US History › Section P · From the Reagan era to today › Topic P.7
New century, old disputes
The twenty-first century revived some of the oldest American arguments: who belongs, what counts as a marriage, and how far science should guide policy. Debates over immigration, same-sex marriage and climate change show how values, faith, evidence and party loyalty collided.
Old questions, new forms
Many disputes of the 2000s echoed earlier ones. Americans had argued over immigration since the 1840s, over the definition of marriage since laws once banned interracial unions, and over science and faith since the 1925 Scopes trial on teaching evolution. New technology raised new versions of these questions. In 2001 Bush limited federal funding for research using human embryonic stem cells, which many religious conservatives opposed because embryos are destroyed, while many scientists and patients' groups urged wider research; Obama lifted the limit in 2009. In each debate, people on different sides appealed to deeply held values, which made compromise hard.
A changing population
Since a 1965 law ended national-origin quotas, most immigrants had come from Latin America and Asia rather than Europe. By the early 2000s Hispanic Americans had become the largest minority group, and census officials projected that non-Hispanic white Americans would fall below half the population in the 2040s. Some Americans welcomed this diversity; others worried about rapid cultural change. One response was the campaign to make English an official language. In 2006 about three-quarters of Arizona voters approved such a measure. Supporters said a shared language helped newcomers succeed; opponents replied that English was already dominant and the laws singled out Spanish speakers.
Reform that never passed
By 2007 an estimated 12 million people lived in the country without legal status. Many proposals combined three parts: tighter border security, more temporary visas for guest workers, and a path to legal status for long-term residents. Bush backed such a deal, and the Senate passed a version in 2006, but the House refused, and a 2007 bill failed in the Senate. In 2013 the Senate passed another bipartisan bill, which the House never brought to a vote. Supporters of a path to legal status saw it as fair and practical; opponents called it amnesty that rewarded lawbreaking and would encourage more unauthorised entry.
States, schools and children
As Congress stalled, states acted. Arizona's 2010 law SB 1070 directed police to check the status of people they stopped and suspected were in the country unlawfully; in 2012 the Supreme Court struck down three of its provisions but allowed the status checks. Alabama passed a strict law in 2011, parts of which courts blocked. Arizona also banned school courses said to promote ethnic resentment, ending Tucson's Mexican American studies programme, a ban a federal judge ruled unconstitutional in 2017. In 2012 Obama created DACA, which let many people brought to the country as children apply for work permits and protection from deportation. In 2014 tens of thousands of unaccompanied Central American children reached the border.
Worked example: why did immigration reform keep failing?
1. Competing goals: some voters wanted enforcement first, others legal status first, and every bill tried to balance both. 2. Trust: opponents pointed to the 1986 law, which legalised about 2.7 million people but did not stop unauthorised immigration, and doubted new enforcement promises. 3. Interests: businesses wanted workers, some unions feared wage competition, and Latino and immigrant groups pressed for legal status. 4. Institutions: the Senate passed bills, but House leaders would not hold votes most of their members opposed. 5. Conclusion: deep disagreement and distrust, not lack of proposals, blocked reform, leaving presidents to act through executive actions such as DACA.
The road to marriage equality
In 1996 neither major party supported same-sex marriage, and the Defense of Marriage Act denied it federal recognition. Then states moved. Vermont created civil unions with the legal rights of marriage in 2000. In 2003 the Supreme Court struck down state laws criminalising gay sex, and Massachusetts's highest court ruled that same-sex couples could marry; weddings began there in 2004. A backlash followed: eleven states banned same-sex marriage by referendum in November 2004, and about thirty had constitutional bans by 2012. California voters approved Proposition 8 in 2008, banning such marriages. Yet in 2012 Maine, Maryland and Washington became the first states to approve them by popular vote.
The courts decide
Public opinion shifted fast: Gallup polls found support for same-sex marriage rising from about 27 percent in 1996 to about 60 percent in 2015, driven largely by younger Americans. In United States v. Windsor (2013) the Supreme Court struck down the part of DOMA that denied federal recognition. Then, in Obergefell v. Hodges in June 2015, it ruled 5 to 4 that the Fourteenth Amendment guarantees same-sex couples the right to marry in every state. Supporters celebrated equal treatment under the law. Many religious conservatives saw the ruling as overturning a traditional definition of marriage and worried about the religious liberty of those who disagreed.
The climate change dispute
By the 2000s most climate scientists agreed that the Earth was warming and that human emissions of greenhouse gases, such as carbon dioxide from burning fossil fuels, were very likely the main cause. In 1997 nations adopted the Kyoto Protocol to cut emissions by industrial countries. The United States, then the world's largest emitter, signed it in 1998, but the Senate had already voted 95 to 0 against any treaty that excused developing nations, and it was never submitted for ratification. In 2001 Bush rejected it, citing harm to the economy and the exemption for China and India. Al Gore's film An Inconvenient Truth helped him share the 2007 Nobel Peace Prize with UN climate scientists.
Worked example: separating science from policy
Question: what exactly were Americans arguing about on climate? 1. Scientific question: is the climate warming, and are humans the main cause? Here the evidence and expert bodies largely agreed. 2. Policy question: what should be done, how fast and at what cost? Here reasonable people weighed jobs, energy prices and fairness between nations differently. 3. Trust: polls showed that Republicans grew far more doubtful than Democrats of the science itself, a gap tied to party identity and distrust of government regulation. 4. Conclusion: clear thinking separates factual claims, which evidence can settle, from value choices about costs and responses, which democratic debate must decide.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, treating immigration anxiety as new; it recurs throughout American history. Second, assuming Congress never tried immigration reform; the Senate passed bills in 2006 and 2013, but the House did not act. Third, dating nationwide same-sex marriage to Massachusetts in 2004; it became national through Obergefell in 2015. Fourth, saying the United States ratified the Kyoto Protocol; it signed but never ratified it. Fifth, mixing the scientific question about climate change with the policy question of how to respond.
Key takeaways
Immigration since 1965 made the nation more diverse, prompting official-English measures and repeated, failed attempts at comprehensive reform. States such as Arizona and Alabama passed strict laws that courts partly blocked, and Obama created DACA in 2012. Same-sex marriage moved from civil unions in Vermont and marriage in Massachusetts, through a wave of state bans, to nationwide recognition in Obergefell v. Hodges (2015). On climate, scientists broadly agreed on human-caused warming, but the United States never ratified Kyoto, and views split sharply by party.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Ended national-origin quotas
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which three elements did most comprehensive immigration reform bills combine?
Question 2 of 5
What did the Supreme Court decide in Obergefell v. Hodges (2015)?
Question 3 of 5
What was the status of the Kyoto Protocol in the United States?
Question 4 of 5
Why did many Senate-passed immigration bills fail to become law?
Question 5 of 5
In the climate debate, which question could scientific evidence settle most directly?
