US History › Section H · Civil War and Reconstruction › Topic H.4
Union victory
In 1864 and 1865 the Union turned its advantages in people and industry into victory, through relentless campaigns, the service of Black soldiers and Lincoln's re-election. The war ended slavery and preserved the Union, at a cost in lives that historians are still counting.
A Confederacy under strain
By 1864, the Confederacy was running out of the things it needed most. Its armies could not replace their losses, because its free population was far smaller than the North's. Inflation had made Confederate money nearly worthless, the blockade choked imports, and food was scarce in many towns. Desertion rose as soldiers' families wrote of hunger at home. Enslaved people kept escaping, weakening the labour system that fed the armies. The Union, by contrast, had mobilised its economy fully and could keep replacing men, weapons and supplies.
Europe stays out
Confederate hopes of European recognition never came true. Britain allowed Confederate agents to buy warships built in British yards, including the commerce raider CSS Alabama, but it refused to recognise the Confederacy or break the blockade. Once the Emancipation Proclamation made the war a fight against slavery, which Britain had abolished in its empire in the 1830s, intervention became politically far harder there. France's emperor, Napoleon III, used the war instead to send troops into Mexico and install the Austrian archduke Maximilian as emperor in 1864. That regime collapsed in 1867, after the United States, free of its own war, pressed France to withdraw.
Black soldiers in the Union army
After the Emancipation Proclamation, Black men enlisted in large numbers. About 180,000 served in the army, roughly a tenth of its total strength, in units called the United States Colored Troops, and about 18,000 more served in the navy. Most had been enslaved. They served under white officers and at first received less pay than white soldiers, a wrong Congress corrected in 1864 after protests. In July 1863, the 54th Massachusetts led a costly assault on Fort Wagner, near Charleston, which helped convince doubtful Northerners that Black troops would fight. Their service strengthened claims to citizenship after the war.
Fort Pillow and the prisoners
The Confederacy refused to treat captured Black soldiers as prisoners of war, threatening to enslave them or execute them and their officers. In April 1864, Confederate cavalry under Nathan Bedford Forrest overran Fort Pillow in Tennessee and killed many Black soldiers after they tried to surrender. The Union's insistence that Black prisoners be treated equally was a key reason the exchange of prisoners largely broke down. Prison camps on both sides became overcrowded and deadly. At Andersonville, in Georgia, about 13,000 Union prisoners died, mostly from disease, exposure and hunger.
Grant takes command
In March 1864, Lincoln made Ulysses S. Grant general-in-chief of all Union armies. Grant planned simultaneous offensives so the Confederates could not shift troops between threatened points. He directed the Overland Campaign against Lee in Virginia in person, travelling with George G. Meade's Army of the Potomac. At the Wilderness, Spotsylvania and Cold Harbor in May and June, Union losses were enormous, but instead of retreating after each battle, Grant kept moving south around Lee's flank. In mid-June he crossed the James River and began a siege of Petersburg, the rail centre that supplied Richmond. The siege lasted about nine months, with both armies dug into miles of trenches.
Worked example: a strategy of attrition
Question: why did Grant keep attacking despite terrible losses? 1. Evidence: in about six weeks of the Overland Campaign, Union casualties numbered roughly 55,000, against perhaps 30,000 or more for Lee. 2. Numbers: the Union could replace its losses through volunteers, bounties and the draft; the Confederacy could not. 3. Strategy: by never letting go, Grant kept Lee pinned in Virginia, unable to send help to Georgia. 4. Cost: Northern newspapers called Grant a butcher, and war weariness grew. 5. Conclusion: attrition was brutal but suited the Union's advantage in manpower, provided Northern voters were willing to continue the war.
Sherman's march
In the West, William T. Sherman advanced from Tennessee into Georgia and captured Atlanta, a vital rail and supply hub, on 2 September 1864. In November he cut loose from his supply lines and marched about 60,000 men across Georgia to the sea, living off the land and destroying railways, factories, crops and livestock. Savannah fell in late December. In 1865 he turned north through the Carolinas, where much of Columbia burned. Sherman's aim was to break the South's capacity and will to fight. Thousands of enslaved people freed themselves by following his columns.
The election of 1864
In the summer of 1864, Lincoln expected to lose. Casualty lists from Virginia were long, and many Northerners were tired of war. The Democrats nominated George B. McClellan on a platform calling for an end to the fighting, while Republicans and pro-war Democrats ran Lincoln with Andrew Johnson, a Unionist Democrat from Tennessee. Then the capture of Atlanta, a naval victory at Mobile Bay and Philip Sheridan's success in the Shenandoah Valley changed the mood. In November, Lincoln won about 55% of the popular vote and all but three states, with strong support from soldiers. The war would continue until the Confederacy surrendered.
Worked example: counting the dead
How many died? 1. The traditional figure, about 620,000 soldiers, came from estimates compiled from incomplete army records after the war. 2. In 2011, the historian J. David Hacker used census data instead, comparing how many men of military age survived from one census to the next with normal peacetime survival. 3. His estimate was about 750,000 deaths, with a wide margin of uncertainty. 4. Why higher: records missed many deaths from disease, deaths after discharge, and Confederate losses, whose paperwork was often lost. 5. Conclusion: historians now give a range of about 620,000 to 750,000, roughly as many as in all other American wars combined. Roughly two-thirds died of disease.
The war ends
In early April 1865, Lee abandoned Petersburg and Richmond and tried to escape west. Grant's forces cut him off, and on 9 April Lee surrendered the Army of Northern Virginia at Appomattox Court House. Grant's terms were generous: Confederate soldiers were paroled and allowed to go home. Joseph E. Johnston surrendered to Sherman in North Carolina later in April, and other forces gave up through the spring; the Cherokee general Stand Watie was among the last, in June. On 19 June 1865, Union troops arriving in Galveston announced that enslaved people in Texas were free, a day now marked as Juneteenth.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, citing a single precise death toll: historians give a range of about 620,000 to 750,000. Second, assuming Lincoln's re-election was certain; until Atlanta fell, he and many others expected defeat. Third, ignoring the roughly 180,000 Black soldiers, most of them formerly enslaved, who fought for the Union. Fourth, thinking Britain or France openly fought for the Confederacy; neither recognised it. Fifth, treating Appomattox as the end of every Confederate force; surrenders continued into June 1865.
Key takeaways
By 1864, the Confederacy faced shortages of men, money and food, and Europe stayed out of the war. About 180,000 Black soldiers served in the Union army despite unequal treatment and Confederate atrocities such as Fort Pillow. Grant's attrition campaign pinned Lee at Petersburg, while Sherman took Atlanta and marched to the sea. Victories in late 1864 re-elected Lincoln. Lee surrendered at Appomattox on 9 April 1865. Between about 620,000 and 750,000 soldiers died, most of them from disease.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Confederate commerce raider built in Britain
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Why do historians now give Civil War deaths as a range of about 620,000 to 750,000 rather than one figure?
Question 2 of 5
What best explains Grant's strategy of continuing to attack in the Overland Campaign despite heavy losses?
Question 3 of 5
Which events in late 1864 did most to secure Lincoln's re-election?
Question 4 of 5
What happened at Fort Pillow in April 1864?
Question 5 of 5
What does Juneteenth commemorate?
