US History › Section L · The Great War and the 1920s › Topic L.6
Transformation and backlash
Rapid change in the 1920s provoked a fierce reaction. Fear of immigrants, radicals and modern city life fed a controversial murder trial, strict immigration quotas, a mass revival of the Ku Klux Klan and a famous courtroom battle over evolution.
A nation divided over change
The 1920 census showed, for the first time, that slightly more Americans lived in towns and cities than in the countryside. Cities were home to most new immigrants, to jazz and nightclubs, to modern science and to looser social rules. Many rural and small-town Americans, especially white Protestants, felt that the country they knew was slipping away. The war had already taught them to fear disloyal foreigners, and the Red Scare had linked immigrants with radicalism. In the 1920s, that unease took several forms: nativism, the belief that native-born white Protestants were the true Americans; a revived Klan; and a religious movement that rejected modern ideas.
Nativism and fear of radicals
Between the 1880s and the First World War, millions of newcomers had come from Italy, Poland, Russia and neighbouring lands, mostly Catholic or Jewish, speaking Italian, Polish, Yiddish and other languages. Nativists claimed they could never become real Americans. Pseudo-scientific writers such as Madison Grant, author of The Passing of the Great Race (1916), ranked Europeans into superior and inferior "races", ideas linked to the eugenics movement. A few well-publicised anarchist bombings let critics treat whole communities as dangerous. This mood shaped courtrooms as well as laws, as the case of two Italian immigrants would show.
Worked example: Sacco and Vanzetti
Question: why did this trial become an international controversy? 1. Facts: in 1920, a paymaster and a guard were shot dead during a robbery in South Braintree, Massachusetts. Nicola Sacco and Bartolomeo Vanzetti, Italian immigrants and anarchists, were arrested carrying guns. 2. Evidence: the identifications were shaky and the ballistics disputed. 3. Atmosphere: the prosecution stressed their radical politics and their avoidance of the draft, and the judge showed open hostility to them. 4. Verdict: they were convicted in 1921 and, after years of failed appeals, executed in August 1927 amid protests worldwide. 5. Later views: historians still debate Sacco's guilt, but most agree the trial was unfair, and in 1977 the governor of Massachusetts proclaimed that it had been. Conclusion: prejudice against immigrants and radicals shaped the outcome.
Closing the gates
Congress acted on nativist fears with the first numerical limits on European immigration. The Emergency Quota Act of 1921 capped arrivals from each country at 3% of people born there living in the United States in 1910. The Johnson-Reed Act of 1924 cut the quota to 2% and based it on the 1890 census, before most southern and eastern Europeans had arrived, so Italian, Polish and Jewish immigration fell sharply. It also barred almost all immigration from Asia, ending Japanese immigration. Immigration from the Western Hemisphere was not capped, so Mexican immigration grew, and the new Border Patrol, also created in 1924, began policing the southern border.
The Birth of a Nation and a new Klan
In 1915, D. W. Griffith's film The Birth of a Nation, based on a 1905 novel by Thomas Dixon, portrayed Reconstruction as a time of Black misrule and the original Ku Klux Klan as heroic saviours of the white South. The NAACP protested across the country and won some cuts, but the film drew huge audiences. That November, William J. Simmons revived the Klan at a cross-burning on Stone Mountain, Georgia. The second Klan grew slowly until 1920, when professional recruiters began selling memberships for a $10 fee, with a share of each fee going to the recruiter. Growth then exploded.
The Klan's reach
The second Klan targeted Catholics, Jews and immigrants as well as Black Americans, and claimed to defend Prohibition, Protestant morality and "100 per cent Americanism". Estimates of its peak membership in the mid-1920s range from about two million to five million or more. Unlike the first Klan, it was strongest in the Midwest and West as well as the South, above all in Indiana. Many members were ordinary middle-class townspeople, and it had a large women's auxiliary. The Klan helped elect governors and legislators, and tens of thousands marched in robes down Pennsylvania Avenue in Washington in 1925. Its members still used threats, beatings and arson.
The Klan's decline
The Klan collapsed almost as quickly as it had grown. In 1925, D. C. Stephenson, the Klan's leader in Indiana, was convicted of murder after the rape and death of a young woman, Madge Oberholtzer, exposing the hypocrisy of an order that claimed to guard morality. Other scandals followed, and several states passed laws banning masks in public. The NAACP, Catholic organisations and Jewish groups such as the Anti-Defamation League campaigned against it, and some newspapers exposed it. Members drifted away, unwilling to pay dues to leaders who seemed corrupt. By about 1930, the Klan had fallen to a small fraction of its peak.
Fundamentalism and the old-time religion
Many Protestants also resisted modern ideas within their churches. Fundamentalists insisted that the Bible was literally true and opposed "modernists" who read it in the light of science and history. They saw the theory of evolution, now standard in biology textbooks, as an attack on faith and morality. Revivalists drew huge crowds. Billy Sunday, a former professional baseball player, preached against drink, dancing and modern doubt. In Los Angeles, Aimee Semple McPherson built a large congregation at her Angelus Temple and used radio and theatrical staging to spread an old message by modern means, showing that tradition and modern media could mix.
Worked example: the Scopes trial
Question: what did the 1925 trial in Dayton, Tennessee, decide, and what did it reveal? 1. Law: the Butler Act of March 1925 banned teaching in public schools that humans descended from "a lower order of animals". 2. Test case: the American Civil Liberties Union offered to defend any teacher who challenged it, and Dayton's leaders, hoping for publicity, recruited John Scopes, a young teacher. 3. Lawyers: William Jennings Bryan helped the prosecution; Clarence Darrow led the defence. 4. Drama: Darrow questioned Bryan as a Bible expert, exposing gaps in a literal reading. 5. Verdict: Scopes was convicted and fined $100, a decision overturned in 1927 on a technicality, while the law stayed until 1967. Conclusion: legally a small case, it exposed a deep divide between rural faith and urban modernism.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, imagining the second Klan as a purely Southern group focused only on Black Americans; it was strongest in states such as Indiana and also targeted Catholics, Jews and immigrants. Second, saying the 1924 act stopped all immigration; it targeted southern and eastern Europe and Asia but left Mexico and Canada uncapped. Third, treating Sacco and Vanzetti's guilt as settled either way; the debate continues, but the trial's unfairness is widely accepted. Fourth, thinking Scopes was acquitted; he was convicted, and only overturned on a technicality. Fifth, giving one precise Klan membership figure; estimates vary widely.
Key takeaways
Rapid urban change in the 1920s provoked a backlash from many rural, native-born white Protestants. Nativism shaped the Sacco and Vanzetti trial, executed in 1927, and the quota laws of 1921 and 1924, which cut immigration from southern and eastern Europe and barred most Asians. A second Klan, inspired partly by The Birth of a Nation, claimed millions of members across the North, West and South before collapsing in scandal. Fundamentalists fought evolution, and the 1925 Scopes trial exposed the gap between rural faith and urban modernism.
Flashcards
Flashcard
First count with more Americans in urban areas than rural ones
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Why did the Johnson-Reed Act of 1924 base its quotas on the 1890 census?
Question 2 of 5
Which statement about the second Ku Klux Klan of the 1920s is accurate?
Question 3 of 5
What is the best-supported historical judgement of the Sacco and Vanzetti case?
Question 4 of 5
What was the legal outcome of the 1925 Scopes trial?
Question 5 of 5
Which development did most to bring about the second Klan's rapid decline after 1925?
