US History › Section O · The 1960s and 1970s › Topic O.7
Watergate
A burglary at the Democratic Party's offices in 1972 grew into what many historians call one of the gravest constitutional crises in American history. The cover-up, exposed by reporters, judges, prosecutors and Congress, led Richard Nixon to become the only president to resign, and it left a lasting mark on Americans' trust in government.
Why Watergate matters
Watergate is the name for a group of abuses of power by President Nixon's White House and re-election campaign, and the attempt to hide them. It takes its name from the Watergate office complex in Washington, DC. The crisis tested whether a president could be held to the law. In the end, a free press, federal courts, a special prosecutor and both houses of Congress, including many members of Nixon's own party, each played a part. The scandal also arrived when trust was already falling after Vietnam, and it deepened that loss of faith.
The election of 1972
After the chaos of 1968, a Democratic commission led by Senator George McGovern rewrote the party's rules, so that convention delegates were chosen mainly through primaries and caucuses open to ordinary voters, with more women, minorities and young people. Shirley Chisholm became the first Black woman to seek a major party's presidential nomination. McGovern himself, a strong opponent of the war, won the nomination, but his campaign stumbled when his first running mate, Thomas Eagleton, withdrew after revelations about past treatment for depression. Nixon, helped by détente and troop withdrawals, won about 61 percent of the popular vote and 520 electoral votes to 17.
The plumbers and dirty tricks
Nixon's White House saw its opponents as enemies and kept a list of them. After the Pentagon Papers leak in 1971, aides formed a secret unit known as the plumbers, because their job was to stop leaks. In September 1971 the plumbers broke into the office of Daniel Ellsberg's psychiatrist, hoping to find material to discredit him. The Committee to Re-elect the President, known as CREEP, raised large sums, some secretly, and funded "dirty tricks" against Democrats, such as a forged letter that damaged Senator Edmund Muskie before the New Hampshire primary.
The break-in
In the early hours of 17 June 1972, police arrested five men inside the Democratic National Committee's offices at the Watergate, carrying cameras and bugging equipment. One, James McCord, was CREEP's security chief, and the operation had been planned by the former plumbers G. Gordon Liddy and E. Howard Hunt, then working for CREEP. Nixon's press secretary, Ron Ziegler, dismissed it as a "third-rate burglary attempt", and the White House denied involvement. Two young Washington Post reporters, Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein, kept digging, helped by a secret source they called Deep Throat, revealed in 2005 as Mark Felt, the FBI's second-ranking official. The story had little effect on the November election.
The cover-up unravels, 1973
In January 1973, the burglars, Hunt and Liddy were convicted or pleaded guilty, and Judge John Sirica pressed for the full story; McCord then wrote that others were involved and that witnesses had lied. In April, Nixon's top aides H. R. Haldeman and John Ehrlichman resigned, and he fired his counsel, John Dean. The new attorney general, Elliot Richardson, appointed Archibald Cox as special prosecutor. From May, a Senate committee chaired by Sam Ervin held televised hearings. Dean testified that Nixon had known of the cover-up. Then, in July, the aide Alexander Butterfield revealed that a hidden system had recorded conversations in the Oval Office. The tapes could show who was telling the truth.
The Saturday Night Massacre
Nixon refused to hand over the tapes, claiming executive privilege, the right to keep some presidential communications confidential. When Cox kept demanding them, Nixon ordered him fired on 20 October 1973. Richardson and his deputy, William Ruckelshaus, resigned rather than carry out the order, and the third-ranking official, Robert Bork, fired Cox. A storm of public anger followed, the House began an impeachment inquiry, and a new special prosecutor, Leon Jaworski, continued the case. Separately, Vice President Spiro Agnew had resigned that October over tax evasion linked to bribes, and Nixon named Gerald Ford to replace him under the Twenty-Fifth Amendment.
Worked example: United States v. Nixon
Legal analysis of the 1974 tapes case. 1. Question: must a president obey a subpoena for evidence in a criminal trial? 2. Nixon's argument: executive privilege is absolute, and courts cannot decide what a president must release. 3. Prosecutor's argument: a general claim of confidentiality cannot block evidence needed for justice in a criminal case. 4. Ruling: on 24 July 1974, the Supreme Court ruled 8 to 0 against Nixon. Executive privilege exists, the justices held, but it is not absolute. 5. Effect: Nixon had to release the tapes. 6. Significance: the ruling confirmed that no president is above the law and that the courts decide the limits of presidential power.
Resignation
In late July 1974, the House Judiciary Committee approved three articles of impeachment, charging Nixon with obstruction of justice, abuse of power and contempt of Congress. Several Republicans on the committee voted in favour. On 5 August, Nixon released a tape of 23 June 1972, six days after the break-in, on which he approved a plan to have the CIA ask the FBI to halt its investigation. This smoking gun proved he had joined the cover-up almost at once. Republican leaders told him that he would be impeached and probably removed. On 8 August, Nixon announced his resignation, which took effect at noon the next day.
Worked example: why did a burglary topple a president?
Cause-and-effect analysis. 1. The break-in itself was small, and Nixon was likely to win in 1972 anyway. 2. The cover-up was the fatal step: paying the burglars, lying to investigators and using the CIA against the FBI were crimes. 3. Investigative reporting kept the story alive when it faded elsewhere. 4. A judge, a special prosecutor and a Senate committee forced out testimony. 5. The tapes turned claims into evidence, and the Supreme Court ordered their release. 6. Congress, including members of the president's party, moved to impeach. Conclusion: many historians judge that checks and balances worked, but slowly and only because many separate institutions acted.
Ford and the aftermath
Gerald Ford, sworn in on 9 August 1974, was the only president never elected as president or vice president. He told the nation, "Our long national nightmare is over." A month later he gave Nixon a full pardon, saying the country needed to move on; many suspected a deal, and his popularity fell sharply. Congress passed reforms: limits on campaign contributions and a Federal Election Commission, a stronger Freedom of Information Act and, in 1978, a law allowing court-appointed special prosecutors, later called independent counsels. Ford faced inflation and recession, signed the Helsinki Accords on borders and human rights with the Soviet Union in 1975, and saw Congress refuse more aid to South Vietnam.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, thinking Nixon was impeached; the House committee approved articles, but he resigned before the full House voted. Second, believing the break-in alone ended his presidency; the cover-up did. Third, saying Watergate hurt Nixon in 1972; he won a landslide before the cover-up unravelled. Fourth, crediting only the reporters; courts, prosecutors and Congress were essential. Fifth, assuming Ford was elected vice president; Nixon appointed him under the Twenty-Fifth Amendment.
Key takeaways
The plumbers and CREEP broke laws to stop leaks and win in 1972. Five men were arrested at the Watergate in June 1972, but Nixon won a landslide. Reporters, Judge Sirica, the Ervin committee and special prosecutors exposed the cover-up, and Butterfield revealed the tapes. After the Saturday Night Massacre, United States v. Nixon forced release of the tapes, and the smoking gun led Nixon to resign in August 1974. Ford pardoned him, and Congress passed reforms to limit abuses of power.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Abuses of power by Nixon's White House and campaign, and their cover-up
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Why did Alexander Butterfield's testimony in July 1973 change the investigation?
Question 2 of 5
What did the Supreme Court decide in United States v. Nixon (1974)?
Question 3 of 5
What did the "smoking gun" tape of 23 June 1972 show?
Question 4 of 5
Which statement about the end of Nixon's presidency is accurate?
Question 5 of 5
Why did Ford's pardon of Nixon damage Ford politically?
