US History › Section L · The Great War and the 1920s › Topic L.7

A new generation

Young Americans in the 1920s challenged their parents' rules in dress, dating and music. Women tested the meaning of their new right to vote, Black artists in Harlem proclaimed a "New Negro", Prohibition bred a lawless underground, and disillusioned writers questioned the whole American dream.

A youth culture

For the first time, large numbers of young Americans spent their teenage years together in high schools and colleges rather than at work, and they developed their own styles and slang. Many rejected the strict Victorian manners of their parents. Cars gave couples privacy, movies showed glamorous romance, and popular versions of Sigmund Freud's ideas suggested that sexual desire was natural rather than shameful. Older Americans worried about "petting parties", jazz and cigarettes. This new morality was strongest among urban, middle-class white youth; rural, working-class and religious families often kept to older ways.

Flappers

The flapper became the symbol of the decade: a young woman with bobbed hair, a knee-length dress, rolled stockings and make-up, who danced the Charleston, smoked and drank in public. Magazine covers and films spread the image far beyond the relatively small number of women who lived it fully. To admirers, the flapper stood for freedom and fun; to critics, for selfishness and moral decay. Historians often see the style as a claim to social equality to match the political equality of the vote. Yet it was also a fashion sold by advertisers, and it could be a new kind of conformity.

The "new woman" in public life

Women voted nationally from 1920, but they did not vote as a single bloc, and overall turnout in 1920 and 1924 was lower than before the war. Reformers kept working. The League of Women Voters, founded in 1920, educated new voters. The Sheppard-Towner Act of 1921 funded health clinics for mothers and babies, though Congress let it lapse in 1929. In 1923, Alice Paul's National Woman's Party proposed an Equal Rights Amendment, which made little progress. Margaret Sanger's American Birth Control League campaigned to make contraception legal and available. More women worked in offices and shops, usually for less pay than men.

The Jazz Age

Jazz grew from Black musical traditions, including blues, ragtime and brass bands, especially in New Orleans. Musicians carried it north during the Great Migration to Chicago, New York and other cities. Louis Armstrong's recordings made the improvised solo central to jazz, Duke Ellington led his orchestra at Harlem's Cotton Club, and Bessie Smith became the leading blues singer of the age. Records and radio spread the music across the nation and abroad, giving the decade its nickname. Yet many clubs, including the Cotton Club, featured Black performers for white-only audiences, and some critics condemned jazz as immoral.

Harlem and the New Negro

The Great Migration continued in the 1920s, as hundreds of thousands more Black Southerners moved north. Harlem, in northern Manhattan, became the largest Black urban community in the country and a centre of Black business, politics and art. Writers spoke of a "New Negro", proud, assertive and unwilling to accept second-class status, and the scholar Alain Locke collected their work in The New Negro (1925). Black veterans, migrants and the survivors of the 1919 riots shared a new determination. Northern life still brought segregated housing, job discrimination and police hostility, but it also offered better schools and the right to vote.

Worked example: "If We Must Die"

Source: a sonnet by the Jamaican-born poet Claude McKay, published in 1919. It opens, "If we must die, let it not be like hogs". 1. Context: McKay wrote it during the Red Summer, as white mobs attacked Black communities across the country. 2. Content: the speaker urges his people, outnumbered and hunted, to die fighting back rather than submit. 3. Form: McKay chose the sonnet, a traditional European form, to deliver a militant message, showing mastery of the very tradition used to exclude Black writers. 4. Reception: widely reprinted, it was read as a call to self-defence. 5. Significance: it is often seen as an early voice of the Harlem Renaissance. Conclusion: the poem joins artistic ambition to political resistance.

Writers and artists of Harlem

The Harlem Renaissance produced an outpouring of work. Langston Hughes, in collections such as The Weary Blues (1926), brought the rhythms of jazz and blues into poetry and wrote of ordinary Black life with pride. Zora Neale Hurston, a writer and anthropologist, collected the folklore of Black Southerners. Countee Cullen wrote polished lyric poetry, and the painter Aaron Douglas created bold images drawing on African art. Participants argued over purpose: W. E. B. Du Bois wanted art to advance civil rights, while younger writers insisted on freedom to portray Black life honestly, and many depended on white patrons.

Marcus Garvey and Black nationalism

Marcus Garvey, a Jamaican immigrant, built the largest Black mass movement of the era. His Universal Negro Improvement Association, based in Harlem, celebrated African heritage and Black beauty and urged economic independence through Black-owned businesses. It had hundreds of thousands of members, and claimed far more, mostly working people. Garvey promoted settlement in Africa and founded a shipping company, the Black Star Line, which failed. Leaders such as Du Bois, who favoured integration through the NAACP, attacked him as a demagogue. In 1923 Garvey was convicted of mail fraud over the sale of shares; he was imprisoned from 1925 and deported in 1927.

Worked example: how Prohibition fed organised crime

1. Law: from 1920, making and selling alcohol was illegal, but millions still wanted to drink. 2. Market: demand without legal supply created huge profits for anyone willing to break the law. 3. Supply: liquor was smuggled from Canada and the Caribbean, distilled illegally as "moonshine" and served in hidden bars called speakeasies. 4. Enforcement: federal agents were few and underpaid, and many police and officials took bribes. 5. Organisation: gangs fought for territory; in Chicago, Al Capone's organisation earned many millions a year, and the 1929 St. Valentine's Day Massacre showed its violence. 6. Outcome: Capone was jailed in 1931 for tax evasion, not bootlegging, and the Twenty-first Amendment repealed Prohibition in 1933. Conclusion: Prohibition probably cut drinking somewhat, but it also bred crime and contempt for law.

The Lost Generation

Many young writers felt that the war had destroyed old certainties. The writer Gertrude Stein called them a "lost generation", a phrase Ernest Hemingway used as an epigraph for The Sun Also Rises (1926). Several, including Hemingway, lived for a time in Paris. F. Scott Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby (1925) portrayed wealth, glamour and emptiness on Long Island. Sinclair Lewis satirised small-town conformity in Main Street (1920) and Babbitt (1922), and in 1930 became the first American to win the Nobel Prize in Literature. Their criticism of materialism shaped how later Americans remembered the decade.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, treating flappers as typical of all young women; the style was strongest in cities and among the middle class. Second, assuming the vote quickly transformed women's lives; turnout was low and many reforms stalled. Third, thinking jazz began in New York; it grew from Black Southern traditions, especially in New Orleans. Fourth, confusing Garvey's separatism with the NAACP's integrationism; their leaders clashed bitterly. Fifth, saying Prohibition simply failed to change anything; drinking probably fell somewhat, but crime and corruption rose.

Key takeaways

A youth culture of flappers, dating and jazz challenged older morals, mainly in cities. Women won the vote but found political gains limited, though reformers pursued health funding, an Equal Rights Amendment and birth control. Jazz spread from Black Southern roots to national fame. In Harlem, the New Negro movement produced writers such as McKay, Hughes and Hurston, and Garvey built a mass nationalist movement. Prohibition bred speakeasies and organised crime. Lost Generation writers voiced disillusionment with American materialism.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Flapper

1920s young woman with bobbed hair and short skirts who defied old manners

Symbol of the decade, spread by magazines and films.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which statement about the flapper image of the 1920s is most accurate?

Question 2 of 5

How did Marcus Garvey's movement differ from the approach of the NAACP?

Question 3 of 5

Why did Prohibition help organised crime to grow?

Question 4 of 5

What does Claude McKay's poem "If We Must Die" urge its readers to do?

Question 5 of 5

Which writer satirised small-town conformity in Main Street and Babbitt?

← Previous topicNext topic →