US History › Section E · Industry and Jacksonian democracy › Topic E.7
Majority rule and its critics
By the 1830s the majority had become a dominant force in American life. A French visitor warned that it could be as oppressive as any king, and mobs, Congress and the 1840 campaign all showed what majority rule could do, for good and ill.
The majority as a new power
Earlier topics showed white men gaining the vote, parties mobilising them, and Jackson claiming to speak for the people. But who protected those outside the majority? Native nations had just been removed with broad popular support, and abolitionists, free Black communities, Catholics and Mormons were all unpopular minorities. Critics asked whether a majority, unchecked by kings or aristocrats, could become a tyrant itself. The most famous answer came from a young French aristocrat who toured the country in 1831 and 1832.
Tocqueville's journey
Alexis de Tocqueville and his friend Gustave de Beaumont arrived in New York in May 1831, officially to study American prisons for the French government. Over about nine months they travelled through the Northeast, the Great Lakes, the Ohio and Mississippi valleys and parts of the South, interviewing politicians, lawyers and clergy. Near Memphis in December 1831, Tocqueville watched Choctaw families crossing the icy Mississippi by boat on their way west, a scene he later described with sorrow. He published Democracy in America in two volumes, in 1835 and 1840. It is still widely read as a classic study of American democracy.
What Tocqueville admired
Tocqueville believed democracy was the future for Europe as well as America, and he studied the United States to learn how it worked. He was struck by the "equality of conditions": Americans showed little of the deference to rank he knew in France. He praised local self-government, such as the New England town meeting, which taught citizens to manage their own affairs. He was impressed by voluntary associations, the countless societies Americans formed for churches, reforms, schools and business, which let individuals act together without waiting for the state.
The tyranny of the majority
Tocqueville's sharpest warning was about the tyranny of the majority. In America, he argued, legislatures, elected officials, juries and often judges all answered to the majority, so a person wronged by it had nowhere to turn. Worse, the majority's power reached beyond laws into thought itself: public opinion could make dissenters so isolated that few dared to speak against it, and he claimed to know of no country with less independence of mind. A king could control people's actions; a majority, he warned, could shape what they were willing to think. He judged slavery and race the gravest threat to the Union's future, and wrote with sorrow of Native peoples' fate.
Worked example: reading Tocqueville critically
Evaluate Democracy in America as historical evidence. 1. Author: a liberal French aristocrat whose family had suffered in the French Revolution, so he feared mob rule and hoped to tame democracy for France. 2. Method: interviews and observation during about nine months, mostly with educated men. 3. Strengths: a sharp outsider's eye for patterns Americans took for granted, such as associations and the pressure to conform. 4. Limits: a short stay, few conversations with women, enslaved people or workers, and conclusions written with French debates in mind. 5. Conclusion: valuable for understanding how democracy worked and felt, but to be tested against other sources. Check: these are the same questions to ask of any traveller's account.
Mobs against minorities
The 1830s saw a wave of crowd violence, much of it aimed at unpopular minorities. Anti-abolitionist mobs, often led by respectable merchants and lawyers, broke up meetings across the North; in Boston in 1835 a crowd dragged William Lloyd Garrison through the streets with a rope. In May 1838 a mob burned Pennsylvania Hall in Philadelphia days after it opened, during a national antislavery convention of women. Crowds attacked Black neighbourhoods and churches, and in 1834 a mob near Boston burned a Catholic convent. In 1838 Missouri's governor ordered Mormons to leave the state or be "exterminated". In each case rioters claimed to speak for the community.
Worked example: the killing of Elijah Lovejoy
Trace the causes and effects of one riot. 1. Elijah Lovejoy, a Presbyterian minister, published an antislavery newspaper, first in St. Louis and then across the river in Alton, Illinois. 2. Local mobs destroyed his presses three times, arguing that his views endangered the town's peace and trade with slaveholding Missouri. 3. In November 1837 Lovejoy and armed supporters guarded a new press; a mob attacked, set fire to the warehouse and shot him dead. 4. In the North the killing shocked many who had ignored abolitionists, because it now seemed free speech itself was under attack. 5. In Boston, the young lawyer Wendell Phillips gave his first antislavery speech at a protest meeting. Check: the mob aimed to silence a minority but enlarged it.
Silencing debate in government
Majorities also used official power to limit debate over slavery. In 1835 the American Anti-Slavery Society mailed pamphlets to the South; in Charleston a crowd seized and burned them, and Postmaster General Amos Kendall let southern postmasters refuse to deliver such mail. In 1836 the House of Representatives adopted the gag rule, which automatically tabled antislavery petitions without discussion. Many petitions were organised and signed by women, who could not vote but could petition. Former president John Quincy Adams, now a Massachusetts congressman, fought the gag rule as an attack on the right of petition until the House repealed it in 1844.
The second party system
By the late 1830s two national parties competed in every region, a pattern historians call the second party system. Democrats favoured limited federal government, opposed national banks and protective tariffs, and drew many small farmers, urban workers and Irish Catholic immigrants. Whigs favoured Clay's American System, a strong Congress over a strong president and often moral reform, and drew many merchants, manufacturers, commercial farmers and evangelical Protestants. Both parties had northern and southern wings, so both tried to keep slavery out of national debate. A small antislavery Liberty Party ran James G. Birney for president in 1840 and won few votes.
The log cabin campaign of 1840
With the country still in depression after the Panic of 1837, the Whigs nominated William Henry Harrison, the hero of Tippecanoe in 1811, with John Tyler of Virginia: "Tippecanoe and Tyler too!" When a Democratic newspaper sneered that Harrison would be content with a log cabin and hard cider, the Whigs adopted both as symbols, though he came from a wealthy Virginia planter family. They held huge rallies with parades, songs and log cabin floats, and invited women to attend and support the cause. About 80 percent of eligible voters turned out. Harrison beat Van Buren by 234 electoral votes to 60, but died about a month after taking office.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, Tocqueville did not reject democracy; he thought it was inevitable and wanted to make it safe for liberty. Second, the tyranny of the majority meant more than unjust laws; it included social pressure that silenced dissent. Third, the anti-abolitionist mobs were northern, not only southern, and were often led by prominent citizens. Fourth, the gag rule blocked discussion of petitions; it did not stop people from sending them. Fifth, the popular tale that the word "booze" comes from a Whig-era distiller is a myth; the word is centuries older.
Key takeaways
Tocqueville admired American equality, local self-government and voluntary associations, but warned that a majority could tyrannise minorities through law and opinion. The 1830s bore him out: mobs attacked abolitionists, Black communities, Catholics and Mormons, and killed Elijah Lovejoy in 1837, while the gag rule and the mails controversy limited debate. Whigs and Democrats built the second party system, and in 1840 the Whigs used mass campaigning to elect Harrison, with turnout of about 80 percent.
Flashcards
Flashcard
French aristocrat who toured the US in 1831 and 1832
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What did Tocqueville mean by the tyranny of the majority?
Question 2 of 5
What did the gag rule adopted by the House of Representatives in 1836 do?
Question 3 of 5
Who was Elijah Lovejoy?
Question 4 of 5
Why was the 1840 contest called the log cabin campaign?
Question 5 of 5
Which is the strongest reason to use Democracy in America with care as evidence about American life?
