US History › Section D · Building a republic › Topic D.6
The War of 1812
Caught between Britain and Napoleon's France, the United States tried trade restrictions and then war. The War of 1812 settled little on paper, but it broke much of the Native resistance east of the Mississippi, fatally weakened the Federalist Party and left Americans more confident in their nation.
A neutral nation squeezed
From 1803, Britain and Napoleon's France fought a world war, and each tried to stop neutral ships from trading with the other. British orders in council and French decrees led both sides to seize American ships. Britain added impressment: short of sailors, its navy stopped American ships and took off men it claimed were British deserters, and several thousand American citizens were among them. In June 1807, the British warship Leopard fired on the American frigate Chesapeake off Virginia, killing three men and seizing four. Jefferson answered with the Embargo Act of December 1807, which barred American ships from sailing to foreign ports.
The embargo backfires
Jefferson hoped that losing American trade would force Britain and France to respect neutral rights. Instead, the embargo hurt Americans most. Exports fell from about $108 million in 1807 to about $22 million in 1808, sailors lost work, and New England's ports suffered badly. Smuggling across the Canadian border and by sea was widespread, and Federalists revived in the Northeast. In March 1809, Congress replaced the embargo with the Non-Intercourse Act, which reopened trade with every nation except Britain and France. Neither power changed course, and James Madison, president from 1809, inherited the crisis.
Tecumseh and the Prophet
In the Old Northwest, settlers and land cessions were squeezing Native nations. Two Shawnee brothers offered a response. Tenskwatawa, known as the Prophet, preached a spiritual revival: Native peoples should reject alcohol and American goods and ways. In 1808 the brothers founded Prophetstown, on the Tippecanoe River, which drew people from many nations. Tecumseh worked to unite those nations politically, arguing that Native land belonged to all of them and that no single group could sell it, as some leaders had in the 1809 Treaty of Fort Wayne. In November 1811, while Tecumseh was away recruiting, Governor William Henry Harrison's troops fought the Battle of Tippecanoe and then burned Prophetstown.
Worked example: why Congress chose war
Weigh the causes of the June 1812 declaration. 1. Maritime grievances: impressment and seizures under the orders in council insulted American sovereignty and hurt trade. 2. The frontier: Americans blamed British agents in Canada for arming Native resistance, and some hoped to conquer Canada. 3. Honour: young Democratic-Republican war hawks such as Henry Clay of Kentucky and John C. Calhoun of South Carolina argued that the republic must defend itself or lose respect. 4. The vote: the House voted 79 to 49 and the Senate 19 to 13, with every Federalist opposed. 5. The irony: New England, the region most exposed to seizures at sea, opposed the war, and Britain was suspending its orders in council in the same week Congress acted, too late for the news to cross the Atlantic.
Failure in Canada, victory on the lakes
American plans to invade Canada quickly failed. In August 1812, General William Hull surrendered Detroit to a British and Native force that included Tecumseh's warriors, and an invasion across the Niagara River failed in October when militiamen refused to leave American soil. At sea, the frigate USS Constitution won morale-raising duels, but the Royal Navy soon blockaded the coast. In 1813 the tide turned in the West. Oliver Hazard Perry's squadron won the Battle of Lake Erie in September, giving Americans control of the lake, and Harrison's army then defeated British and Native forces at the Battle of the Thames in October, where Tecumseh was killed. His confederacy did not survive him.
The Creek War
The war also reached the Southeast. Among the Creeks, a militant faction called the Red Sticks, influenced by Tecumseh's message, fought both American expansion and Creeks who accommodated it, and in August 1813 they killed hundreds of people at Fort Mims in present-day Alabama. Andrew Jackson led Tennessee militia, with Cherokee and allied Creek warriors, against them and crushed the Red Sticks at Horseshoe Bend in March 1814. The Treaty of Fort Jackson that August forced the whole Creek Nation, including Jackson's own Creek allies, to cede about 23 million acres of land.
Britain strikes back in 1814
Napoleon's abdication in April 1814 freed British veterans for America. In August, after routing American militia at Bladensburg, British troops burned the Capitol, the President's House and other public buildings in Washington, partly in retaliation for the American burning of York, now Toronto, in 1813. The attack on Baltimore failed in September, when Fort McHenry withstood a night of bombardment, inspiring Francis Scott Key's poem that became the national anthem in 1931. Days earlier, an American naval victory on Lake Champlain had turned back an invasion from Canada at Plattsburgh. In the Chesapeake, perhaps 3,000 to 4,000 enslaved people escaped to British ships, some of them serving as Colonial Marines.
Hartford and Ghent
New England Federalists, angry at a war that ruined their trade, sent twenty-six delegates to Hartford, Connecticut, from December 1814 to January 1815. Some radicals spoke of secession, but the convention's report proposed constitutional amendments instead: ending the three-fifths clause, requiring a two-thirds vote of Congress to declare war or admit new states, and limiting presidents to one term. Meanwhile, diplomats at Ghent, in present-day Belgium, signed a peace treaty on 24 December 1814. It restored prewar boundaries and said nothing about impressment or neutral rights, which faded as issues once the war in Europe ended.
Worked example: the Battle of New Orleans
Ask why a battle fought after the peace mattered. 1. Timing: news crossed the Atlantic slowly, so a British army attacked New Orleans on 8 January 1815, two weeks after the treaty was signed. 2. Status: the treaty took effect only when both governments ratified it, which the Senate did in February 1815. 3. The battle: Jackson's mixed force of regulars, militia, free Black volunteers, Choctaw warriors and Jean Lafitte's privateers inflicted about 2,000 British casualties, including about 300 dead, and suffered fewer than 100. 4. Memory: arriving with news of peace, the victory let Americans feel they had won. 5. Consequences: Jackson became a national hero, while the Hartford proposals reached Washington just in time to make the Federalists look disloyal.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, thinking the Treaty of Ghent gave the United States new land or ended impressment: it restored prewar borders and was silent on impressment. Second, believing the Battle of New Orleans won the war: the treaty had already been signed. Third, assuming New England led the call for war because of its shipping losses: New England Federalists opposed the war, while southern and western war hawks drove it. Fourth, describing the Hartford Convention as a vote to secede: it proposed constitutional amendments. Fifth, leaving out Native nations: they lost the most, as British support vanished and their land was taken.
Key takeaways
British impressment and both powers' seizures of American ships led Jefferson to the self-damaging Embargo of 1807. Tecumseh and Tenskwatawa built a Native confederacy that Harrison attacked at Tippecanoe in 1811. War hawks pushed a divided Congress to declare war in June 1812. Invasions of Canada failed, but Lake Erie and the Thames, where Tecumseh died, secured the Northwest, and Jackson crushed the Red Sticks. Britain burned Washington but failed at Baltimore and Plattsburgh. The Treaty of Ghent restored prewar borders, New Orleans made Jackson a hero, and the Hartford Convention discredited the Federalists.
Flashcards
Flashcard
The British navy taking sailors, including American citizens, from American ships
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What was the main effect of the Embargo Act of 1807?
Question 2 of 5
What did Tecumseh try to achieve?
Question 3 of 5
Which group most strongly opposed the declaration of war in 1812?
Question 4 of 5
What did the Treaty of Ghent provide?
Question 5 of 5
Why did the Battle of New Orleans matter even though it came after the Treaty of Ghent was signed?
