World History › Section R · Enlightenment and revolution › Topic R.4
Nationalism, liberalism, and conservatism
After Napoleon's fall, Europeans argued over what to keep from the revolutionary age. Three ideologies, conservatism, liberalism and nationalism, framed that argument, redrew the map of Europe and still shape political language today.
Conservatism
By 1815 Europe had seen kings overthrown and constitutions written. Three ideologies, connected sets of ideas about how society should be organised, offered rival answers to what should survive. Conservatism held that sudden change destroys the institutions that make order and freedom possible. Its most influential voice, the Irish-born politician Edmund Burke, predicted in Reflections on the Revolution in France (1790) that rebuilding society from abstract principles would end in violence. Burke saw society as a partnership of past, present and future generations, so reform should be gradual and build on custom, religion and property. After 1815 conservatism guided most European governments.
The Congress of Vienna
From 1814 to 1815 the victors over Napoleon, Austria, Britain, Prussia and Russia, met at Vienna to rebuild Europe, and defeated France was soon admitted. Austria's Klemens von Metternich led the talks. Three principles guided the settlement. Legitimacy meant restoring the rightful dynasties, such as the Bourbons in France and Spain. A balance of power meant arranging territory so that no state could dominate the others. Compensation meant rewarding the victors with land. A German Confederation of 39 states replaced the old Holy Roman Empire, and the great powers agreed to meet to settle future crises, a system called the Concert of Europe.
Worked example: reading the Vienna settlement
Test the settlement against its own aims. 1. Containing France: the Dutch received the former Austrian Netherlands, today's Belgium, and Prussia gained land on the Rhine, so stronger states now bordered France. 2. Legitimacy: Louis XVIII returned to the French throne and Ferdinand VII to Spain's. 3. Balance and compensation: Russia took most of the Duchy of Warsaw as a kingdom under the tsar, while Prussia and Austria were compensated elsewhere. 4. Omission: the wishes of Poles, Italians, Belgians and Germans were largely ignored. 5. Record: smaller wars came, but none involving all the great powers until 1914. Historians such as Henry Kissinger praised that stability; critics stress the nationalist and liberal hopes it suppressed.
Liberalism
Nineteenth-century liberalism grew from Locke's ideas of consent and natural rights. Political liberals demanded written constitutions, limited government, equality before the law, representative assemblies and freedom of speech, press and religion. Most still wanted the vote limited to men of property. Economic liberals, following Adam Smith's The Wealth of Nations (1776), favoured free trade and minimal state interference in the economy, often called laissez-faire. This differs from the modern American use of liberal, which usually means support for government action to reduce inequality. In On Liberty (1859), John Stuart Mill argued that society may restrict a person's freedom only to prevent harm to others.
Nationalism
A nation is a people who believe they share a language, culture, history or descent; a state is a political unit with territory, borders and a government. Nationalism is the belief that a nation should govern itself in its own state, and that loyalty to the nation comes before loyalty to a dynasty, region or religion. French revolutionaries spread it by calling citizens to defend the nation, and Napoleon's conquests provoked it among Germans, Spaniards and others. It could unite peoples split among many states or break apart empires. Unlike simple patriotism, nationalism could claim that one's own nation was superior and treat minorities as outsiders.
Where do nations come from?
Historians disagree about how old nations are. In Imagined Communities (1983) the political scientist Benedict Anderson argued that nations are modern creations: people who will never meet come to feel part of one community through shared newspapers, books and print languages. Ernest Gellner, also in 1983, linked nationalism to industrial societies that needed a common, schooled culture. Others, such as the sociologist Anthony D. Smith, argued that modern nations drew on much older ethnic myths, memories and symbols. Most scholars accept that nationalism as a political movement is modern, while debating how much it built on older identities.
Challenges to the Vienna order
The Vienna system soon faced revolts. Greeks rose against Ottoman rule in 1821 and won independence by 1830 with British, French and Russian help, and Belgium broke away from the Dutch kingdom in 1830. In 1848 revolutions swept France, the German states, the Austrian Empire and Italy. Metternich fled Vienna, and the elected Frankfurt Parliament offered the crown of a united Germany to Frederick William IV of Prussia in 1849; he refused a crown from an elected assembly. By 1849 most of the revolutions had been crushed, but serfdom had been abolished in the Austrian lands.
The unification of Italy
In 1815 Italy was a patchwork of states, with Austria dominant in the north. Giuseppe Mazzini founded Young Italy in 1831 to create a united, democratic republic. Unification came instead under the kingdom of Piedmont-Sardinia. Its prime minister from 1852, Count Camillo di Cavour, allied with France and defeated Austria in 1859, gaining Lombardy. In 1860 Giuseppe Garibaldi led a volunteer army, the Thousand or Redshirts, to conquer Sicily and Naples, then handed them to King Victor Emmanuel II. The Kingdom of Italy was proclaimed in 1861. Venetia followed in 1866 and Rome in 1870, becoming the capital in 1871. Italy was united as a monarchy, not Mazzini's republic.
The unification of Germany
German economic unity came first: the Prussian-led customs union, the Zollverein, founded in 1834, removed tariffs among most German states. Political unity followed the failure of the liberal Frankfurt Parliament. In 1862 King William I of Prussia appointed Otto von Bismarck as minister-president, and in a speech that year Bismarck said the great questions would be decided not by speeches and majority votes but by "iron and blood". Three short wars followed: against Denmark in 1864, Austria in 1866, which shut Austria out of German affairs, and France in 1870 to 1871, which won Alsace and much of Lorraine. On 18 January 1871 William was proclaimed German emperor at Versailles.
Worked example: one force, opposite effects
Why did nationalism unite Germany but strain Austria? 1. Germany: German speakers were divided among dozens of states, so the national idea pulled them together, and Bismarck harnessed it to build a Prussian-led empire. 2. The Habsburg Empire: its subjects included Germans, Hungarians, Czechs, Poles, Croats, Serbs, Italians and others, so the national idea pushed each group towards its own rights or state. 3. A response: in 1867 the Compromise made the empire a dual monarchy, Austria-Hungary, sharing power with Hungary. 4. A limit: the Slavic peoples gained no equal share and kept pressing their claims. 5. Conclusion: the same ideology built one state and weakened another until it collapsed in 1918.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, reading nineteenth-century liberalism as modern American liberalism; it stressed limited government and free markets. Second, assuming liberals wanted democracy; most backed a vote limited to property owners. Third, treating nationalism as always liberal: Bismarck, a conservative, unified Germany through war. Fourth, confusing a nation, a people with a shared identity, with a state, a political unit. Fifth, believing the Vienna settlement ended revolution; Greece, Belgium and 1848 tested it. Sixth, crediting Garibaldi with founding a republic; Italy was united as a monarchy.
Key takeaways
Conservatism, voiced by Burke and practised by Metternich, defended gradual change and legitimate monarchy, and the Congress of Vienna rebuilt Europe on legitimacy, balance of power and compensation. Liberalism demanded constitutions, rights and free markets, usually with a property-based vote. Nationalism held that each nation should have its own state; historians debate whether nations are modern inventions or built on older identities. Greece, Belgium and 1848 challenged the Vienna order, and nationalism united Italy and Germany by 1871 while straining multinational Austria-Hungary.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A connected set of ideas about how society should be organised and why
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which principle of the Congress of Vienna explains the restoration of the Bourbon kings in France and Spain?
Question 2 of 5
How did most nineteenth-century liberals differ from modern American liberals?
Question 3 of 5
What did Benedict Anderson argue in Imagined Communities (1983)?
Question 4 of 5
Why did Italy's unification disappoint Giuseppe Mazzini?
Question 5 of 5
Why did nationalism weaken the Habsburg Empire while it strengthened Prussia?
