World History › Section R · Enlightenment and revolution › Topic R.3

Revolutions in America, France, and Haiti

Between 1775 and 1804, three revolutions turned Enlightenment ideas of rights and consent into new governments. Comparing them shows how far each carried the promise of equality, and who forced it further than its authors intended.

An age of Atlantic revolutions

Historians such as R. R. Palmer have described the decades after 1775 as an age of democratic revolutions around the Atlantic. The first began in Britain's North American colonies. After the Seven Years' War (1756 to 1763) left Britain in debt, Parliament taxed colonists who had no representatives in it. Fighting began in 1775, and in July 1776 Congress declared independence in Lockean language of natural rights and consent. French aid from 1778 helped win the war, ended by the Treaty of Paris in 1783. The new republic kept slavery, and Native nations lost land; the US History course covers these events in detail.

France on the eve of revolution

French society was divided into three estates. The clergy formed the First Estate and the nobility the Second; together they were a small fraction of the population but held a large share of the land and many exemptions from taxes. The Third Estate, about 97 percent of the people, ranged from peasants to wealthy lawyers and merchants, the bourgeoisie. By the late 1780s the Crown was near bankruptcy, partly from aiding the American war, and a poor harvest in 1788 sent bread prices soaring. Nobles blocked new taxes, so in 1789 Louis XVI summoned the Estates-General, which had not met since 1614.

1789: the old order falls

Each estate had one vote, so clergy and nobles could outvote the Third Estate. In June 1789 its deputies declared themselves a National Assembly and, in the Tennis Court Oath, swore not to separate until France had a constitution. When the king gathered troops, Parisians stormed the Bastille fortress on 14 July. In August the Assembly abolished feudal privileges and issued the Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen, whose first article states that "Men are born and remain free and equal in rights". In October a crowd led by market women marched on Versailles and brought the royal family to Paris.

Republic, war and Terror

A constitution of 1791 made France a constitutional monarchy, but the royal family's attempted flight that June destroyed trust in the king. In 1792 France went to war with Austria and Prussia, the monarchy was overthrown and a republic proclaimed; Louis XVI was executed in January 1793. Facing invasion and revolt, the radical Jacobins of the Mountain, with Maximilien Robespierre prominent, controlled the Committee of Public Safety. During the Terror of 1793 to 1794, about 17,000 people were executed after trials and many more died in prisons or civil war. The same government fixed grain prices and, in 1794, abolished slavery. Robespierre was guillotined in July 1794.

From the Directory to Napoleon

Women had marched and organised, but they gained no political rights. In 1791 the playwright Olympe de Gouges answered the Declaration with a Declaration of the Rights of Woman and of the Female Citizen; she was guillotined in 1793. After the Terror a five-man Directory governed from 1795 until the general Napoleon Bonaparte seized power in 1799. Napoleon crowned himself emperor in 1804 and issued a Civil Code that made men equal before the law and protected property, while strengthening husbands' authority over wives. In 1802 he restored slavery in France's colonies. He was defeated in 1814 and finally at Waterloo in 1815, but legal equality among men outlasted him.

Saint-Domingue

France's richest colony was Saint-Domingue, the western third of the island of Hispaniola, which produced a large share of the sugar and coffee Europe consumed. Its wealth rested on about 500,000 enslaved people, most born in Africa, because brutal conditions killed so many that planters kept importing more. About 40,000 white colonists ranged from rich planters to poor artisans. About 30,000 free people of colour, the gens de couleur libres, some themselves slaveholders, faced legal discrimination. When news of 1789 arrived, planters wanted autonomy, poor whites equality with the rich, and free people of colour equal rights.

The Haitian Revolution

In August 1791 enslaved people in the northern plain rose in a coordinated revolt; a religious ceremony at Bois Caïman is said to have sealed the plan, though historians debate its details. Britain and Spain invaded in 1793. Needing allies, the French commissioner Léger-Félicité Sonthonax freed the enslaved in the north that year, and in 1794 the Convention abolished slavery throughout France's colonies. Toussaint Louverture, a formerly enslaved man, became the colony's leading general and ruler; his 1801 constitution made him governor for life and bound workers to plantations. Napoleon sent an army in 1802, and Louverture died in a French prison in 1803. Under Jean-Jacques Dessalines, Haiti declared independence on 1 January 1804.

Worked example: who made the rights universal?

Trace how a principle spread. 1. The principle: in 1789 the Declaration of the Rights of Man proclaimed men free and equal in rights. 2. The limit: planters argued it did not apply to the colonies, and in 1791 the white colonists of Saint-Domingue refused rights that Paris had granted to some free men of colour. 3. The action: enslaved people rose in 1791 and fought on. 4. The response: to keep the colony, Sonthonax declared emancipation in 1793, and the Convention made it general in 1794. 5. The test: when Napoleon tried to reverse this, the revolutionaries fought for independence. 6. Conclusion: the enslaved, not the Declaration's authors, made its promise apply to them.

Worked example: comparing three revolutions

1. Leaders: the American and French revolutions were led mainly by propertied men, Haiti's by formerly enslaved and free Black people. 2. Slavery: the United States kept it; France abolished it in 1794 but restored it in 1802; Haiti ended it permanently. 3. Political rights: none of the three gave women the vote, and France and the United States long limited voting by property. 4. Price: France recognised Haiti only in 1825, in return for an indemnity of 150 million francs, later reduced to 90 million, a debt that burdened Haiti for generations; the United States withheld recognition until 1862. Conclusion: Haiti went furthest on equality and was punished for it.

How historians interpret them

Interpretations have shifted. For much of the twentieth century, Marxist historians such as Georges Lefebvre read the French Revolution as a bourgeois revolution that overthrew a feudal aristocracy. From the 1950s, revisionists such as Alfred Cobban and later François Furet argued that social classes were less clear-cut, and stressed political ideas and revolutionary language. For Haiti, C. L. R. James's The Black Jacobins (1938) placed enslaved people at the centre of their own liberation. The anthropologist Michel-Rolph Trouillot argued in 1995 that many contemporaries found a successful slave revolution unthinkable, which long kept it out of Western narratives.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, treating the three revolutions as copies: one created an independent state, one overturned a social order at home, and one destroyed slavery. Second, crediting the French government alone with abolition in 1794; enslaved rebels had already forced the issue. Third, assuming the Terror was random; it targeted perceived enemies during war and revolt. Fourth, forgetting that Napoleon restored slavery in 1802. Fifth, assuming revolutionary rights included women. Sixth, overlooking the cost of Haitian independence.

Key takeaways

The American Revolution created a republic on Lockean principles but kept slavery. In France, debt, privilege and hunger led to the Estates-General of 1789, the National Assembly, the Bastille and the Declaration of the Rights of Man; war radicalised the republic, bringing the king's execution, the Terror and the abolition of slavery in 1794. Napoleon kept male legal equality but restored slavery. In Saint-Domingue, enslaved people rose in 1791 and, led by Louverture and then Dessalines, founded Haiti in 1804, the first state born of a successful revolt by enslaved people.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Age of revolutions

The era of Atlantic revolutions from 1775 into the 1820s

R. R. Palmer's "age of the democratic revolution".

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Why did the Third Estate object to the voting rules of the Estates-General in 1789?

Question 2 of 5

What did the French Convention do in 1794 that Napoleon reversed in 1802?

Question 3 of 5

Which statement best explains why slavery was abolished in Saint-Domingue in 1793 and 1794?

Question 4 of 5

How did the outcome of the Haitian Revolution for slavery differ from those of the American and French revolutions?

Question 5 of 5

What did revisionist historians such as Alfred Cobban and François Furet argue about the French Revolution?

← Previous topicNext topic →