US History › Section G · Reform and a decade of crisis › Topic G.7

Dred Scott and sectional strife

In 1857 the Supreme Court tried to end the argument over slavery in the territories once and for all. Instead its decision in Dred Scott v. Sandford enraged the North, split the Democrats and set the stage for Abraham Lincoln.

A president hopes the Court will decide

James Buchanan took office in March 1857 facing violence in Kansas and a country bitterly divided over slavery in the West. In his inaugural address he said the question belonged to the Supreme Court and promised to accept its ruling. He already knew roughly what was coming, because he had privately urged one justice to join a broad decision. Two days later, on 6 March 1857, the Court announced its judgment in the case of Dred Scott, an enslaved man who had spent over a decade suing for his freedom.

Dred Scott and his family

Dred Scott was born into slavery in Virginia in about 1799 and taken to St. Louis, Missouri. He was sold to John Emerson, an army surgeon, who took him in the 1830s to Illinois, a free state, and then to Fort Snelling in the Wisconsin Territory, where the Missouri Compromise banned slavery. There Scott married Harriet Robinson, an enslaved woman, and the couple later had two daughters. Emerson brought the family back to Missouri and died in 1843. In 1846 Dred and Harriet Scott each sued Emerson's widow for freedom, arguing that living on free soil had made them free, a principle Missouri courts had often accepted.

The road to the Supreme Court

In 1850 a St. Louis jury declared the Scotts free. In 1852, however, the Missouri Supreme Court reversed that verdict, openly breaking with its own earlier rulings because of the rising political conflict over slavery. Scott's lawyers then sued in federal court, which could hear the case because the man now claiming him, John Sanford, Irene Emerson's brother, lived in New York. A clerk misspelled his name, which is why the case is called Dred Scott v. Sandford. Scott lost in 1854 and appealed. The Supreme Court heard arguments twice and decided the case by seven votes to two.

Taney's ruling and the dissent

Chief Justice Roger Taney of Maryland wrote the main opinion. First, he held that Black Americans whose ancestors had been enslaved, free or not, were not and could not become citizens of the United States, so Scott had no right to sue in federal court. Second, he held that Congress had no power to ban slavery in the territories, because enslaved people were property protected by the Fifth Amendment. The Missouri Compromise ban was therefore unconstitutional, the first federal law struck down since Marbury v. Madison in 1803. Justices John McLean and Benjamin Curtis dissented, Curtis pointing out that free Black men had voted in several states when the Constitution was ratified.

Worked example: reading Taney's opinion

Taney wrote that, in the founders' era, Black people "had no rights which the white man was bound to respect." 1. Source: the majority opinion of the Supreme Court, written by its chief justice, with the force of law. 2. Claim: Taney presented this as a description of how the founders saw Black people, so that the Constitution's guarantees did not cover them. 3. Purpose: it supported his conclusion that Black Americans could not be citizens. 4. Evidence against: Curtis showed that free Black men voted in some states in 1787 and 1788. 5. Impact: northerners quoted the line as if it were Taney's own view of the present, which spread outrage. 6. Conclusion: a legal opinion can be read as both history and policy.

Reactions North and South

Many white southerners rejoiced: the highest court had confirmed that slaveholders could take enslaved people into any territory. Republicans were furious, because the ruling declared their main policy, keeping slavery out of the territories, unconstitutional. They argued that the Slave Power now controlled the Court too, and some warned that a future ruling might force slavery into the free states. Frederick Douglass predicted that the decision would hasten slavery's end by awakening the nation. Black northerners were told they had no claim to citizenship. Dred Scott himself was freed weeks later by a new owner, but he died in 1858.

Kansas and the Lecompton constitution

Meanwhile Kansas remained in turmoil. In 1857 a proslavery convention at Lecompton wrote a state constitution protecting slavery, and free-state voters, who were the majority, boycotted the vote on it. Buchanan nevertheless asked Congress to admit Kansas under the Lecompton constitution. Stephen Douglas broke with the president, calling the document a fraud on popular sovereignty. Congress sent it back to Kansas voters, who rejected it overwhelmingly in August 1858. Kansas entered the Union as a free state only in January 1861. The fight cost Buchanan support in the North and made Douglas an enemy of many southern Democrats.

Lincoln and the house divided

In 1858 Illinois Republicans chose Abraham Lincoln, a former one-term congressman, to challenge Douglas for his Senate seat. Accepting, Lincoln warned that "a house divided against itself cannot stand" and that the nation would eventually become all slave or all free. He argued that the Kansas-Nebraska Act and the Dred Scott decision were steps towards making slavery lawful everywhere. Lincoln called slavery a moral wrong and opposed its expansion, but he said he did not seek to end it in the southern states, and like most white Americans of his time he rejected full social and political equality for Black Americans.

The Lincoln-Douglas debates

The two men held seven debates across Illinois from August to October 1858, before large crowds, and newspapers printed them nationwide. Douglas defended popular sovereignty and attacked the Republicans as radicals bent on racial equality. At Freeport, Lincoln asked whether settlers could still exclude slavery after Dred Scott. Douglas answered with what became known as the Freeport Doctrine: slavery could not survive where local laws refused to protect it, so settlers could keep it out by declining to pass slave codes. The answer helped him at home, and the Illinois legislature, which then chose senators, re-elected him. But Lincoln emerged a national figure.

Worked example: how one ruling split the Democrats

Trace how Dred Scott damaged the Democratic Party. 1. The ruling said Congress could not ban slavery in territories, which implied a territorial legislature could not either. 2. That undercut popular sovereignty, the policy northern Democrats such as Douglas had sold to their voters. 3. Douglas's Freeport Doctrine tried to rescue it by saying settlers could exclude slavery in practice. 4. Southern Democrats rejected this and began demanding a federal slave code to protect slavery in the territories. 5. Result: the party's two wings now wanted incompatible things. 6. Check: in 1860 the Democrats split and ran two candidates for president.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, the Dred Scott case did not begin in 1857; the Scotts first sued in 1846. Second, the ruling went far beyond Scott's own freedom: it denied Black citizenship and struck down the Missouri Compromise ban. Third, Lincoln lost the 1858 Senate race; the debates made his name, not his seat. Fourth, senators were then chosen by state legislatures, not by direct popular vote. Fifth, the Freeport Doctrine was Douglas's idea, not Lincoln's, and it angered southern Democrats rather than pleasing them.

Key takeaways

Dred and Harriet Scott sued for freedom in 1846 because they had lived on free soil. In Dred Scott v. Sandford (1857), Chief Justice Taney ruled that Black Americans could not be citizens and that Congress could not ban slavery in the territories, voiding the Missouri Compromise line; Justice Curtis dissented. Republicans saw the Slave Power at work, and the ruling undercut popular sovereignty. Lecompton split Buchanan from Douglas. In 1858 Lincoln's house-divided warning and the Lincoln-Douglas debates made him a national leader, while Douglas's Freeport Doctrine alienated the South.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Dred Scott

Enslaved man who sued for freedom after living on free soil

He and his wife Harriet first sued in 1846.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

On what grounds did Dred and Harriet Scott sue for their freedom?

Question 2 of 5

Which two holdings did Chief Justice Taney's opinion contain?

Question 3 of 5

Why did the Dred Scott decision anger Republicans in particular?

Question 4 of 5

What was the Freeport Doctrine?

Question 5 of 5

What was the result of the 1858 Illinois Senate race?

← Previous topicNext topic →