US History › Section P · From the Reagan era to today › Topic P.5

September 11 and the war on terror

The attacks of 11 September 2001 transformed George W. Bush's presidency and American priorities. They led to wars in Afghanistan and Iraq and to new security powers at home, raising hard questions about evidence, liberty and the limits of military force.

The attacks of 11 September 2001

Bush took office in 2001 promising "compassionate conservatism" at home and a modest role abroad. On the morning of 11 September, 19 hijackers from al-Qaeda, an Islamist terrorist network led by the Saudi-born Osama bin Laden, seized four airliners. Two were flown into New York's World Trade Center, whose twin towers collapsed within two hours. A third hit the Pentagon outside Washington. On the fourth, United Flight 93, passengers fought back after learning of the other attacks, and it crashed in a field in Pennsylvania. In all, 2,977 people were killed, including 343 New York firefighters: the deadliest terrorist attack in American history.

The first response

Americans rallied around the president, whose approval rating reached about 90 percent. Within days Congress authorised him to use force against those responsible, with only one member voting no. For the first time, NATO allies declared that an attack on one member was an attack on all. On 20 September Bush told Congress that the nation was at war with terrorism and warned other countries, "Either you are with us, or you are with the terrorists." Bush urged respect for Muslim Americans, yet hate crimes against Muslims, and against Sikhs wrongly assumed to be Muslim, rose sharply.

War in Afghanistan

Bin Laden was based in Afghanistan, ruled since 1996 by the Taliban, a strict Islamist movement. In the 1980s the United States had armed Afghan fighters resisting the Soviet occupation, and bin Laden, then a volunteer from abroad, later turned the networks of that war against the West. When the Taliban refused to hand him over, American bombing began on 7 October 2001. With the anti-Taliban Northern Alliance, US forces drove the Taliban from Kabul by mid-November, but bin Laden escaped into Pakistan in December. The war would last nearly twenty years, until the United States withdrew in 2021.

The Bush Doctrine and the case against Iraq

In January 2002 Bush named Iraq, Iran and North Korea an "axis of evil". His strategy, called the Bush Doctrine, held that the United States could strike first against hostile states or groups before they attacked, and should promote democracy. Officials such as Vice-President Dick Cheney and Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld argued that Saddam Hussein was hiding weapons of mass destruction (WMDs), chemical, biological or nuclear arms, and might share them with terrorists. Secretary of State Colin Powell was more cautious but presented the case to the UN Security Council in February 2003. UN inspectors led by Hans Blix had found no such weapons.

The invasion of Iraq

Congress authorised force against Iraq in October 2002. On 20 March 2003 American troops, joined by British, Australian and Polish forces, invaded without a new UN resolution. Baghdad fell in three weeks, and on 1 May Bush declared an end to major combat on an aircraft carrier beneath a banner reading "Mission Accomplished". Saddam was captured that December and later executed by an Iraqi court. Yet no stockpiles of WMDs were ever found: a 2004 US report concluded that Iraq had destroyed them years earlier. The intelligence had been wrong, and some sources, including an informant behind parts of Powell's case, proved unreliable.

Worked example: weighing a case for war

Source: in an October 2002 speech, Bush said the nation could not wait for "the smoking gun", because final proof of Iraq's weapons might arrive as "a mushroom cloud". 1. Claim: Iraq posed a growing danger. 2. Reasoning: because the cost of waiting could be a nuclear attack, the United States should act without certainty; this is the logic of preventive war. 3. Evidence: the speech called the danger clear but offered no new proof, and UN inspectors who returned to Iraq that November found no such weapons. 4. Persuasion: the mushroom-cloud image appealed to fears raised by 9/11. 5. Evaluation: the argument's strength depended on accurate intelligence, which proved mistaken, so historians use the case to show the risks of acting on uncertain evidence.

Occupation and insurgency

Planners had expected a short war and a grateful population. Instead, American authorities disbanded the Iraqi army and purged members of Saddam's party, leaving many armed men jobless and resentful. An insurgency grew, and violence between Sunni and Shia Muslims spread. In 2004 photographs of American soldiers abusing prisoners at Abu Ghraib prison provoked outrage worldwide. In 2007 Bush sent about 30,000 extra troops, the surge, and violence fell as many Sunni tribes turned against al-Qaeda's Iraqi branch. The last American combat troops left in December 2011. Nearly 4,500 Americans died; estimates of Iraqi deaths range from over 100,000 to several hundred thousand.

Worked example: why did the occupation go wrong?

1. Expectations: leaders predicted a quick war and a welcome, so they sent too few troops to keep order after victory. 2. Decisions: disbanding the army and the purge removed the people who ran the state and created a pool of angry recruits. 3. Divisions: the fall of a Sunni-led regime opened a struggle for power with the Shia majority. 4. Legitimacy: Abu Ghraib and civilian deaths turned many Iraqis against the occupation. 5. Correction: the surge and new alliances with Sunni tribes reduced violence by 2008. 6. Conclusion: early choices made a hard task far harder, a judgement now shared by many who supported the war.

Security at home

Weeks after the attacks, Congress passed the USA Patriot Act, which widened the government's power to conduct surveillance, obtain business records and share intelligence between agencies. Airport screening passed to a new federal agency, and in 2002 Congress created the Department of Homeland Security, combining 22 agencies. The 9/11 Commission reported in 2004 that agencies had failed to share warnings. In 2005 newspapers revealed that the National Security Agency had been monitoring some Americans' international calls and emails without warrants. Supporters said such powers saved lives; critics said they threatened civil liberties protected by the Fourth Amendment.

Detainees and the courts

From January 2002, suspected fighters were held at the US naval base at Guantánamo Bay, Cuba. The administration called them "unlawful enemy combatants", not prisoners of war protected by the Geneva Conventions, and argued US courts could not hear their cases. The CIA held some suspects in secret prisons abroad, used harsh methods including waterboarding, and transferred others to countries known for torture, a practice called extraordinary rendition. The Supreme Court pushed back: in Hamdan v. Rumsfeld (2006) it ruled the planned military tribunals unlawful, and in Boumediene v. Bush (2008) it held that detainees could challenge their imprisonment in federal court.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, linking Saddam Hussein to the 9/11 attacks; investigators found no operational tie between Iraq and al-Qaeda. Second, saying WMDs were found in Iraq; no stockpiles were. Third, confusing the two wars: Afghanistan was the direct response to 9/11, while Iraq was a separate war launched in 2003. Fourth, dating the end of the Iraq War to "Mission Accomplished" in 2003; American troops fought there until 2011. Fifth, assuming the courts approved every security policy; the Supreme Court ruled against the administration several times.

Key takeaways

Al-Qaeda killed 2,977 people on 11 September 2001. The United States invaded Afghanistan, toppling the Taliban, but bin Laden escaped. The Bush Doctrine justified striking first, and Iraq was invaded in 2003 over WMDs that did not exist. A quick victory turned into a long insurgency, eased by the 2007 surge; troops left in 2011. At home, the Patriot Act, Homeland Security and warrantless surveillance expanded government power. Guantánamo and harsh interrogation drew criticism, and the Supreme Court affirmed detainees' rights.

Flashcards

Flashcard

11 September 2001

Al-Qaeda hijackings killed 2,977 people

New York, the Pentagon and Pennsylvania.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Why did the United States go to war in Afghanistan in October 2001?

Question 2 of 5

What was the main public justification for invading Iraq in 2003?

Question 3 of 5

Which decision after the 2003 invasion most fuelled the Iraqi insurgency?

Question 4 of 5

What did the Supreme Court decide in Boumediene v. Bush (2008)?

Question 5 of 5

Which statement about weapons of mass destruction in Iraq is accurate?

← Previous topicNext topic →