US History › Section M · Depression and New Deal › Topic M.6

The Second New Deal

From 1935, squeezed by critics on the left and right and by a hostile Supreme Court, Roosevelt pushed through laws on jobs, pensions and union rights that built America's modern social safety net. Who those laws included and left out, and whether they ended the Depression, remain central questions for historians.

Pressure from the right and the Court

Business leaders and conservative Democrats formed the American Liberty League in 1934, accusing Roosevelt of leading the country towards socialism or dictatorship. The Supreme Court struck harder. In Schechter Poultry Corporation v. United States in May 1935, it unanimously struck down the National Industrial Recovery Act, ruling that Congress had handed too much lawmaking power to the president and had regulated business that was not interstate commerce. In United States v. Butler in January 1936, it struck down the Agricultural Adjustment Act's processing tax. Historians still debate whether the laws of 1935 marked a sharp new turn or a continuation of earlier aims.

Challengers from the left

Other critics said the New Deal did too little. Senator Huey Long of Louisiana promoted Share Our Wealth, a plan to cap great fortunes and guarantee every family a home allowance and a minimum income; his clubs claimed millions of members before he was assassinated in September 1935. Father Charles Coughlin, a Catholic radio priest with millions of listeners, turned against Roosevelt and later spread antisemitic views. Francis Townsend, a retired California doctor, proposed paying $200 a month to every retired American over 60, provided they spent it within a month. In 1934 the novelist Upton Sinclair lost a race for governor of California on a plan to End Poverty in California.

Jobs: the WPA and its offshoots

In April 1935 Congress passed the Emergency Relief Appropriation Act, about $4.9 billion, then the largest single spending bill in American history. Its centrepiece, the Works Progress Administration (WPA), led by Harry Hopkins, employed about 8.5 million people between 1935 and 1943, building roads, bridges, schools and parks. Its Federal One projects hired writers, artists and performers; the Federal Writers' Project recorded interviews with more than 2,000 formerly enslaved people. The National Youth Administration gave part-time jobs to students, and the Rural Electrification Administration brought power lines to farms, when only about one farm in ten had electricity.

The Social Security Act

Signed in August 1935, the Social Security Act created old-age insurance funded by payroll taxes on workers and employers; taxes began in 1937 and regular monthly pensions in 1940. It also set up unemployment insurance run jointly by the federal government and the states, and grants for aid to dependent children and to the blind. Labour Secretary Frances Perkins, the first woman in a presidential cabinet, chaired the committee that drafted it. Roosevelt chose payroll taxes partly so that workers would feel they had earned their benefits, making the programme hard to abolish. The act left out farmworkers and domestic servants, among others.

Unions, taxes and banks

The National Labor Relations Act of July 1935, known as the Wagner Act, replaced Section 7(a). It guaranteed the right to join unions and bargain collectively, banned unfair practices such as firing union members, and created the National Labor Relations Board to enforce it. John L. Lewis led the new Committee for Industrial Organization (CIO), renamed the Congress of Industrial Organizations in 1938, in organising whole industries, and a sit-down strike at General Motors in Flint, Michigan, in 1936-1937 won recognition of the autoworkers' union. The Revenue Act of 1935 raised taxes on the rich, and the Banking Act of 1935 concentrated Federal Reserve power in a Washington board.

Worked example: who did Social Security cover?

A cause-and-effect comparison of two hypothetical workers in 1937. 1. A white Detroit factory worker pays the new payroll tax, building a right to a pension. 2. A Black woman who cooks and cleans in an Atlanta household is a domestic servant, so she is excluded. 3. Pattern: because most Black workers then worked in farming or domestic service, a large majority of them were left out, along with many women and Mexican American farmworkers. 4. Debate: historians such as Ira Katznelson stress pressure from Southern Democrats who wanted to keep control over Black labour; others stress the difficulty of collecting taxes from farm and household workers. 5. Outcome: farm and domestic workers were added in the 1950s.

Landslide and the Court fight

In 1936 Roosevelt won about 61 percent of the popular vote and 523 electoral votes to 8 for Alf Landon, carrying every state except Maine and Vermont. His coalition now included most Black voters, union members and urban immigrant communities alongside the white South. In February 1937 he proposed adding up to six justices to the Supreme Court, one for each justice over 70 who did not retire. Critics called it court-packing. That spring the Court upheld a state minimum wage law, the Wagner Act and Social Security, and one conservative justice retired. The Senate shelved the plan in July, but the fight split Democrats.

Recession and the last reforms

Believing recovery was secure, Roosevelt cut spending in 1937, just as Social Security taxes began and the Federal Reserve doubled banks' reserve requirements. A sharp recession followed: unemployment rose from about 14 percent in 1937 to about 19 percent in 1938. In 1938 Roosevelt resumed heavy spending, an approach in line with the ideas of the British economist John Maynard Keynes. The Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938, the last major New Deal law, set a minimum wage of 25 cents an hour, rising to 40 cents, cut the standard workweek to 40 hours by 1940 with overtime pay, and banned most labour by children under 16 in covered industries.

Included and excluded

Black Americans gained from the New Deal yet faced discrimination within it. Mary McLeod Bethune led Black affairs at the National Youth Administration and joined other advisers in an informal Black Cabinet, and Eleanor Roosevelt pressed for fair treatment. But Roosevelt never backed a federal anti-lynching bill, fearing Southern Democrats. The Indian Reorganization Act of 1934, championed by Commissioner John Collier, ended the allotment of tribal land and encouraged tribal constitutions, though many nations, including the Navajo, rejected it. Women such as Perkins held high office, but relief jobs went mostly to men and often paid women less.

Worked example: did the New Deal end the Depression?

A cause-and-effect analysis. 1. Growth: output grew fast from 1933 to 1937 and again after 1938. 2. Jobs: unemployment was still about 15 percent in 1940, or under 10 percent if work-relief jobs are counted as employment. 3. War: mass unemployment ended only when spending for the Second World War soared in 1941-1942. 4. Interpretations: some economists say New Deal spending was too small; others say uncertainty about new regulations slowed investment; left-wing historians say it saved capitalism without reshaping it. 5. Conclusion: it did not by itself end the Depression, but it built lasting institutions and greatly expanded the federal government's role.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, saying Social Security covered all workers from the start; farm and domestic workers were excluded. Second, assuming the Supreme Court struck down the whole New Deal; it struck down the NRA and the AAA but upheld the Wagner Act and Social Security in 1937. Third, believing Congress passed the court-packing plan; it did not. Fourth, forgetting the 1937-1938 recession, which pushed unemployment back to about 19 percent. Fifth, treating Long, Coughlin and Townsend as conservative critics; they attacked the New Deal for doing too little.

Key takeaways

Critics on both sides and Court rulings against the NRA and AAA shaped the Second New Deal of 1935-1938. The WPA employed about 8.5 million people; Social Security created pensions, unemployment insurance and aid to dependent children but excluded farm and domestic workers. The Wagner Act protected unions. After the 1936 landslide, court-packing failed, though the Court began upholding New Deal laws. Spending cuts brought the 1937-1938 recession. The 1938 Fair Labor Standards Act set a minimum wage. Unemployment stayed high until war spending ended it.

Flashcards

Flashcard

American Liberty League

1934 group of business leaders and conservative Democrats opposing the New Deal

Accused Roosevelt of moving towards socialism.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Why were most Black workers left out of Social Security when it began?

Question 2 of 5

What happened to Roosevelt's 1937 plan to enlarge the Supreme Court?

Question 3 of 5

What caused the recession of 1937-1938, according to the reading?

Question 4 of 5

What did Huey Long, Charles Coughlin and Francis Townsend have in common?

Question 5 of 5

Which statement about the New Deal and the end of the Depression is best supported?

← Previous topicNext topic →