US History › Section H · Civil War and Reconstruction › Topic H.5

Restoring the Union

Winning the war answered two questions: the Union would survive, and slavery would end. It left open harder ones. On what terms would the defeated states return, who would set those terms, and what would freedom mean for about four million people who had been enslaved?

The questions of 1865

Reconstruction, the period from roughly 1865 to 1877, was the attempt to answer those questions. Three groups had very different answers. Many white Southerners wanted to return quickly with as little change as possible, keeping control of land and labour. Most Republicans wanted proof of loyalty and an end to slavery, and a growing number wanted rights for freed people. Freed people themselves wanted land, education, family security and a voice in government. The first conflict was over who had the authority to decide: the president, who had pardoned rebels in wartime, or Congress, which decided whether to seat a state's elected members.

Lincoln's Ten Percent Plan

Lincoln began planning for reunion long before the war ended. In December 1863 he offered a pardon to most Confederates, excluding high-ranking civil and military leaders, if they swore future loyalty to the Union and accepted emancipation. Once loyal voters equal to 10% of a state's 1860 electorate had taken the oath, they could form a new state government, which had to abolish slavery. Lincoln's view was that the states had never legally left the Union, so the task was to restore loyal governments quickly. Louisiana, Arkansas and Tennessee formed governments under the plan, but Congress refused to seat their members.

The Radical challenge: Wade-Davis

Radical Republicans, a powerful faction in Congress, thought Lincoln's plan far too lenient. In July 1864, Congress passed the Wade-Davis Bill, named after Senator Benjamin Wade of Ohio and Representative Henry Winter Davis of Maryland. It required a majority of a state's white men, not 10%, to swear loyalty before a state could be restored, and only men who could take the Ironclad Oath, swearing they had never voluntarily supported the rebellion, could take part in writing its new constitution. Lincoln killed the bill with a pocket veto, leaving it unsigned after Congress adjourned. Its authors publicly accused him of overstepping his authority.

Worked example: comparing two plans

Question: what does the gap between Lincoln's plan and the Wade-Davis Bill reveal? 1. Threshold: 10% of voters against a majority. 2. Oath: a promise of future loyalty against a sworn denial of past disloyalty. 3. Assumption: Lincoln treated the war as a rebellion by individuals inside states that never left; the Radicals treated the states as having forfeited their normal rights. 4. Aim: Lincoln wanted to weaken the Confederacy and speed reunion while the war continued; the Radicals wanted to keep former rebels out of power. 5. Conclusion: the disagreement was about both how fast to reunite and who should hold power in the South afterwards.

The Thirteenth Amendment

The Emancipation Proclamation was a war measure that left slavery legal in the border states, and it might be challenged in peacetime. To end slavery permanently, Republicans made a constitutional amendment part of their 1864 platform. The Senate passed it in April 1864, but it stalled in the House until Lincoln pressed hard after his re-election, and the House approved it on 31 January 1865. Ratified in December 1865, the Thirteenth Amendment abolished slavery and involuntary servitude throughout the United States, freeing those still enslaved in Kentucky and Delaware. It also gave Congress power to enforce it, a first step in expanding federal protection of rights.

Worked example: one clause, long consequences

Source: the Thirteenth Amendment bans slavery and involuntary servitude "except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted". 1. Plain meaning: forced labour stayed lawful for people convicted of crimes. 2. Intent: the wording followed older laws such as the Northwest Ordinance of 1787, and historians find little sign that lawmakers debated it. 3. Use: within a year, Southern states passed vagrancy and other laws aimed at freed people; over the following years they hired out convicted prisoners to planters and companies, a system called convict leasing. 4. Conclusion: a clause written to end slavery left an exception that was soon used to force Black people back into unpaid labour.

Freedom in practice

Freed people acted at once on their freedom. Many travelled long distances searching for relatives sold away, placed notices in newspapers, and legalised marriages that slavery had not recognised. They founded churches, set up schools and moved off the plantations they had been held on. Above all, many wanted land of their own. In January 1865, General Sherman's Field Order No. 15 set aside coastal land from South Carolina to Florida in plots of up to 40 acres, and about 40,000 freed people settled there. News of freedom spread unevenly: in Texas it was announced only on 19 June 1865.

The assassination of Lincoln

On 11 April 1865, Lincoln gave his last public speech, suggesting that the vote might be extended to educated Black men and to Black soldiers. Three days later, on 14 April, John Wilkes Booth, an actor and Confederate sympathiser, shot him at Ford's Theatre in Washington; Lincoln died the next morning. In the same plot, Secretary of State William Seward was stabbed but survived, and a planned attack on Vice President Andrew Johnson never happened. Union troops cornered and killed Booth on 26 April, and a military commission convicted eight conspirators, four of whom were hanged. Historians still debate how Lincoln's own plans would have developed.

Andrew Johnson's plan

Johnson, a Unionist Democrat from Tennessee, had risen from poverty and despised the planter elite, but he held firmly to white supremacy and opposed federal action for Black rights. In May 1865 he offered amnesty to most Confederates who swore loyalty, but excluded leaders and owners of taxable property worth more than $20,000, who had to apply to him personally. He then issued thousands of such pardons. States had to declare secession void, abolish slavery, ratify the Thirteenth Amendment and refuse to pay Confederate debts. He did not require any vote for Black men, and he ordered most land held by freed people returned to its former owners.

Congress refuses to accept the result

Under Johnson's terms, Southern voters, all of them white, elected many former Confederate officials. Georgia's legislature even chose Alexander Stephens, the Confederacy's vice president, for the Senate. The new state governments also passed Black Codes, laws restricting freed people's lives, which the next topic examines. When Congress met in December 1865, Johnson declared that the Union was restored. Republicans disagreed: they refused to seat the members elected under his plan and set up a Joint Committee on Reconstruction to investigate conditions in the South. The struggle between the president and Congress over Reconstruction had begun.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, thinking the Emancipation Proclamation ended slavery everywhere; the Thirteenth Amendment did that in December 1865. Second, overlooking its exception for punishment of crime, which made convict leasing possible. Third, assuming Johnson, as a Southern Democrat who disliked planters, wanted to help freed people; he opposed Black rights. Fourth, treating Lincoln's lenient plan as his final word; it was a wartime measure, and he was considering limited Black voting when he died. Fifth, ignoring freed people's own actions in claiming freedom.

Key takeaways

Reconstruction began with disputes over the terms of reunion and who would set them. Lincoln's Ten Percent Plan of 1863 offered easy terms; the Radicals' Wade-Davis Bill demanded a majority oath, and Lincoln pocket-vetoed it. The Thirteenth Amendment, ratified in December 1865, abolished slavery except as punishment for crime. Freed people sought family, schools, churches and land. Lincoln was assassinated in April 1865. Johnson pardoned many ex-Confederates and ignored Black rights, and Congress refused to seat the Southern members elected under his plan.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Reconstruction

The period, about 1865 to 1877, of reuniting the nation and defining freedom

The first fight was over who set the terms.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

How did the Wade-Davis Bill differ from Lincoln's Ten Percent Plan?

Question 2 of 5

Why did Republicans think a constitutional amendment was needed even after the Emancipation Proclamation?

Question 3 of 5

Which part of the Thirteenth Amendment allowed forced labour to continue in a new form?

Question 4 of 5

What did Andrew Johnson's Reconstruction plan require of the former Confederate states?

Question 5 of 5

Why did Congress refuse to seat the Southern members elected under Johnson's plan?

← Previous topicNext topic →