US History › Section D · Building a republic › Topic D.5
The new republic and partisan politics
In the 1790s, revolutions abroad, rebellion at home and war on the frontier tested the new government, and every crisis deepened the quarrel between Federalists and Democratic-Republicans. By 1801 power had passed peacefully from one party to the other, something few republics had managed.
Revolution in France divides Americans
The French Revolution began in 1789, and at first most Americans welcomed it. Opinion split after France executed Louis XVI in January 1793 and entered the Terror, a period of mass executions of suspected enemies. Democratic-Republicans saw a sister republic fighting kings; Federalists saw mob rule. When France went to war with Britain in 1793, Washington proclaimed American neutrality. The French envoy Edmond-Charles Genêt ignored it, commissioning American privateers to raid British shipping and recruiting volunteers to attack Spanish lands. Washington demanded his recall. Meanwhile, Britain seized hundreds of American ships trading with the French Caribbean, and war with Britain seemed close.
Jay's Treaty and Pinckney's Treaty
Washington sent Chief Justice John Jay to London, and the treaty he signed in 1794 avoided war. Britain agreed to leave its forts in the Northwest by 1796 and to refer ship seizures and prewar debts to joint commissions; a clause allowing limited trade with the British West Indies was so restrictive that the Senate struck it out. But the treaty did not end impressment, the British navy's practice of forcing sailors from American ships into its service, nor compensate slaveholders for people who had left with the British in 1783. Democratic-Republicans denounced it as a surrender to Britain; the Senate approved it in 1795 by exactly the two-thirds needed. Spain, fearing an Anglo-American alliance, then signed Pinckney's Treaty, opening the Mississippi and the port of New Orleans to American trade.
The Haitian Revolution
In 1791, enslaved people in the French colony of Saint-Domingue rose up in the largest slave revolt in the Americas. France abolished slavery throughout its empire in 1794, and Toussaint Louverture, a formerly enslaved man, became the colony's leading commander, fighting off Spanish and British invaders. In 1804, after Napoleon's attempt to restore slavery failed, Jean-Jacques Dessalines declared Haiti independent, the first Black-led republic. Thousands of refugees, White and Black, free and enslaved, reached American ports. For enslaved Americans the revolution was a beacon; for White southerners it was a terror that hardened their fear of antislavery talk.
Worked example: the Whiskey Rebellion
Trace the causes and effects. 1. The tax: in 1791 Congress passed Hamilton's excise on distilled spirits. 2. Why it hurt the West: farmers in western Pennsylvania turned surplus grain into whiskey, which was easier to carry over the mountains and often served as money, so the tax fell on their main cash product. 3. Escalation: in July 1794, armed men attacked the house of a federal tax inspector, and thousands gathered near Pittsburgh. 4. Response: Washington called up about 13,000 militiamen from four states, and the rebellion collapsed without a battle. 5. Effects: two men convicted of treason were pardoned, federal authority was upheld, and Federalists blamed Democratic-Republican societies, while many westerners turned to Jefferson's party.
War for the Ohio country
North of the Ohio River, a Western Confederacy of Native nations, led by figures such as Little Turtle of the Miami and Blue Jacket of the Shawnee, defended their lands against settlers. They defeated American armies in 1790 and again in 1791, when Arthur St. Clair's force suffered one of the worst defeats in the army's history. Washington then sent Anthony Wayne with a trained army, which won the Battle of Fallen Timbers in August 1794; a nearby British fort refused to help the Native fighters. In the Treaty of Greenville of 1795, the confederacy ceded most of present-day Ohio.
Washington steps down
Washington declined a third term, setting a two-term tradition that lasted until 1940. His Farewell Address, published in September 1796, warned Americans against the spirit of party and against permanent alliances with foreign powers. The election of 1796 was the first contested by organised parties. Each elector cast two votes, and the runner-up became vice president, so Federalist John Adams won the presidency with 71 electoral votes while his rival Jefferson, with 68, became his vice president.
The XYZ affair and the Quasi-War
Angered by Jay's Treaty, France began seizing American ships. In 1797 Adams sent three envoys to Paris, but agents of the foreign minister, Talleyrand, demanded a large bribe and a loan before talks could begin. When Adams released the envoys' reports in 1798, with the agents' names replaced by the letters X, Y and Z, Americans were furious. Congress built up the navy, and from 1798 to 1800 the two countries fought an undeclared naval war, the Quasi-War. Adams then sent a new mission instead of seeking full war, and the Convention of 1800 restored peace and ended the 1778 alliance, though it split his party.
The Alien and Sedition Acts
In 1798 the Federalist Congress passed four laws. One raised the residence requirement for citizenship to fourteen years; two let the president deport foreigners judged dangerous, or enemy aliens in wartime; and the Sedition Act punished false and malicious writing against the government, Congress or the president with fines and prison. About ten people were convicted, mostly Democratic-Republican editors and printers; Congressman Matthew Lyon of Vermont was re-elected from jail. In reply, Jefferson and Madison secretly wrote the Kentucky and Virginia Resolutions, arguing that states could judge federal laws unconstitutional. Kentucky later used the word nullification, but other states rejected the resolutions.
Worked example: the election of 1800
Follow the problem and its solution. 1. The rule: each elector still cast two votes without saying which was for president. 2. The result: Democratic-Republican electors gave Jefferson and his running mate Aaron Burr 73 votes each, while Adams received 65. 3. The tie: the House, voting by state delegations, needed thirty-six ballots in February 1801 to choose Jefferson; Hamilton, who distrusted Burr, helped tip it. 4. The fix: the Twelfth Amendment of 1804 gave electors separate votes for president and vice president. 5. Significance: power passed peacefully between rival parties. Some historians add that the three-fifths clause's extra southern electoral votes helped decide the result.
Jefferson in power
Jefferson cut internal taxes, including the whiskey excise, and shrank the army, navy and debt, though he fought Tripoli, a Barbary state, from 1801 to 1805 to protect shipping. Before leaving office, Adams had appointed many Federalist judges, and Jefferson's administration withheld some commissions. In Marbury v. Madison (1803), Chief Justice John Marshall ruled that William Marbury deserved his commission, but that the part of the Judiciary Act of 1789 he sued under was unconstitutional, establishing judicial review. In 1803 Jefferson also bought Louisiana from France for $15 million, a purchase covered in a later section. In 1804 Burr killed Hamilton in a duel.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, thinking Jay's Treaty ended impressment: the issue stayed open and helped cause the War of 1812. Second, assuming Adams wanted full war with France: he chose negotiation. Third, believing the Sedition Act protected all federal officials: it covered the president and Congress but not the vice president, who was the opposition leader Jefferson. Fourth, saying Toussaint Louverture declared Haiti's independence: he died in a French prison in 1803, and Dessalines declared it in 1804. Fifth, thinking the 1800 tie was between Jefferson and Adams: it was between Jefferson and Burr.
Key takeaways
The French Revolution split Americans by party, while Washington held to neutrality. Jay's Treaty avoided war with Britain but not impressment, and led to Pinckney's Treaty with Spain. The Haitian Revolution alarmed slaveholders. Washington crushed the Whiskey Rebellion and Wayne defeated the Western Confederacy. Adams faced the XYZ affair and the Quasi-War, and Federalists passed the Alien and Sedition Acts, provoking the Kentucky and Virginia Resolutions. The Jefferson-Burr tie of 1800 led to the Twelfth Amendment, and Marbury v. Madison established judicial review.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Washington's declaration that the US would not take sides in the war between France and Britain
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Why did Democratic-Republicans condemn Jay's Treaty?
Question 2 of 5
What did Washington's response to the Whiskey Rebellion demonstrate?
Question 3 of 5
What was the XYZ affair?
Question 4 of 5
What did the Kentucky and Virginia Resolutions argue?
Question 5 of 5
Why did the election of 1800 lead to the Twelfth Amendment?
