US History › Section E · Industry and Jacksonian democracy › Topic E.6

Indian Removal

In the 1830s the United States forced tens of thousands of Native people from their homelands east of the Mississippi to land in the West. Removal was a deliberate federal policy, fought by Native nations in courts, in Congress and in war, and it cost thousands of lives.

A policy, not an accident

Removal was a government programme, not a natural result of settlement. Thomas Jefferson had suggested moving eastern nations west of the Mississippi, and the idea gained force as cotton spread across the Deep South. Andrew Jackson built his reputation fighting Native peoples. After defeating the Red Stick faction of the Muscogee (Creek) in 1814, he imposed the Treaty of Fort Jackson, which took around 23 million acres, including land from Muscogee who had fought on his side. As president, he made removal a central goal and called it a kindness that would save Native peoples from destruction. Popular culture, such as James Fenimore Cooper's novel The Last of the Mohicans (1826), often cast Native peoples as a vanishing race, which made removal seem inevitable to many white readers.

Nations in the way of cotton

In 1830 tens of thousands of people of five nations still lived in the Southeast: the Cherokee, Muscogee (Creek), Choctaw, Chickasaw and Seminole. White Americans later called them the "Five Civilized Tribes", a label historians now avoid. Many had adopted commercial farming and written laws, and some wealthy members enslaved Black people. The Cherokee used a syllabary devised by Sequoyah, adopted a constitution in 1827 and from 1828 published the Cherokee Phoenix in English and Cherokee. None of this protected them. Georgia extended its laws over Cherokee land, gold was found there in 1829, and the state planned lotteries to hand the land to white settlers.

The Indian Removal Act of 1830

Jackson signed the Indian Removal Act on 28 May 1830. It authorised the president to negotiate treaties exchanging Native lands in the East for land west of the Mississippi, in what became Indian Territory and later Oklahoma, and set aside $500,000 for the purpose. The act did not itself order removal, but federal pressure, state laws and settler violence left little real choice. It passed the House by just 102 votes to 97. Opponents included Senator Theodore Frelinghuysen of New Jersey and Congressman Davy Crockett of Tennessee, while Catharine Beecher organised one of the first national petition campaigns by American women against it.

The Cherokee go to court

The Cherokee sued Georgia. In Cherokee Nation v. Georgia (1831), Chief Justice John Marshall ruled that Native nations were not foreign states but "domestic dependent nations", so the Court could not hear their suit. A year later, in Worcester v. Georgia (1832), the missionary Samuel Worcester challenged his imprisonment under a Georgia law barring white people from Cherokee land without a state licence. Marshall ruled that Georgia's laws had no force inside the Cherokee Nation, because relations with Native nations belonged to the federal government. The ruling affirmed Cherokee sovereignty, but Georgia ignored it and Jackson did nothing to enforce it.

Worked example: a legal victory that changed nothing

Explain why winning Worcester v. Georgia did not save the Cherokee. 1. The Court could declare Georgia's law void but had no troops or officers of its own to enforce the decision. 2. Enforcement depended on the president, and Jackson supported removal. 3. In late 1832 Jackson needed southern support against South Carolina's nullifiers, so he had another reason not to confront Georgia. 4. Georgia released Worcester in 1833, ending the case without protecting Cherokee land, so pressure continued. Check: the famous line "John Marshall has made his decision; now let him enforce it" was reported decades later, and historians doubt Jackson said it.

Treaties under pressure

The other nations signed treaties one by one. The Choctaw ceded their Mississippi lands at Dancing Rabbit Creek in 1830 and moved west from 1831 to 1833, some in freezing winters with too little food. The Muscogee signed a treaty in 1832 promising them individual plots, but speculators and settlers stole much of the land through fraud; after fighting broke out in 1836, the army forced about 15,000 to 20,000 Muscogee west, some in chains. The Chickasaw sold their land and moved in 1837 and 1838, paying for their own removal. The Seminole resisted in the Second Seminole War, from 1835 to 1842.

The Cherokee Trail of Tears

In December 1835 a small Cherokee faction, the Treaty Party led by Major Ridge, John Ridge and Elias Boudinot, signed the Treaty of New Echota, agreeing to removal. They had no authority from the Cherokee government. Principal Chief John Ross and most Cherokee rejected it, and nearly 16,000 signed a petition against it, but in 1836 the Senate ratified it 31 to 15, exactly the two-thirds needed, so it passed by a single vote. After the May 1838 deadline, troops under General Winfield Scott forced about 16,000 Cherokee into disease-ridden stockades, and most travelled west in detachments through the autumn and winter of 1838 and 1839. Enslaved Black people held by Cherokee owners were forced along too.

Worked example: two Cherokee leaders

Compare the positions of John Ross and Elias Boudinot, both educated Cherokee leaders. 1. Ross argued that the nation's land was secured by treaties, that the Cherokee had a right to stay, and that New Echota was a fraud. 2. Boudinot, once editor of the Cherokee Phoenix, came to believe resistance was hopeless, and that a treaty would at least secure payment and land in the West. 3. Both aimed to preserve the Cherokee people; they differed on whether that was possible in the homeland. 4. Most Cherokee backed Ross. 5. In 1839, in the West, Boudinot and both Ridges were killed by Cherokee who saw the treaty as treason. Check: removal divided Native nations as well as Americans.

Counting the cost

Records were poor, so death tolls are estimates. For the Cherokee, historians most often cite about 4,000 deaths in the stockades, on the march and soon after arrival; some demographers put the total loss near 8,000 when lower births and later deaths are counted. Estimates for Choctaw deaths during removal run from about 2,500 to 6,000, and for the Muscogee about 3,500 or more. Across the whole removal era, roughly 1830 to 1850, historians estimate that some 60,000 to 100,000 Native people were forced west of the Mississippi, depending on which nations and years are counted. Even the lowest of these three estimates total about 10,000 deaths.

Removal in the North

Removal reached nations north of the Ohio River too. In 1832 the Sauk war leader Black Hawk led more than 1,000 Sauk and Meskwaki (Fox) people, including women and children, back across the Mississippi into Illinois, land they believed had been ceded unfairly. Militia and army troops pursued them, and at the Bad Axe River in August 1832 soldiers killed many as they tried to recross the river; historians estimate several hundred Sauk and Meskwaki died in the war. Over the next two decades the Potawatomi, Shawnee, Lenape (Delaware), Miami, Ho-Chunk, Wyandot and others were also pushed west.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, removal was not only the Cherokee story: the Choctaw, Muscogee, Chickasaw, Seminole and many northern nations were removed too. Second, the Removal Act authorised treaties; force came through pressured treaties and troops. Third, Worcester v. Georgia was a Cherokee victory that went unenforced. Fourth, death tolls are estimates with wide ranges, not exact numbers. Fifth, removal was not total: some Seminole stayed in Florida, and some Cherokee, Choctaw and others remained in the East.

Key takeaways

Indian Removal was a federal policy pushed by Jackson and land-hungry states. The 1830 act authorised exchange treaties; pressure, fraud and force did the rest. The Cherokee won in Worcester v. Georgia, but the ruling went unenforced, and after a minority signed the Treaty of New Echota, troops drove about 16,000 Cherokee west on the Trail of Tears, with an estimated 4,000 or more deaths. Other southeastern nations and northern peoples such as the Sauk suffered similar fates.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Indian Removal

Federal policy of forcing Native nations from the East to land west of the Mississippi

Peaked in the 1830s under Jackson.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

What did the Indian Removal Act of 1830 actually authorise?

Question 2 of 5

What did the Supreme Court rule in Worcester v. Georgia (1832)?

Question 3 of 5

Why did most Cherokee reject the Treaty of New Echota?

Question 4 of 5

Which nation resisted removal in a war lasting from 1835 to 1842?

Question 5 of 5

Why do historians give the Trail of Tears death toll as a range rather than an exact number?

← Previous topicNext topic →