US History › Section P · From the Reagan era to today › Topic P.6

Domestic policy in the 2000s

At home, George W. Bush's presidency brought tax cuts, a sweeping education law and a new drug benefit for older Americans. It also brought a failed response to Hurricane Katrina and the worst financial crisis since the Great Depression, which reshaped American politics.

Tax cuts and the return of deficits

Bush believed, like Reagan, that lower taxes would encourage investment and growth. In 2001 Congress passed a tax cut worth about $1.35 trillion over ten years, lowering rates for all brackets and the top rate from 39.6 to 35 percent; households also received rebate cheques. A 2003 law cut taxes on dividends and capital gains. Supporters said the cuts softened the brief 2001 recession; critics noted that the largest gains went to the highest earners. With a weaker economy and the costs of two wars, the cuts helped turn the surpluses of the late 1990s into large deficits by 2004; a new Medicare benefit added to later ones.

No Child Left Behind

A 1983 federal report, A Nation at Risk, had warned that American schools were falling behind, and test scores showed wide gaps between white students and students of colour. Bush, working with Democrats such as Senator Ted Kennedy, signed the No Child Left Behind Act in January 2002. It required states to test pupils every year in reading and maths from grades 3 to 8, report results by group, and penalise schools that kept failing to improve. The law made achievement gaps visible, but teachers complained of teaching to the test, and states criticised its rigid targets. It was replaced in 2015. Bush also promoted charter schools and vouchers.

Medicare, faith and the 2004 election

In 2003 Bush signed the largest expansion of Medicare since its creation: Part D, which from 2006 helped older Americans pay for prescription drugs through private insurance plans. He also created a White House office to channel federal grants to religious and community charities. In 2004 the Democrats nominated John Kerry, a Massachusetts senator and decorated Vietnam veteran. Republicans portrayed him as inconsistent on Iraq, and a veterans' group attacked his war record with widely discredited claims. Bush won with about 51 percent of the popular vote, the first majority since 1988, and Republicans gained seats in both houses.

A second-term agenda stalls

Bush declared that he had earned "political capital" and planned to spend it. His main proposal, letting workers divert part of their Social Security taxes into private investment accounts, met strong opposition from Democrats and older voters and never reached a vote. Immigration also divided his own party. In December 2005 the House passed a bill making unlawful presence in the country a felony. In the spring of 2006 millions of immigrants and supporters marched in protest across the country. Congress funded hundreds of miles of border fencing in 2006, but broader reform failed, as the next topic explains.

Hurricane Katrina

On 29 August 2005 Hurricane Katrina struck the Gulf Coast. In New Orleans, much of which lies below sea level, the levees and floodwalls failed, and about 80 percent of the city flooded. Most residents had evacuated, but tens of thousands, many of them poor, elderly or without cars, were stranded. Thousands sheltered for days at the Superdome and the convention centre with little food, water or sanitation. The Coast Guard rescued more than 33,000 people, but the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) was slow and disorganised, and its director, who had little emergency experience, resigned. About 1,800 people died across the region.

Worked example: who was responsible for Katrina's toll?

1. The storm: Katrina was among the largest and costliest hurricanes to strike the United States, so heavy damage was unavoidable. 2. Engineering: independent investigations found that flaws in the floodwall design by the Army Corps of Engineers caused many breaches. 3. Local and state: city and Louisiana leaders ordered evacuation late and lacked plans for residents without transport. 4. Federal: FEMA was slow to deliver supplies and coordinate rescues, and Bush was criticised for appearing detached. 5. Inequality: the poorest neighbourhoods, many largely Black, suffered most. 6. Conclusion: responsibility was shared at every level, and the disaster exposed both planning failures and deep inequality.

Scandal and the housing bubble

Corporate fraud shook confidence early in the decade. The energy trader Enron collapsed in 2001 after hiding debts with accounting tricks, and in 2002 the telecoms firm WorldCom went bankrupt after inflating its accounts, eventually by about $11 billion. Congress responded with the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, tightening rules on company accounts. Meanwhile, after the Federal Reserve cut interest rates to very low levels, lenders offered subprime mortgages, loans to borrowers with weak credit, often with low starting rates that later jumped. Banks bundled these loans into securities sold worldwide. Home prices soared until 2006, then began to fall.

Worked example: from bad loans to a global crisis

1. Lending: lenders could sell mortgages on instead of holding them, so they had less reason to check whether borrowers could repay. 2. Packaging: investment banks combined thousands of loans into complex securities, which ratings agencies often graded as very safe. 3. Leverage: banks borrowed heavily to buy these assets, and insurers such as AIG sold protection against defaults, called credit default swaps. 4. Trigger: as home prices fell from 2006, borrowers defaulted and the securities lost value. 5. Contagion: no one knew which firms held the bad assets, so lending froze. 6. Conclusion: risks hidden across the system turned a housing slump into a financial panic.

The crash of 2008

In March 2008 the investment bank Bear Stearns was rescued through a sale backed by the Federal Reserve. In September the government took over the mortgage giants Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. Lehman Brothers was allowed to fail, the largest bankruptcy in American history, and the next day the Fed rescued AIG. Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson and Fed chair Ben Bernanke asked Congress for $700 billion. After a first House rejection sent stocks plunging, Congress created the Troubled Asset Relief Program (TARP) in October. In December Bush lent $17.4 billion to General Motors and Chrysler. The financier Bernard Madoff's huge Ponzi scheme was also exposed that month.

The Great Recession

The recession lasted from December 2007 to June 2009, the deepest downturn since the 1930s. Stock prices lost roughly half their value from their 2007 peak. About 8.7 million jobs disappeared, and unemployment reached 10 percent in October 2009. Millions of families lost homes to foreclosure, and by 2009 about a quarter of mortgaged homes were underwater, worth less than the loans on them. Many Americans, on both left and right, resented that taxpayers rescued banks whose risky bets had caused the crisis. Politically, Bush was already weakened: in 2006 voters gave Democrats both houses, and Nancy Pelosi became the first woman Speaker.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, blaming the 2008 crisis on a single cause; lending practices, securities, ratings, leverage and weak regulation all played parts. Second, thinking TARP was Obama's programme; Congress passed it under Bush in October 2008. Third, treating Katrina's flooding as purely natural; levee failures turned a storm into a catastrophe. Fourth, calling No Child Left Behind a purely Republican law; it passed with strong support from both parties. Fifth, confusing Madoff's Ponzi scheme, a simple fraud, with the mortgage securities behind the crash.

Key takeaways

Bush's 2001 and 2003 tax cuts, two wars and Medicare Part D turned surpluses into deficits. No Child Left Behind introduced annual testing and accountability. Bush won a narrow majority in 2004, but his Social Security plan failed and immigration divided his party. Hurricane Katrina exposed failures at every level of government and deep inequality, and Democrats won Congress in 2006. Subprime lending and risky securities caused the 2008 crash; Lehman failed, TARP rescued banks, and the Great Recession cost millions of jobs and homes.

Flashcards

Flashcard

2001 tax cut

About $1.35 trillion over ten years; top rate 39.6 → 35%

Largest gains went to top earners.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

What did the No Child Left Behind Act require?

Question 2 of 5

Why did so much of New Orleans flood during Hurricane Katrina?

Question 3 of 5

Why did the spread of subprime mortgage securities make the 2008 crisis so severe?

Question 4 of 5

Which statement about TARP is accurate?

Question 5 of 5

What helped turn the late-1990s budget surpluses into the large deficits of the 2000s?

← Previous topicNext topic →