US History › Section L · The Great War and the 1920s › Topic L.2

The United States prepares for war

Declaring war was the easy part. To fight in Europe, the federal government had to raise an army, feed and supply it, pay for it and win over a divided public, and it grew more powerful than ever before in doing so.

A country unready for war

In April 1917, the United States had only about 200,000 soldiers in its regular army and National Guard together, a tiny force beside the millions fighting in Europe. It had few modern weapons, little shipping and no plan for running a wartime economy. The Allies needed men and supplies quickly, because Russia was collapsing and French armies had been shaken by mutinies that spring. Washington therefore faced four tasks at once: raise an army, organise food and industry, find the money, and persuade a divided nation to back the war.

The draft

Remembering the Civil War draft riots, Wilson's government designed conscription with care. The Selective Service Act of May 1917 required men aged 21 to 30 to register, a range widened to 18 to 45 in 1918. Registration was run by thousands of local draft boards made up of civilians, not by army officers, which made the system feel like a community duty. Nearly ten million men registered on the first day, 5 June 1917. By the end of the war, about 24 million had registered and about 2.8 million had been drafted. In all, roughly four million served in the army, and about two million reached France.

Refusing to serve

Not everyone complied. Hundreds of thousands of men failed to register or did not report when called. Some refused on grounds of conscience: Mennonites, Quakers and members of other peace churches, as well as socialists who opposed a war they saw as fought for profit. The law exempted only members of recognised peace churches from combat, and even they had to accept noncombatant service. About 4,000 drafted men claimed objector status in army camps, and several hundred who refused all military service were court-martialled. Many received very long prison terms, and a small number received death sentences, though none was carried out.

Food and fuel

The Lever Act of August 1917 gave the president broad power over food and fuel. Herbert Hoover, already famous for organising food relief in occupied Belgium, led the Food Administration. Rather than ration by law, he relied mostly on persuasion: "Food will win the war", his posters declared, urging "meatless" and "wheatless" days. Families planted "victory gardens", and farmers, offered guaranteed wheat prices, ploughed more land. The Fuel Administration under Harry Garfield urged heatless days to save coal, and in 1918 Congress made clocks spring forward nationally, America's first daylight saving time.

Organising industry and the railways

The War Industries Board, led from March 1918 by the financier Bernard Baruch, set production priorities, allocated raw materials and fixed prices for key goods. It mostly worked through cooperation with business, offering contracts with good profits, but it could also deny materials to firms that resisted. In December 1917, after traffic jams of freight cars clogged the eastern ports, the government took over the railways, run by the Treasury Secretary William McAdoo through the new Railroad Administration. These agencies showed how far a progressive federal government would go to coordinate the economy.

Paying for the war

The war cost the federal government more than $30 billion, a staggering sum for the time. About a third came from taxes, made possible by the federal income tax that the Sixteenth Amendment had allowed in 1913. Wartime laws raised rates sharply, especially on the wealthy and on corporate profits, so that the top income tax rate reached 77% in 1918. Most of the rest was borrowed through Liberty Loans and a final Victory Loan, which together raised about $21 billion. Bond drives used parades, film stars and posters, and buying a bond became a public test of loyalty.

Worked example: reading a recruiting poster

Source: James Montgomery Flagg's 1917 poster of Uncle Sam pointing straight at the viewer above the words "I want YOU for U.S. Army". 1. Creator and date: a popular illustrator, in the first months of the war, when the army needed volunteers fast. 2. Technique: the direct gaze and pointing finger single out each viewer, so service feels like a personal obligation. 3. Symbol: Uncle Sam stands for the nation, so refusing him means refusing the country. 4. Audience: young men, and families who might encourage them. 5. Limits: a poster shows what officials hoped people would feel, not how many were persuaded. Conclusion: it is evidence of official messaging, best read alongside enlistment and draft records.

Selling the war

A week after war was declared, Wilson created the Committee on Public Information under the journalist George Creel. It produced pamphlets, films and posters, and organised about 75,000 "Four-Minute Men", volunteers who gave short patriotic speeches in cinemas and churches. Its message urged loyalty and sacrifice and painted Germany as a brutal enemy. That message fed a wave of hostility towards German Americans. Schools dropped German lessons, orchestras dropped German composers, and sauerkraut was renamed "liberty cabbage". In April 1918, a mob in Collinsville, Illinois, lynched Robert Prager, a German-born labourer falsely suspected of disloyalty.

Laws against dissent

Congress also passed laws to silence critics. The Espionage Act of 1917 punished interfering with the draft or the armed forces, with prison terms of up to twenty years, and let the postmaster general bar "disloyal" material from the mail. The Sedition Act of 1918 went further, making it a crime to use "disloyal" language about the government, the Constitution, the flag or the military uniform. More than 2,000 people were prosecuted. The socialist leader Eugene V. Debs received ten years for an anti-war speech, and federal agents raided the radical union the Industrial Workers of the World. Private groups such as the American Protective League spied on neighbours.

Worked example: Schenck v. United States (1919)

Question: why did the Supreme Court uphold Charles Schenck's conviction? 1. Facts: Schenck, a Socialist Party official in Philadelphia, mailed leaflets urging drafted men to resist conscription, and was convicted under the Espionage Act. 2. Claim: the First Amendment protected his speech. 3. Ruling: a unanimous court, in Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr.'s opinion, held that speech can be punished when it creates a "clear and present danger" of harms Congress may prevent, and that wartime raises the stakes. 4. Analogy: free speech would not protect "a man in falsely shouting fire in a theatre and causing a panic." 5. Afterwards: Holmes argued for more protection in a dissent later in 1919, and a 1969 ruling replaced his test. Conclusion: Schenck shows how wartime fear narrowed civil liberties.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, assuming that most soldiers volunteered: about 2.8 million men were drafted, roughly 70% of the army. Second, thinking food was rationed by law across the country; Hoover relied mainly on voluntary savings and patriotic pressure. Third, treating the Committee on Public Information as a neutral news service; it existed to build support for the war. Fourth, confusing the two laws: the Espionage Act came in 1917 and the broader Sedition Act in 1918. Fifth, believing that Schenck was the Court's final word on free speech; its "clear and present danger" test was later narrowed and replaced.

Key takeaways

The United States entered the war with a small army and built one mainly through the Selective Service Act, run by local draft boards. New agencies managed food, fuel, industry and the railways, often through voluntary cooperation. Income taxes and Liberty Loans paid for a war costing more than $30 billion. The Committee on Public Information sold the war and fuelled anti-German hostility. The Espionage and Sedition Acts punished dissent, and in Schenck v. United States the Supreme Court upheld them with its "clear and present danger" test.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Selective Service Act

May 1917 law creating the wartime draft

Run through civilian local draft boards.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

How did the Wilson administration try to make conscription acceptable to the public in 1917?

Question 2 of 5

Which statement best describes how the Food Administration under Herbert Hoover saved food?

Question 3 of 5

In Schenck v. United States (1919), what did the Supreme Court decide?

Question 4 of 5

Roughly how was the federal government's war spending of more than $30 billion financed?

Question 5 of 5

What was the main purpose of the Committee on Public Information?

← Previous topicNext topic →