US History › Section L · The Great War and the 1920s › Topic L.1

Neutrality and the European origins of war

When war broke out in Europe in 1914, most Americans wanted no part of it, and President Woodrow Wilson promised neutrality. Within three years, trade, submarines and a secret German telegram had carried the United States into the conflict.

Wilson's moral diplomacy

Woodrow Wilson took office in March 1913 promising a foreign policy guided by principle rather than by power or profit. He believed the United States should intervene abroad only for a clear moral reason. His Secretary of State, William Jennings Bryan, a long-standing critic of imperialism, persuaded about thirty nations to sign "cooling-off" treaties, promising to submit disputes to an international commission and to wait before fighting. Bryan also negotiated a treaty offering Colombia $25 million for the loss of Panama, although the Senate approved it only in 1921, without the apology it first contained.

Intervention in the Caribbean

In practice, Wilson sent troops into Latin America more often than Theodore Roosevelt or William Howard Taft had. After Haiti's president was killed by a crowd in 1915, US Marines landed and took control of the country's customs and finances; the occupation lasted until 1934, and Haitian guerrillas known as Cacos fought it for years. Marines occupied the Dominican Republic from 1916 to 1924 to secure debt payments, and troops landed in Cuba in 1917 to protect American-owned sugar estates. Many in the region saw this as imperialism, whatever Wilson's talk of good government.

Trouble with Mexico

Mexico was in the middle of a revolution. Wilson refused to recognise General Victoriano Huerta, who had seized power in February 1913, and backed his rival Venustiano Carranza. In April 1914, US forces occupied the port of Veracruz to block an arms shipment, a clash that killed well over a hundred Mexicans and nineteen Americans. Carranza took power but resented the interference. When the rebel leader Pancho Villa, angry that Washington had recognised Carranza, raided Columbus, New Mexico, in March 1916, Wilson sent General John J. Pershing into Mexico. The expedition never caught Villa and withdrew in early 1917.

Europe goes to war

On 28 June 1914, Gavrilo Princip, a Bosnian Serb nationalist, assassinated Archduke Franz Ferdinand, heir to the Austro-Hungarian throne, in Sarajevo. Austria-Hungary, promised German support, declared war on Serbia. Russia mobilised to defend Serbia, and Germany declared war on Russia and then France. When German armies marched through neutral Belgium, Britain declared war on Germany. Within weeks the Allies, led by Britain, France and Russia, faced the Central Powers of Germany and Austria-Hungary, later joined by the Ottoman Empire and Bulgaria. Historians stress deeper causes too: rival alliances, an arms race, competition for colonies and intense nationalism.

A new kind of war

Both sides expected a short war. Instead, the Western Front froze into lines of trenches stretching from the North Sea to Switzerland. Machine guns, heavy artillery and barbed wire favoured defenders, so attacks often cost tens of thousands of lives for a few miles of ground. Poison gas, tanks and aircraft added new horrors. By 1918, an estimated nine to ten million soldiers had died, along with millions of civilians, though civilian totals remain uncertain. Many Americans reading of this slaughter concluded that their country should stay away from it.

Neutral, but not equally

In August 1914, Wilson urged Americans to be impartial "in thought as well as in action". For him, neutrality meant trading with every warring nation, not cutting ties. Reality favoured the Allies. Britain's navy blockaded Germany, so American trade with the Central Powers almost vanished, while sales of food, steel and munitions to Britain and France soared. American banks such as J. P. Morgan lent the Allies more than $2 billion by 1917, against only about $27 million to Germany. A German victory would have threatened those debts, which gave the United States a growing financial stake in an Allied win.

A divided nation of immigrants

Americans disagreed about which side deserved sympathy. Many of British ancestry felt close to Britain; many Irish Americans resented British rule in Ireland. Millions of German Americans saw Germany as encircled by enemies. Jewish immigrants who had fled pogroms in the Russian Empire had little reason to cheer for the tsar's side. Pacifists, socialists and many farmers opposed any involvement at all. Meanwhile, a "preparedness" movement led by Theodore Roosevelt and others demanded a bigger military. Wilson gave ground in 1916, signing the National Defense Act, which enlarged the army, and a major naval building programme.

Worked example: the Lusitania and submarine warfare

Question: why did U-boats strain American neutrality more than the British blockade did? 1. Cause: unable to break Britain's blockade, Germany declared the waters around Britain a war zone in February 1915. 2. Method: fragile submarines often struck without warning instead of stopping ships and saving crews, breaking accepted rules of war. 3. Event: on 7 May 1915, a U-boat sank the British liner Lusitania, killing about 1,200 people, including 128 Americans. The ship was carrying some munitions. 4. Response: Wilson sent sharp protests; Bryan resigned, fearing they would lead to war. 5. Result: after further sinkings, Germany pledged in May 1916 (the Sussex pledge) to warn merchant ships first. 6. Conclusion: the blockade seized cargo, but U-boats killed people.

The election of 1916

Wilson had won in 1912 with only about 42% of the popular vote, because Roosevelt and Taft split the Republicans. In 1916 the reunited Republicans nominated Charles Evans Hughes, a Supreme Court justice and former governor of New York, who was vague on the war. Democrats campaigned on the slogan "He kept us out of war" and on progressive laws such as an eight-hour day for railway workers. The result stayed unclear for days, until Wilson narrowly carried California. He won a second term, again with under half the popular vote.

Worked example: the road to war in 1917

Question: what changed between Wilson's victory and April 1917? 1. On 22 January, Wilson called for "peace without victory", a settlement between equals; neither side was interested. 2. On 1 February, Germany resumed unrestricted submarine warfare, breaking the Sussex pledge and gambling that it could starve Britain before American troops arrived. Wilson broke off relations. 3. On 1 March, newspapers published the Zimmermann Telegram, intercepted by British intelligence, offering Mexico the return of Texas, New Mexico and Arizona if it joined a war against the United States. 4. In March, U-boats sank several American ships, and revolution in Russia overthrew the tsar, making the Allies look more democratic. 5. On 2 April, Wilson asked Congress for war, saying the world "must be made safe for democracy". 6. Congress voted for war by 6 April; 56 members voted no, including Jeannette Rankin, the first woman in Congress.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, treating Wilson as a non-interventionist across the board: he sent troops to Mexico, Haiti, the Dominican Republic and Cuba. Second, thinking the Lusitania sinking brought the United States straight into the war; it came almost two years earlier. Third, imagining that neutrality meant equal trade with both sides; the blockade tied American commerce and loans to the Allies. Fourth, giving one cause for American entry: submarine warfare was decisive, but the Zimmermann Telegram, economic ties and the Russian Revolution all mattered. Fifth, assuming Americans were united on the war.

Key takeaways

Wilson promised a moral foreign policy but intervened repeatedly in Mexico and the Caribbean. The First World War began in 1914 when an assassination set Europe's alliance system in motion, and it became a deadly war of trenches. The United States declared neutrality, but trade and loans bound it to the Allies, and Americans were divided by ancestry and politics. German submarine warfare, from the Lusitania in 1915 to the unrestricted campaign of 1917, together with the Zimmermann Telegram, led Congress to declare war on Germany in April 1917.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Moral diplomacy

Wilson's aim of a foreign policy guided by principle rather than power

In practice he still sent troops abroad often.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which statement best describes how American neutrality worked in practice between 1914 and 1917?

Question 2 of 5

Why did German submarine warfare strain relations with the United States more than the British blockade did?

Question 3 of 5

What was the Zimmermann Telegram?

Question 4 of 5

Which of these is the best evidence that Wilson's moral diplomacy differed from his actions?

Question 5 of 5

How long after the sinking of the Lusitania did the United States declare war on Germany?

← Previous topicNext topic →