US History › Section J · Cities and Gilded Age politics › Topic J.7
Social and labor unrest in the 1890s
In 1893 the country fell into the worst depression it had yet known. Marches of the unemployed, a nationwide railway strike and the fierce election of 1896 tested whether the farmers' revolt could become a national movement.
The Panic of 1893
Early in 1893 the Philadelphia and Reading Railroad went bankrupt, and in May the collapse of the National Cordage Company set off a stock market panic. Railways had been built far ahead of the traffic needed to pay for them, and as they failed, the banks and steel mills that depended on them failed too. Several of the biggest lines, including the Northern Pacific and the Union Pacific, passed into receivership. Investors at home and in Britain feared the United States might abandon gold, and they withdrew funds. An estimated 15,000 businesses and hundreds of banks failed.
Hard times and Cleveland's response
Estimates of unemployment in 1894 range from about 12% to nearly 20% of the workforce, and the depression lasted until about 1897. There was no federal unemployment relief; families relied on charities, churches, city soup kitchens and political machines. President Cleveland blamed the Sherman Silver Purchase Act for draining the Treasury's gold and persuaded Congress to repeal it in 1893, splitting his party. In 1895 he arranged for bankers led by J. P. Morgan to supply gold in exchange for government bonds, which angered silver supporters. A modest income tax passed in 1894 was struck down by the Supreme Court in 1895.
Coxey's Army
Jacob Coxey, a businessman from Massillon, Ohio, proposed that the federal government hire the unemployed to build roads, paid for with $500 million in new paper money. In March 1894 he set out for Washington with about a hundred followers, and by the time the "army" arrived on 1 May it numbered perhaps 500. Similar groups set out from the West, some seizing trains along the way. In Washington, police arrested Coxey for walking on the Capitol lawn, and Congress ignored his plan. The march failed, but it helped popularise the idea of federal public works for the jobless.
The Pullman Strike
George Pullman built a company town near Chicago for the workers who made his sleeping cars, and the company owned every house. After 1893 the company cut wages by around a quarter without lowering rents. In May 1894 workers struck and turned to the American Railway Union, founded in 1893 by Eugene V. Debs to unite all railway workers regardless of craft. The union nonetheless voted to exclude Black workers. In late June its members refused to handle any train carrying Pullman cars. The boycott spread to roughly 250,000 workers in about 27 states and halted traffic across much of the country, especially in the West.
Worked example: how the government broke the strike
Trace the cause and effect. 1. Trains carried both Pullman cars and the United States mail, so the boycott stopped mail deliveries. 2. Attorney General Richard Olney, a former railway lawyer, obtained a federal court injunction on 2 July ordering the union to stop interfering with the mail and with interstate commerce, partly under the Sherman Antitrust Act. 3. Cleveland sent federal troops to Chicago on 4 July, over the protests of Illinois governor John Peter Altgeld. 4. Rioting, burning of railway cars and clashes followed, and about 30 people died nationwide. 5. Debs was jailed for six months for defying the injunction. 6. Conclusion: courts and troops could break a national strike, and the union collapsed.
The Democrats turn to silver
By 1896 silver Democrats from the South and West had turned against Cleveland. At the party's Chicago convention, William Jennings Bryan, a 36-year-old former congressman from Nebraska, defended farmers and workers as true producers of wealth and ended by warning gold's defenders not to "crucify mankind upon a cross of gold". The speech won him the nomination on a free-silver platform. Pro-gold Democrats broke away and ran their own candidate. The Populists faced a dilemma: run their own nominee and split the silver vote, or endorse Bryan and risk losing their identity. They chose Bryan, but nominated Tom Watson for vice president instead of the Democrats' choice.
The battle of 1896
The Republicans nominated William McKinley, a former governor of Ohio and author of the 1890 tariff, on a gold and protection platform. His manager, Mark Hanna, raised several million dollars from business, many times what Bryan had. McKinley spoke to delegations from his front porch in Canton, Ohio, while Bryan travelled about 18,000 miles by train and gave hundreds of speeches. Turnout was very high. McKinley won about 51% of the popular vote, the first winner with a majority since 1872, and 271 electoral votes to Bryan's 176. Bryan swept the South and much of the West, but McKinley carried the industrial Northeast and Midwest.
Why the Populists faded
Bryan lost the cities. Many factory workers feared that silver inflation would raise food prices faster than wages, and some employers warned that mills would close if he won. Many Catholic and immigrant voters were also uneasy with his evangelical style. Fusion with the Democrats left the Populists without a separate purpose, and the party soon withered. Gold discoveries in South Africa and the Klondike region of Canada's Yukon, together with new methods of extracting gold, expanded the money supply after 1896, and prices recovered. The Gold Standard Act of 1900 made gold the legal basis of the dollar. Yet many Populist demands returned in the Progressive Era.
Worked example: is Oz a Populist parable?
L. Frank Baum published The Wonderful Wizard of Oz in 1900. In 1964 a teacher, Henry Littlefield, argued that it was an allegory of Populism. 1. Claimed parallels: the Scarecrow as the farmer, the Tin Woodman as the industrial worker, the Cowardly Lion as Bryan, the humbug Wizard as Washington's politicians, and Dorothy's silver shoes on a yellow brick road as silver and gold. 2. Evidence for: Baum had lived in Dakota during the farm crisis and worked as a journalist. 3. Evidence against: Baum never said the story was political, and his own politics are unclear. 4. Conclusion: the reading is a useful teaching device, but most historians doubt Baum intended it.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming the federal government gave relief to the jobless in the 1890s; it gave none. Second, thinking the Pullman Strike stayed in one town; the boycott was national. Third, believing troops were sent at Illinois's request; Governor Altgeld protested. Fourth, calling Bryan the Populists' own creation; he was the Democratic nominee whom the Populists endorsed. Fifth, placing the Klondike gold rush in Alaska; the Klondike is in Canada's Yukon, though many prospectors passed through Alaska.
Key takeaways
Railway overbuilding and fears for the gold standard set off the Panic of 1893 and a depression lasting until about 1897. Cleveland repealed the Sherman Silver Purchase Act and turned to J. P. Morgan for gold. Coxey's Army (1894) asked for public works and was ignored. The Pullman boycott was broken by an injunction and federal troops, and Debs was jailed. In 1896 the Democrats and Populists backed Bryan and free silver, but McKinley won a clear majority with business money and urban votes. Fusion, recovery and new gold ended the Populist Party, though its ideas lived on.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Financial collapse that began the worst depression the country had yet known
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What did Coxey's Army ask the federal government to do in 1894?
Question 2 of 5
Why did the Pullman workers' grievance become a national crisis in 1894?
Question 3 of 5
Which statement about the federal response to the Pullman Strike is accurate?
Question 4 of 5
Why did the Populists endorse William Jennings Bryan in 1896?
Question 5 of 5
Which factor helps explain why McKinley beat Bryan in 1896?
