US History › Section G · Reform and a decade of crisis › Topic G.6
The Kansas-Nebraska Act and the Republican Party
In 1854 a bill to organise the western plains tore up the Missouri Compromise line. Within two years Kansas was at war with itself, a senator had been beaten nearly senseless in the Capitol, and a new northern party had changed American politics.
A short calm
After 1850 many Americans hoped the slavery question was settled. In the 1852 election both major parties endorsed the compromise, and the Democrat Franklin Pierce of New Hampshire easily beat the Whig general Winfield Scott. The Whig Party, already divided between its northern and southern wings, never recovered. The calm lasted barely two years. The land west of Missouri and Iowa, home to Native nations, many of them moved there by removal policy, was still unorganised, and white settlers, land speculators and railway promoters all wanted it opened. How it was organised would decide the fate of slavery there.
Douglas's bill
Senator Stephen Douglas of Illinois wanted the region organised so that a transcontinental railway could run west from Chicago. Southern senators would back him only if slavery was allowed a chance there, even though the whole area lay north of 36°30′, where the Missouri Compromise of 1820 had banned slavery. Douglas's bill, introduced in January 1854, created two territories, Kansas and Nebraska, applied popular sovereignty to both and expressly repealed the Missouri Compromise line. After months of bitter debate it passed in May 1854, by 113 votes to 100 in the House, and President Pierce signed it.
The northern backlash
To many northerners, repealing a line that had stood for over thirty years looked like proof that the Slave Power would break any bargain. Antislavery congressmen issued an appeal calling the bill a betrayal of a sacred pledge. Douglas was burned in effigy across the North. In the elections of 1854 and 1855, northern Democrats lost many seats in Congress, and voters searched for a new party. Some turned to a movement against immigrants; others founded a new antislavery party. The act made the issue unavoidable: no one could any longer pretend the West's future had been settled in 1850.
The Know-Nothings
From about 1845 to 1855, roughly three million immigrants arrived, many of them Irish Catholics fleeing the potato famine and Germans, both Catholic and Protestant. Many native-born Protestants feared they would take jobs, drink heavily and obey the Pope rather than American law. Secret nativist societies grew into the American Party, nicknamed the Know-Nothings because members told outsiders they knew nothing about it. In 1854 they won control of Massachusetts and made gains in other states. But the party itself split over slavery in 1855 and 1856, and many of its northern voters moved to the Republicans. On the West Coast, nativists also targeted Chinese immigrants.
The Republican Party
Meetings across the North in 1854, including at Ripon, Wisconsin, and Jackson, Michigan, launched the Republican Party. It drew in former northern Whigs, antislavery Democrats, Free-Soilers and some abolitionists, and it absorbed the Free-Soil Party. Its core demand was to keep slavery out of the territories, not to abolish it in the states. Republicans praised free labour: the idea that in the North an ordinary man could work for wages, save, and rise to own a farm or shop, an opportunity they believed slavery would destroy. Many Republicans also held racist views and wanted the West for white settlers. The party had almost no support in the South.
Worked example: how one law broke a party system
Explain how the Kansas-Nebraska Act reshaped politics. 1. Trigger: the act repealed the Missouri Compromise line, angering northern voters of every party. 2. Whigs: already divided by section, they could not agree on a response and disappeared as a national party. 3. Democrats: northern Democrats lost heavily, so the party's southern wing gained weight within it. 4. Newcomers: voters first tried the Know-Nothings, then many settled on the Republicans. 5. Result: the second party system of Whigs and Democrats gave way to a contest between a national Democratic Party and a purely northern Republican Party. 6. Check: by 1856 the Republicans were the main opposition.
Bleeding Kansas
Popular sovereignty turned Kansas into a contest of numbers, and both sides sent settlers. Antislavery northerners, helped by the New England Emigrant Aid Company, founded towns such as Lawrence. Thousands of proslavery Missourians, called border ruffians, crossed the border to vote illegally in the 1855 elections, giving Kansas a proslavery legislature. Free-state settlers set up a rival government at Topeka. In May 1856 a proslavery posse sacked Lawrence, wrecking its newspaper presses and burning a hotel. Days later the abolitionist John Brown and his followers killed five proslavery settlers at Pottawatomie Creek. Guerrilla fighting followed, and estimates of deaths range widely, from about 50 to about 200.
Violence in the Senate
In May 1856 Senator Charles Sumner of Massachusetts gave a two-day speech, "The Crime Against Kansas", attacking the proslavery cause and personally insulting Senator Andrew Butler of South Carolina. Two days later Butler's relative, Representative Preston Brooks, walked into the Senate chamber and beat Sumner with a cane until he collapsed. Sumner needed about three years to recover, and Massachusetts kept his seat for him. Many white southerners praised Brooks for defending honour and sent him new canes, while many northerners saw the attack as proof that slaveholders would answer free speech with violence.
Worked example: reading an 1856 campaign slogan
Republican banners of 1856 joined the words free soil, free speech and free men to the name of their candidate, the explorer John C. Frémont. 1. Source: campaign slogans aimed at northern voters, found in several slightly different versions. 2. Free soil: keep slavery out of the territories, the party's central policy. 3. Free speech: a reminder of the caning of Sumner and of southern attempts to silence antislavery voices. 4. Free men: the free labour ideal of independent working men. 5. Purpose: to link slavery's spread with threats to the liberties of white northerners, not only to the rights of enslaved people. 6. Limits: the slogans say nothing about equal rights for Black Americans.
The election of 1856
Three serious candidates ran. The Democrat James Buchanan of Pennsylvania had been abroad as minister to Britain during the Kansas-Nebraska fight, so he had few enemies. The Republican Frémont won about a third of the popular vote and carried eleven free states, a remarkable result for a two-year-old party. The former president Millard Fillmore, running for the American Party, won about a fifth and carried only Maryland. Buchanan won with about 45 percent by sweeping the South and taking several free states, including his own. The Democrats remained the one major party with real strength in both sections, and the American Party soon faded.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, the Kansas-Nebraska Act did not ban or require slavery; it let settlers decide, and it repealed the Missouri Compromise line. Second, the Republican Party was not an abolitionist party: it opposed slavery's expansion, not slavery where it already existed. Third, the Know-Nothings were mainly an anti-immigrant party, not an antislavery one, and they split over slavery. Fourth, Bleeding Kansas was not one battle but years of fraud, raids and killings by both sides. Fifth, Frémont lost in 1856; the first Republican president was elected in 1860.
Key takeaways
The Kansas-Nebraska Act of 1854 applied popular sovereignty to Kansas and Nebraska and repealed the Missouri Compromise line, provoking a northern backlash. The Whigs collapsed, northern Democrats lost ground, the nativist Know-Nothings rose and fell, and the Republican Party formed to stop slavery's expansion. In Kansas, border ruffians, rival governments, the sack of Lawrence and John Brown's Pottawatomie killings produced Bleeding Kansas, and Brooks's caning of Sumner brought the violence to the Senate. In 1856 Buchanan won, but the Republicans became the North's main party.
Flashcards
Flashcard
1854 law creating two territories under popular sovereignty
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Why did the Kansas-Nebraska Act anger so many northerners?
Question 2 of 5
What was the Republican Party's central aim in the 1850s?
Question 3 of 5
Who were the border ruffians?
Question 4 of 5
Which statement about the Know-Nothings is accurate?
Question 5 of 5
What did the 1856 election show about the new Republican Party?
