Topic K.2
Progressivism at the grassroots
Before Washington took up reform, Progressives changed how Americans voted, how cities were run and how workers and children were treated, one town and one state at a time. Many of those changes still shape local government today.
Reform from below
Progressivism grew from the ground up. Muckrakers exposed a problem, citizens formed a league or committee, and reformers pressed city councils and state legislatures for laws. Women's clubs, churches, settlement workers, unions and business groups all took part. Until Theodore Roosevelt became president in 1901, the federal government did comparatively little to regulate business or protect workers. States were where most experiments happened, and successful ones spread as reformers copied each other.
Giving voters more direct power
Reformers believed bosses and corporate lobbies had captured government. The direct primary let party members, not conventions controlled by bosses, choose candidates; Wisconsin passed the first broad statewide primary law in 1903. The initiative let citizens petition to put a proposed law on the ballot, and the referendum let them vote on laws already passed; South Dakota adopted both in 1898 and Oregon followed in 1902. The recall let voters, after a petition, remove an official in a special election before the term ended. The Seventeenth Amendment, ratified in 1913, ended the choice of US senators by state legislatures.
Remaking city government
Cities were the front line against machine politics. In September 1900 a hurricane struck Galveston, Texas, killing an estimated 6,000 to 12,000 people, the deadliest natural disaster in US history. The old council could not cope, and in 1901 the city adopted government by a small elected commission, each member running one department. The commission plan spread quickly, though most cities later dropped it. More lasting was the council-manager plan, tried in Staunton, Virginia, in 1908, in which an elected council hires a professional manager to run daily operations.
Worked example: who gained from city reform?
Question: did reformed city government make cities more democratic? 1. Change: many reformed cities replaced ward elections with at-large, nonpartisan contests for a few seats. 2. Intended effect: candidates now had to appeal to the whole city, which weakened ward bosses who traded favours for votes. 3. Side effect: city-wide campaigns cost more, so business and professional candidates won more often, while immigrant and working-class neighbourhoods lost their own representatives. 4. Evidence: the historian Samuel P. Hays argued in the 1960s that such reforms shifted power towards business elites. 5. Conclusion: the reforms reduced graft and often improved services, but they also narrowed whose voices counted.
Experts in office and on the shop floor
Robert La Follette, governor of Wisconsin from 1901 to 1906, made his state a model. Under the Wisconsin Idea, university experts and a legislative reference library helped draft laws, and Wisconsin passed the direct primary, railway regulation and civil service reform. Later Wisconsin governments added workers' compensation in 1911. La Follette served as a US senator from 1906 to 1925. In industry, Frederick Winslow Taylor's The Principles of Scientific Management (1911) promised efficiency through time-and-motion studies, with managers setting every step of the job. Many workers resented losing control over their craft, and some struck against Taylor's methods.
Settlement houses and child labour
Jane Addams and Ellen Gates Starr opened Hull House in Chicago in 1889, and Lillian Wald founded the Henry Street Settlement in New York in 1893, offering classes, childcare and health care, and studying neighbourhood conditions. The 1900 census counted roughly one in six children aged 10 to 15 at work. The National Child Labor Committee, formed in 1904, hired the photographer Lewis Hine to document children in mills, mines and canneries. Pressure led Congress to create the federal Children's Bureau in 1912, led by Julia Lathrop, the first woman to head a federal bureau. A lasting federal ban on most child labour came only in 1938.
Protecting adult workers
Florence Kelley, general secretary of the National Consumers League from 1899, urged shoppers to buy only goods made under fair conditions and campaigned for limits on working hours. Courts were often hostile: in Lochner v. New York (1905) the Supreme Court struck down a limit on bakers' hours as a violation of freedom of contract. In Muller v. Oregon (1908), however, it upheld a ten-hour limit for women, persuaded by a brief from the lawyer Louis Brandeis full of medical and social evidence. That victory rested on the argument that women were weaker and needed protection, a reasoning later used to exclude them from many jobs.
Worked example: from the Triangle fire to factory law
1. Event: on 25 March 1911, fire swept the upper floors of the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory in New York. 2. Cause of the death toll: a key exit door was locked, the single fire escape collapsed and fire ladders could not reach the top floors; 146 workers died, most of them young Jewish and Italian immigrant women. 3. Context: many of the same workers had joined a large garment strike in 1909 demanding safer conditions. 4. Response: mass protests led New York to create a Factory Investigating Commission, whose investigators included Frances Perkins, later the first woman in a presidential cabinet. 5. Result: the state passed dozens of laws on fire exits, sprinklers and working hours, and the commission became a model for other states.
Temperance and prohibition
For many reformers, alcohol was the root of poverty, domestic violence and machine politics, which was often run from saloons. The Woman's Christian Temperance Union, founded in 1874 and led for years by Frances Willard, linked temperance to women's rights and child welfare. The Anti-Saloon League, founded in the 1890s, worked as a single-issue pressure group, backing any candidate of either party who supported its cause. Towns, counties and then whole states voted to go dry. The campaign peaked with the Eighteenth Amendment, ratified in 1919, which banned the making, sale and transport of alcohol. Prohibition also carried hostility towards immigrant drinking cultures.
Radical voices
The Socialist Party of America, founded in 1901, sought public ownership of major industries through elections. Its leader Eugene Debs ran for president five times between 1900 and 1920, winning about 900,000 votes, around 6 percent, in 1912. Socialists elected mayors in cities such as Milwaukee and sent Victor Berger and Meyer London to Congress. The Industrial Workers of the World, founded in 1905 and led by figures such as William "Big Bill" Haywood, aimed to unite all workers in one big union and favoured strikes over elections. It led the 1912 textile strike in Lawrence, Massachusetts, and faced arrests and vigilante violence.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, mixing up the initiative, which proposes a new law by petition, with the referendum, which puts an existing law to a popular vote. Second, assuming every city reform increased democracy; at-large elections often reduced immigrant representation. Third, treating Muller v. Oregon as a simple victory for equality, when it rested on the idea of female weakness. Fourth, thinking the Children's Bureau banned child labour; it researched and publicised the problem. Fifth, lumping socialists and the IWW together with mainstream Progressives, who mostly wanted to regulate capitalism rather than replace it.
Key takeaways
Grassroots Progressives introduced the direct primary, initiative, referendum and recall, and won direct election of senators in 1913. Cities adopted commission and council-manager government, which cut graft but sometimes reduced immigrant representation. La Follette's Wisconsin Idea relied on experts, and Taylor applied efficiency to factories. Women led settlement houses, child labour campaigns and consumer activism, and the Triangle fire of 1911 produced new safety laws. Temperance campaigners won the Eighteenth Amendment in 1919, while socialists and the IWW pressed for deeper change.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Election in which party members choose their candidates
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Citizens in a state gather signatures so that a new minimum wage law appears on the ballot. Which reform are they using?
Question 2 of 5
What led Galveston, Texas, to adopt the commission form of government in 1901?
Question 3 of 5
Why do some historians argue that at-large, nonpartisan city elections narrowed democracy?
Question 4 of 5
On what argument did the Supreme Court rely in Muller v. Oregon (1908)?
Question 5 of 5
What was the most direct result of the Triangle Shirtwaist fire of 1911?
