US History › Section J · Cities and Gilded Age politics › Topic J.6
Farmers and the Populist revolt
Squeezed by falling prices, high freight rates and debt, American farmers organised first into the Grange, then into the Farmers' Alliances, and finally into a new political party. The Populists lost elections but set much of the next generation's reform agenda.
Hard times on the farm
Farmers were still the largest group of Americans, and many were losing ground. Wheat and cotton prices fell for most of the years from the early 1880s to the mid-1890s; cotton fell from over 10 cents a pound around 1880 to about 7 cents or less in the mid-1890s. Yet farmers' costs did not fall as fast. They owed fixed mortgage payments and interest, paid high freight rates and bought tools at prices raised by protective tariffs. Plains farmers also suffered a run of droughts from the late 1880s. Many concluded that the economic system itself was stacked against them.
Why prices fell and costs rose
Several forces combined. New machinery and millions of acres of newly settled land raised American output. Farmers in Canada, Argentina, Russia, India and Australia also sold into the same world markets. When prices dropped, many families planted even more to cover their debts, which pushed prices lower still. Where only one railway served a town, it could charge what it liked, and grain elevator owners set storage fees. In the South, the crop lien system described in the previous section kept sharecroppers and small owners in debt to merchants. Deflation, explained in the previous topic, made every debt heavier.
The Grange
In 1867 Oliver Hudson Kelley, a clerk in the federal Department of Agriculture, founded the Patrons of Husbandry, known as the Grange. It began as a social and educational society to break the isolation of rural life, and it admitted women as full members. It grew quickly in the 1870s, reaching an estimated 800,000 members by the middle of the decade. Granges set up cooperatives to buy tools and supplies in bulk and to sell crops together, cutting out middlemen. Many cooperatives later failed for lack of capital and business experience, and membership declined.
Granger laws and the Greenbackers
In the early 1870s, farmers, often allied with local merchants, persuaded Illinois, Iowa, Minnesota and Wisconsin to pass Granger laws setting maximum rates for railways and grain elevators. In Munn v. Illinois (1877), the Supreme Court upheld such regulation of businesses serving the public. But the Wabash decision of 1886 barred states from regulating rates on traffic between states. Some farmers backed the Greenback Party, formed in the mid-1870s to keep paper money in circulation and expand the currency. In 1878 Greenback-Labor candidates won more than a dozen House seats, and James B. Weaver ran as its presidential candidate in 1880.
The Farmers' Alliances
In the 1880s larger organisations took over. The Southern Farmers' Alliance, founded in Texas, grew rapidly after Charles Macune became its leader in the late 1880s. A separate Northwestern Alliance organised the Plains. Because the Southern Alliance admitted only white members, Black farmers formed the Colored Farmers' National Alliance in Texas in 1886. The alliances sent travelling lecturers from town to town, teaching farmers about money, credit and railways, and they built cooperative stores and exchanges. Both the Southern and Colored alliances claimed more than a million members by about 1890, though such figures were probably inflated.
The subtreasury plan
Macune's most ambitious idea was the subtreasury plan, presented in 1889. The federal government would build warehouses in farming counties. Farmers could store crops that would not spoil, such as cotton and wheat, and borrow up to 80% of their market value at low interest. They could then wait to sell until prices rose, instead of dumping crops at harvest when prices were lowest, and the loans would expand the money supply. Congress refused to consider it, partly because many members thought the government should not lend to farmers. New Deal farm programmes in the 1930s later made loans on stored crops.
Race, women and the movement
Women lectured, wrote and organised for the alliances, and speakers such as Mary Elizabeth Lease of Kansas became nationally famous. Some Populists, including Georgia's Tom Watson, argued that Black and white farmers shared the same economic enemies. In 1892 Watson called on armed white Populists to protect a Black Populist preacher threatened by a lynch mob. But cooperation was fragile. When the Colored Alliance backed a cotton pickers' strike in 1891, white posses in Arkansas killed an estimated 15 strikers. Watson himself later turned to vicious racism. Southern Democrats attacked Populists by stirring white fears of Black political power.
From alliance to party
Frustrated by both major parties, alliance members entered politics. In 1890 they helped elect governors, state legislators and several members of Congress, through independent parties on the Plains and by capturing Democratic nominations in the South. In 1891 and 1892, delegates founded the national People's Party, whose members were called Populists. At Omaha, Nebraska, on 4 July 1892, the party adopted a platform whose preamble, written by Ignatius Donnelly, denounced a nation "brought to the verge of moral, political, and material ruin". It nominated James B. Weaver, a former Union general, with a former Confederate officer as his running mate.
Worked example: reading the Omaha Platform
1. Author and purpose: a national convention of farmers and some labour delegates, seeking voters from both sections. 2. Economic demands: free coinage of silver at 16 to 1, a larger currency, a graduated income tax, the subtreasury plan, postal savings banks, and government ownership of railways, telegraphs and telephones. 3. Political demands, in attached resolutions: direct election of senators, the secret ballot, an eight-hour day for government workers and immigration restriction. 4. What it reveals: Populists saw monopolies and bankers as enemies of producers. 5. Outcome: within about 20 years the secret ballot spread to most states, and the 16th and 17th Amendments (1913) brought a federal income tax and direct election of senators. 6. Conclusion: a losing party wrote much of the future agenda.
Worked example: explaining the 1892 result
Weaver won just over a million votes and 22 electoral votes, while Grover Cleveland won the presidency again. Why did Populists not do better? 1. Strength: they carried Kansas, Colorado, Idaho and Nevada, where farmers and silver miners were desperate. 2. The South: Democrats used fraud, intimidation and race-baiting, and many white farmers stayed loyal to the party of white supremacy. 3. Cities: most industrial workers saw little in a farmers' party and feared that inflation would raise food prices. 4. Old loyalties: Northern farmers tied to the Republicans by war memories often stayed put. 5. Conclusion: the Populists were strong regionally but lacked a national coalition.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, blaming farmers' troubles on a single cause; world markets, overproduction, freight rates, debt and deflation all mattered. Second, confusing the Grange of the 1870s with the alliances of the 1880s. Third, assuming the alliances were integrated; Black farmers had a separate Colored Alliance. Fourth, thinking the subtreasury plan was adopted at the time; Congress ignored it. Fifth, dismissing the Populists as failures; many of their demands later became law.
Key takeaways
Falling crop prices, high railway rates, debt, tariffs and deflation hurt farmers in the late 1800s. The Grange (1867) built cooperatives and won state Granger laws, upheld in Munn v. Illinois but limited by the Wabash case. The Southern, Northwestern and Colored alliances spread cooperatives and proposed the subtreasury plan. In 1892 the People's Party adopted the Omaha Platform, demanding silver, an income tax, government-owned railways and direct election of senators. Weaver won over a million votes, but race, regional loyalties and urban indifference limited the party.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Patrons of Husbandry, farmers' society founded in 1867 by Oliver Hudson Kelley
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Why did many farmers keep planting more even as crop prices fell?
Question 2 of 5
What was the effect of the Wabash decision of 1886?
Question 3 of 5
How was the subtreasury plan supposed to help farmers?
Question 4 of 5
Why did Black farmers form the Colored Farmers' National Alliance?
Question 5 of 5
Which Omaha Platform demand later became law through a constitutional amendment?
