US History › Section K · Progressives and empire › Topic K.3

New voices for women and African Americans

The Progressive talk of perfecting democracy raised an obvious question: democracy for whom? Women and African Americans answered with new organisations, new leaders and fierce debates over strategy, and their work set the course of civil rights for the next century.

Two movements, one promise

Progressives spoke of giving the people more control over government, yet most women could not vote and most Black Southerners had lost the vote. Two movements pushed against these exclusions. Suffragists demanded the ballot for women, and Black activists fought disfranchisement, segregation and lynching. Both were divided over tactics: whether to persuade gradually or to confront openly. They also clashed, because many white suffragists were willing to sacrifice Black women's interests to win white Southern support.

From Seneca Falls to a united association

Women had demanded the vote at Seneca Falls in 1848, as an earlier topic showed. After the Civil War the movement split over the Fifteenth Amendment, which barred racial discrimination in voting but not discrimination by sex. Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Susan B. Anthony formed the National Woman Suffrage Association to seek a federal amendment, while Lucy Stone's American Woman Suffrage Association worked state by state. Anthony was arrested for voting in 1872 and fined the next year, and in 1875 the Supreme Court ruled in Minor v. Happersett that citizenship did not carry a right to vote. In 1890 the rivals merged as the National American Woman Suffrage Association, NAWSA.

The West leads and the arguments shift

The first victories came in the West. Wyoming Territory gave women the vote in 1869 and kept it at statehood in 1890; Colorado followed in 1893, Utah and Idaho in 1896. After a long pause, Washington, California, Oregon, Kansas and Arizona joined between 1910 and 1912. Arguments also changed. Beside equal rights, many suffragists argued that women voters would clean up politics and protect homes, schools and public health. Some white suffragists argued instead that educated white women's votes would outweigh those of immigrants and Black men, an appeal to prejudice that alienated Black allies.

Two strategies: Catt and Paul

Carrie Chapman Catt, who led NAWSA in 1900 to 1904 and again from 1915, favoured disciplined lobbying; her "Winning Plan" of 1916 combined state campaigns with pressure on Congress. Alice Paul, inspired by British militants, chose confrontation. On 3 March 1913, the day before Woodrow Wilson's inauguration, she staged a parade of several thousand marchers in Washington; hostile crowds attacked it while police largely stood by, and about 100 marchers were treated in hospital. Paul's group broke from NAWSA and became the National Woman's Party. From 1917 its "Silent Sentinels" picketed the White House; jailed pickets went on hunger strike and were force-fed.

Worked example: why the amendment passed

Why did the Nineteenth Amendment succeed in 1919 and 1920 after decades of failure? 1. Votes: by 1918 women could vote in many states, so members of Congress from those states risked angering voters. 2. Organisation: Catt's NAWSA had a large membership and a coordinated plan. 3. Pressure: Paul's pickets and the news of force-feeding embarrassed a president who claimed to fight for democracy abroad. 4. War: women's work in factories, nursing and volunteer drives during the First World War strengthened their claim. 5. Result: Wilson endorsed the amendment in 1918, Congress passed it in June 1919, and Tennessee's ratification in August 1920 completed the required three-quarters of the states.

Black women and the limits of 1920

Black women organised on their own terms. The National Association of Colored Women, founded in 1896 with Mary Church Terrell as its first president, took the motto "Lifting as we climb" and ran schools, clinics and suffrage clubs. At the 1913 parade, organisers asked Black women to march at the back; Ida B. Wells-Barnett refused and joined her Illinois delegation. After 1920, poll taxes, literacy tests and violence still kept most Black women in the South from voting. Many Native American women were not citizens until a 1924 law, and Asian immigrant women were barred from citizenship altogether.

Booker T. Washington's strategy

Born into slavery in Virginia around 1856, Booker T. Washington became the first head of Tuskegee Institute in Alabama in 1881, training Black students in trades, farming and teaching. At the Atlanta Cotton States Exposition in 1895 he urged Black Southerners to "cast down your bucket where you are": to build economic strength first and set aside, for the moment, demands for social equality and political rights. White leaders praised the speech, later called the Atlanta Compromise, and wealthy donors funded his projects. Yet historians have found that he secretly financed lawsuits against disfranchisement and segregation.

Du Bois and the Niagara Movement

W. E. B. Du Bois, the first African American to earn a Harvard doctorate, in 1895, became Washington's sharpest critic. In The Souls of Black Folk (1903) he argued that accepting segregation and disfranchisement would leave Black Americans permanently subordinate, and in an essay that year he called for a college-educated "talented tenth" to lead the fight for full rights. In 1905 Du Bois and other activists met on the Canadian side of Niagara Falls, reportedly because a hotel on the American side would not house them. Their Niagara Movement demanded voting rights, equal education and an end to segregation and the convict-leasing system. It stayed small and short of money.

Worked example: comparing Washington and Du Bois

1. Goal: both wanted Black Americans to prosper and win respect; they disagreed about order and method. 2. Washington's priority: economic self-help first, with rights expected to follow once white Southerners saw Black success. 3. Du Bois's priority: political and civil rights now, because without the vote Black property and progress had no protection. 4. Context: Washington spoke in the Deep South in 1895, where open protest invited violence; Du Bois wrote from Atlanta and later the North, as lynching and disfranchisement spread despite Black economic gains. 5. Conclusion: their debate reflected different judgements about risk, not simply courage versus timidity.

The NAACP is born

In August 1908 a white mob attacked Black residents of Springfield, Illinois, Lincoln's hometown, killing several people and burning homes and businesses. In 1909 an interracial group, including white Progressives such as Mary White Ovington and Oswald Garrison Villard and Black leaders such as Du Bois, Wells-Barnett and Terrell, founded the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People. Du Bois edited its magazine, The Crisis, from 1910 until the 1930s. The NAACP chose publicity and the courts, and in 1915 the Supreme Court struck down Oklahoma's grandfather clause in Guinn v. United States, a case in which the association filed a brief.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, thinking the Nineteenth Amendment gave all women the vote in practice; many Black, Native and Asian immigrant women remained excluded. Second, crediting suffrage to a single leader or tactic, when Catt's lobbying and Paul's protests worked together. Third, picturing the suffrage movement as united on race; many white leaders sidelined Black women. Fourth, treating Booker T. Washington as having done nothing for civil rights; he quietly funded legal challenges. Fifth, describing the NAACP as an all-Black organisation at its founding; it was interracial.

Key takeaways

NAWSA, formed in 1890, united the suffrage movement, and Western states granted women the vote first. Catt's organised lobbying and Paul's confrontational protests together helped win the Nineteenth Amendment, ratified in 1920. Black women organised through groups such as the NACW, but racial barriers kept many women of colour from voting. Booker T. Washington urged economic self-help, while Du Bois demanded immediate rights through the Niagara Movement. After the Springfield riot of 1908, an interracial coalition founded the NAACP in 1909, which turned to publicity and the courts.

Flashcards

Flashcard

NAWSA

National American Woman Suffrage Association, formed in 1890

A merger of two rival groups.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Where did American women first win the right to vote in full elections?

Question 2 of 5

How did Alice Paul's methods differ from Carrie Chapman Catt's?

Question 3 of 5

Why did the Nineteenth Amendment not secure voting rights for all women in practice?

Question 4 of 5

What did Booker T. Washington propose in his 1895 Atlanta speech?

Question 5 of 5

Which event most directly led to the founding of the NAACP in 1909?

← Previous topicNext topic →