US History › Section M · Depression and New Deal › Topic M.5
The First New Deal
In 1933 and 1934 Roosevelt and a Democratic Congress rescued the banks, put millions to work and tried to lift farm and factory prices. The First New Deal was a burst of experiments rather than a single plan, and its results, uneven across groups, are still debated.
The Hundred Days
Between 9 March and 16 June 1933, a special session of Congress passed about fifteen major laws at Roosevelt's request, a period remembered as the Hundred Days. Teachers often sort the New Deal's aims into three Rs: relief for the needy, recovery of the economy and reform to prevent another collapse. That is a later shorthand: Roosevelt's advisers held conflicting ideas, from planning industry to breaking up big business, and many laws mixed all three aims. The common thread was a willingness to use federal power quickly and drop what failed.
Saving the banks
On 6 March 1933 Roosevelt declared a national bank holiday, closing every bank. On 9 March Congress passed the Emergency Banking Act within hours, allowing federal officials to inspect banks and reopen those judged sound, with Treasury and Federal Reserve support. On 12 March Roosevelt gave the first of his radio fireside chats, explaining plainly why money would be safer in a reopened bank than under a mattress. As banks reopened from the next day, deposits soon exceeded withdrawals, though thousands of weaker banks never reopened. Within two weeks Roosevelt also signed the Economy Act, cutting federal salaries and veterans' benefits.
Money and financial reform
In April 1933 Roosevelt ordered Americans to hand in most gold coins and certificates, and the dollar left the gold standard. Under the Gold Reserve Act of January 1934, Roosevelt fixed the price of gold at $35 an ounce, up from about $20.67, cutting the dollar's gold value by about 40 percent and allowing the money supply to expand. The Banking Act of 1933, known as Glass-Steagall, separated commercial from investment banking and created the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC), which from 1934 insured deposits up to $2,500. The Securities Act of 1933 required honest disclosure by companies selling shares, and in 1934 Congress created the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) to police the stock market.
Relief and jobs
The Federal Emergency Relief Administration (FERA), created in May 1933 with $500 million and run by Harry Hopkins, gave grants to states for relief. The Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC) enrolled unemployed young men, at first aged 18 to 25 and mostly from families on relief, to plant trees, fight fires and build park trails; they earned $30 a month, most of which went home to their families. About 3 million men served from 1933 to 1942, usually in racially segregated camps. In the winter of 1933-1934 the Civil Works Administration employed about 4 million people at its peak before it was closed over its cost.
Saving homes and farms
The Home Owners' Loan Corporation (HOLC), created in June 1933, replaced mortgages that owners could not pay with longer, cheaper loans, refinancing about a million homes. The Farm Credit Administration did the same for farms. The HOLC also drew maps grading neighbourhoods by lending risk, and it usually marked Black and many immigrant neighbourhoods as the riskiest, in red. Historians agree that these maps reflected and reinforced racial discrimination, the practice later called redlining, but debate how much the HOLC maps themselves shaped lending, compared with later Federal Housing Administration rules.
The Agricultural Adjustment Act
The Agricultural Adjustment Act of May 1933 tried to raise farm prices by cutting production. Farmers who agreed to grow less cotton, wheat, corn and other staples received payments, funded by a tax on processors such as flour mills and meatpackers. Because crops were already planted, in 1933 the government paid farmers to plough under about 10 million acres of cotton and slaughter about 6 million young pigs while many Americans went hungry. Prices and farm incomes rose, helped by drought. Payments went to landowners, however, and many cut acreage by evicting tenants and sharecroppers, a large share of them Black.
Worked example: the AAA and a sharecropping family
A hypothetical Arkansas cotton plantation in 1934, traced step by step. 1. The landowner signs an AAA contract to take a third of his cotton land out of production. 2. The government pays him for the idle acres; he is supposed to share the payment with his tenants. 3. With less land to farm, he needs fewer families, so he evicts a Black sharecropping family and keeps the whole payment. 4. The family loses both its home and its crop share and seeks day labour or relief. 5. Response: in 1934, Black and white sharecroppers in Arkansas formed the interracial Southern Tenant Farmers' Union to protest. 6. Conclusion: a programme that helped landowners could hurt the poorest farmers.
Planning industry: the NRA
The National Industrial Recovery Act of June 1933 suspended antitrust laws so that each industry could write a code of fair competition setting prices, output, wages and hours. The National Recovery Administration (NRA), led by Hugh Johnson, approved more than 500 codes, and firms that complied displayed a Blue Eagle emblem. Big firms often dominated the codes, and small businesses complained. Section 7(a) promised workers the right to bargain collectively through unions of their choice, and organising surged. In 1934 about 1.5 million workers struck, including violent strikes in Toledo, Minneapolis and San Francisco and a national textile strike.
Building: the PWA and the TVA
The same 1933 act created the Public Works Administration (PWA), which Interior Secretary Harold Ickes ran cautiously with about $3.3 billion, funding schools, hospitals, dams, New York's Triborough Bridge and even navy aircraft carriers. The Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA), created in May 1933, was a public corporation that built dams across a poor seven-state river basin to control floods, make cheap electricity and fertiliser, and reduce soil erosion. Private power companies attacked it as unfair competition. The dams brought electricity to many homes and farms but forced thousands of families off flooded land.
Worked example: did the First New Deal work?
A cause-and-effect analysis. 1. Banks: failures fell from about 4,000 in 1933 to about 60 in 1934, a clear success. 2. Output: real output grew strongly from 1933, and unemployment fell from about 25 percent in 1933 to about 20 percent in 1935. 3. Measurement: if people on work relief are counted as employed, as the economist Michael Darby argued they should be, unemployment was several points lower. 4. Causes: the economist Christina Romer credits mainly devaluation and a growing money supply, while others argue that NRA codes, by raising prices and wages, slowed recovery. 5. Conclusion: the First New Deal stopped the collapse and restored confidence, but full recovery remained far off.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, treating the New Deal as one master plan; it was a set of experiments built on competing ideas. Second, confusing the CCC with the CWA; the CCC enrolled young men for conservation work for years, while the CWA was a short-lived winter jobs programme. Third, saying the Securities Act created the SEC; the SEC came in 1934. Fourth, assuming the AAA helped all farmers; many tenants and sharecroppers were evicted. Fifth, saying unemployment was 25 percent throughout the 1930s; it fell after 1933, though it stayed high.
Key takeaways
A bank holiday, the Emergency Banking Act and the first fireside chat ended the banking panic, and Glass-Steagall created the FDIC. The dollar left gold and was devalued in 1934. FERA, the CCC and the CWA gave relief and jobs; the HOLC saved homes but its maps reflected racial discrimination. The AAA raised farm prices but displaced many sharecroppers. The NRA's codes and Section 7(a) sparked labour conflict, while the PWA and TVA built lasting public works. Recovery was real but incomplete.
Flashcards
Flashcard
9 March to 16 June 1933, when Congress passed about fifteen major New Deal laws
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
How did the Emergency Banking Act and the first fireside chat end the banking panic of 1933?
Question 2 of 5
Why did many sharecroppers suffer under the Agricultural Adjustment Act?
Question 3 of 5
What did Section 7(a) of the National Industrial Recovery Act promise?
Question 4 of 5
Which statement about unemployment under the First New Deal is accurate?
Question 5 of 5
Which programme was a public corporation that built dams to make electricity and control floods?
