US History › Section O · The 1960s and 1970s › Topic O.6

Vietnam: escalation to withdrawal

Richard Nixon promised "peace with honor" in Vietnam, but American troops took more than four years to leave, the war spread into Cambodia, and protest at home turned deadly. The war ended in a communist victory in 1975 and left deep scars on Vietnam, on the veterans and on Americans' trust in their government.

Nixon inherits the war

When Nixon took office in January 1969, more than half a million American troops were in Vietnam. Johnson's escalation after the Gulf of Tonkin Resolution, followed by the shock of the Tet Offensive in 1968, had convinced many Americans that the war could not be won at an acceptable cost. Peace talks had begun in Paris but made little progress. Nixon wanted to bring troops home without appearing to abandon South Vietnam, because he believed a plain defeat would damage American credibility with allies and rivals. His solution was to withdraw slowly while using heavy force to push North Vietnam towards a settlement.

A brutal war on all sides

US commanders fought a war of attrition, measuring progress partly by body counts of enemy dead, which encouraged inflated numbers and the killing of civilians counted as fighters. American forces burned villages suspected of sheltering guerrillas, dropped napalm and sprayed the herbicide Agent Orange, which later harmed the health of Vietnamese people and US veterans. North Vietnamese and Viet Cong forces also used terror: they assassinated village officials, and during Tet they killed thousands of civilians in the city of Hue. Captured Americans were often tortured. Many US soldiers, fighting an enemy hard to tell apart from civilians, grew bitter and disillusioned.

My Lai

On 16 March 1968, soldiers of Charlie Company, part of the Americal Division, entered the village of My Lai expecting to find Viet Cong fighters. They met no resistance, yet they killed an estimated 347 to 504 unarmed civilians, mostly women, children and old men. A helicopter pilot, Warrant Officer Hugh Thompson, landed, shielded some villagers and reported the killings. The army covered up the massacre until a former soldier, Ron Ridenhour, wrote to members of Congress in 1969 and the journalist Seymour Hersh reported it. Lieutenant William Calley was convicted of murder in 1971, the only soldier found guilty. Many Americans protested his sentence, Nixon had him moved to house arrest, and he was paroled in 1974.

Vietnamization and Cambodia

Nixon's plan, called Vietnamization, was to train and equip South Vietnam's army to take over the fighting while US troops left. American troop numbers fell from a peak of about 543,000 in 1969 to under 30,000 by the end of 1972. At the same time, Nixon widened the war. From 1969, US planes secretly bombed North Vietnamese bases and supply routes in neutral Cambodia, hidden from Congress and the public, and bombing of supply routes in Laos increased. On 30 April 1970, he announced on television that US and South Vietnamese troops had entered Cambodia. To critics it looked like expansion, not withdrawal, and it set off the largest wave of campus protest of the war.

Kent State and Jackson State, 1970

At Kent State University in Ohio, protests over Cambodia included the burning of the campus military training building, and the governor sent in the National Guard. On 4 May 1970, guardsmen fired on a crowd of students, killing four and wounding nine; some of the dead were simply walking between classes. Hundreds of colleges shut down as students went on strike. Opinion was divided: polls showed many Americans blamed the students, and in New York construction workers attacked antiwar marchers. On 15 May, police fired on a dormitory at Jackson State College, a historically Black college in Mississippi, killing two young men. That killing drew far less national attention.

Worked example: was the draft fair?

Cause-and-effect analysis of who served. 1. Under the draft, young men could be deferred while in college or in certain jobs. 2. College was easier to reach for wealthier families, so working-class and poor men were more likely to be drafted and to serve in combat. 3. In the early years, Black soldiers made up a larger share of combat deaths than of the population, which civil rights leaders condemned. 4. Draft calls grew with escalation, and anger at the system fed protest and draft resistance. 5. In December 1969, a lottery based on birth dates replaced much of the old system, and student deferments were later phased out. 6. Result: the draft ended in 1973, and the military became an all-volunteer force.

Worked example: the Pentagon Papers

Source analysis. 1. What: a secret Defense Department history of US decisions in Vietnam from 1945 to 1967, ordered by Robert McNamara. 2. Who leaked it: Daniel Ellsberg, a former analyst who had worked on it and turned against the war; The New York Times began publishing it in June 1971. 3. What it showed: presidents from Truman to Johnson had deepened involvement while telling the public less than they knew, including planning wider war in 1964 as Johnson campaigned on restraint. 4. Government response: Nixon's administration went to court to stop publication. 5. Outcome: on 30 June 1971, the Supreme Court ruled 6 to 3 that the newspapers could publish. 6. Significance: trust fell further, and Nixon's anger at leaks soon led to illegal White House operations.

The Paris Peace Accords, 1973

Nixon's openings to China and the Soviet Union in 1972 reduced Hanoi's backing from its patrons. When North Vietnam launched a major offensive in spring 1972, Nixon resumed heavy bombing of the North and mined Haiphong harbour. After talks stalled again, he ordered intense bombing of Hanoi and Haiphong in December, known as the Christmas bombing. On 27 January 1973, the United States, North and South Vietnam and the Viet Cong signed the Paris Peace Accords. US forces would leave within 60 days and prisoners of war would be returned, but North Vietnamese troops were allowed to stay in the South. Henry Kissinger and North Vietnam's Le Duc Tho had negotiated the deal.

The fall of Saigon and the costs

Fighting resumed between North and South almost at once. Congress, wary after years of war, passed the War Powers Resolution over Nixon's veto in November 1973, requiring presidents to report troop deployments within 48 hours and withdraw them within 60 to 90 days without congressional approval. In 1975, Congress refused further major aid, and North Vietnam's final offensive swept south. On 30 April 1975, Saigon fell as helicopters evacuated the last Americans and some South Vietnamese allies from the embassy. About 58,000 Americans died. Vietnamese deaths are estimated at well over a million, with some estimates near 3 million. Cambodia fell to the Khmer Rouge, whose rule killed an estimated 1.5 to 2 million people, and an estimated million or more Vietnamese later fled abroad.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, thinking Nixon ended the war quickly; US troops stayed until 1973, and he widened the war into Cambodia. Second, assuming only American forces committed atrocities, or only the other side did; both did. Third, treating the Paris Accords as the end of the war; fighting continued until Saigon fell in 1975. Fourth, assuming the Pentagon Papers exposed Nixon's own decisions; the study ended in 1967, before he took office. Fifth, forgetting Jackson State, where two young Black men were killed eleven days after Kent State.

Key takeaways

Nixon pursued Vietnamization, cutting US troops from about 543,000 to under 30,000, while bombing and invading Cambodia. My Lai revealed atrocities and a cover-up. The Cambodian invasion led to the killings at Kent State and Jackson State in May 1970. Draft inequality fed protest, and the draft ended in 1973. The Pentagon Papers showed earlier presidents had misled the public. The Paris Peace Accords of 1973 ended US involvement, the War Powers Resolution limited presidents, and Saigon fell in 1975.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Peace with honor

Nixon's goal of leaving Vietnam without appearing to abandon the South

Withdraw slowly, pressure the North hard.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

What was Vietnamization?

Question 2 of 5

What set off the wave of campus protest that led to the Kent State shootings?

Question 3 of 5

Why did many working-class men end up fighting in Vietnam?

Question 4 of 5

What did the Pentagon Papers reveal?

Question 5 of 5

What happened after the Paris Peace Accords of 1973?

← Previous topicNext topic →