US History › Section I · The West and big business › Topic I.6
From invention to industrial growth
New technology became big business through railways, steel, oil and banking. A few industrialists built corporations of unprecedented size, and Americans argued then, as historians do now, over whether they were builders or plunderers.
The Gilded Age economy
Mark Twain and Charles Dudley Warner gave the era its nickname in their 1873 novel The Gilded Age: a thin layer of gold over something cheaper underneath. Between the Civil War and 1900, American industrial output multiplied several times, and by the 1890s the United States had become the world's largest industrial economy. The previous topic covered the inventions behind this growth. This topic follows the business leaders who turned them into giant firms, and the methods, some ingenious and some ruthless, they used to control whole industries.
Railways: the first big business
Railways were the first American businesses to need huge capital, thousands of workers and professional managers. Track grew from about 35,000 miles in 1865 to nearly 200,000 by 1900. In 1883 the railways themselves divided the country into standard time zones, which Congress made law only in 1918, and in 1886 Southern lines converted to the standard gauge, so cars could run anywhere. Air brakes and automatic couplers allowed longer, heavier trains, and George Pullman's sleeping cars made long journeys bearable. Cheap freight let factories sell nationwide and buy raw materials from far away. Railways also bought vast amounts of iron, steel and coal, driving growth in those industries.
Railway barons and their methods
Railway fortunes came with scandal. Cornelius Vanderbilt combined lines into the New York Central, linking New York City to Chicago, and was praised for running them efficiently. Jay Gould became a symbol of speculation: in 1868 he and his partners issued watered stock to keep Vanderbilt from taking over the Erie Railroad, and he later built a huge network that included the Union Pacific. Railways gave secret rebates to big shippers and charged more for short hauls, where they had no competition, than for long ones. Angry farmers pushed states to regulate rates, and in 1887 Congress created the Interstate Commerce Commission, though it had little power at first.
Carnegie and steel
Andrew Carnegie, born in Scotland in 1835, came to Pennsylvania with his family in 1848 and worked as a bobbin boy in a cotton mill and then a telegraph messenger. As a young manager at the Pennsylvania Railroad, he invested shrewdly and saw the coming demand for steel. In 1875 he opened the Edgar Thomson Works near Pittsburgh using the Bessemer process, naming it after the Pennsylvania Railroad's president, a likely buyer of rails. Carnegie obsessed over costs, replaced machinery whenever a cheaper method appeared, and bought rivals cheaply during depressions. He also gained control of iron ore, coke ovens, ships and railways, so he never had to pay another company's profit on his supplies.
Worked example: two ways to grow a firm
Compare the two strategies of integration. 1. Vertical integration means owning every stage of production, from raw materials to the finished product. 2. Example: Carnegie owned ore mines, coke ovens, ore boats and railways as well as steel mills. 3. Benefit: steady supplies and lower costs at each stage. 4. Horizontal integration means buying or merging with rival firms at the same stage of business. 5. Example: Rockefeller bought up competing oil refineries until Standard Oil dominated refining. 6. Benefit: less competition and power over prices. 7. Conclusion: vertical integration controls a supply chain; horizontal integration controls a market. Rockefeller later did both, adding pipelines and tank cars.
Rockefeller and Standard Oil
After Edwin Drake drilled a successful oil well in Titusville, Pennsylvania, in 1859, a rush of drillers followed. John D. Rockefeller, a Cleveland bookkeeper born in 1839, chose refining, turning crude oil into kerosene for lamps, rather than gambling on wells. He founded Standard Oil in 1870 and used his size to win secret railway rebates, then undercut rivals until they sold. In early 1872 he took over most of Cleveland's refineries within a few months. By about 1880, Standard Oil refined roughly 90 percent of America's oil. Kerosene became cheaper, but critics saw a monopoly built on coercion.
Trusts, holding companies and the law
To manage dozens of firms that state laws said could not own one another, Rockefeller's lawyers created the Standard Oil Trust in 1882: shareholders handed their stock to nine trustees who ran the companies as one. Other industries, from sugar to whiskey, copied the trust. Public anger led Congress to pass the Sherman Antitrust Act in 1890, banning combinations "in restraint of trade". Enforcement was weak, and in United States v. E. C. Knight in 1895 the Supreme Court ruled that manufacturing was not commerce, shielding a sugar trust. After Ohio's courts ordered the trust broken up in 1892, Standard Oil reorganised as a New Jersey holding company that owned the shares of its parts.
Morgan and finance capitalism
J. P. Morgan, born into a wealthy banking family in 1837, made money by organising other people's companies. After the Panic of 1893 bankrupted many railways, his bank reorganised them, cutting debts and placing its partners on their boards, a process critics called "Morganization". He helped create General Electric in 1892. In 1901 he bought Carnegie's steel business for about $480 million and merged it with other firms into United States Steel, the first corporation valued at over $1 billion. A congressional inquiry in 1912 described Morgan and his allies as a "money trust" that controlled much of the nation's credit.
Self-made men? Ideas that justified wealth
Many Americans explained great fortunes with Social Darwinism, the misuse of Charles Darwin's ideas about evolution to argue that society rewards the fittest. Herbert Spencer, who coined the phrase "survival of the fittest", and the Yale professor William Graham Sumner argued that government should not interfere. Horatio Alger's novels, beginning with Ragged Dick in 1868, told of poor boys rising through hard work and luck. Carnegie's 1889 essay, later called The Gospel of Wealth, argued that the rich should give their fortunes away wisely; he funded thousands of public libraries. Studies of business leaders, however, found that most came from middle-class or wealthy families.
Worked example: robber barons or captains of industry?
Weigh the two labels for the industrialists. 1. Origin: critics in the late 1800s called them robber barons, after medieval lords who robbed travellers; the historian Matthew Josephson's 1934 book revived the term. 2. Evidence for the charge: secret rebates, crushed rivals, stock manipulation, bribery and low wages. 3. Evidence for "captains of industry": falling prices for kerosene and steel, efficient management, new jobs and large gifts to libraries and universities. 4. Historians such as Allan Nevins stressed their achievements as builders. 5. Conclusion: the answer depends on the criteria; most historians now weigh both the growth they produced and the costs others paid.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, confusing vertical integration, controlling the supply chain, with horizontal integration, buying out rivals. Second, assuming the Sherman Antitrust Act broke up trusts at once; courts weakened it for years. Third, accepting the rags-to-riches story as typical; Carnegie was an exception, and Morgan was born rich. Fourth, treating Social Darwinism as Darwin's own theory; it was a later misapplication by others. Fifth, ignoring the role of government; land grants, tariffs and courts all favoured big business.
Key takeaways
Railways became the first big business, creating national markets and standard time. Vanderbilt and Gould showed both efficient consolidation and speculation. Carnegie dominated steel through cost-cutting and vertical integration; Rockefeller dominated oil refining through rebates, horizontal integration and the trust. The Sherman Antitrust Act of 1890 was weakly enforced. Morgan reorganised railways and created US Steel in 1901. Social Darwinism and the Gospel of Wealth defended great fortunes, and the robber baron debate continues.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Name for the late 1800s: a glittering surface over deep problems
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Carnegie bought iron mines, coke ovens and ore boats to supply his steel mills. What strategy was this?
Question 2 of 5
How did secret railway rebates help Standard Oil?
Question 3 of 5
Why did the Sherman Antitrust Act of 1890 do little to break up trusts at first?
Question 4 of 5
What did J. P. Morgan create in 1901?
Question 5 of 5
Which argument would a defender of the "captains of industry" label most likely make?
