World History › Section L · The Mongol Empire › Topic L.4

Christianity and Islam beyond Central Asia

While the Mongols conquered the heart of Eurasia, the Christian and Muslim lands at its western and southern edges went their own way. Popes fought kings and heretics, Christian kingdoms advanced in Iberia, crusaders tried and failed to win Egypt, and the Mamluks of Egypt and the sultans of Delhi became the powers that stopped the Mongols.

Beyond the Mongol advance

The Mongols reached Hungary, Syria and the borders of India, but never conquered western Europe, Egypt or most of India. In Latin Christendom, popes claimed authority over all Christians and clashed with increasingly strong kings. In the Islamic world, rule passed to new military elites, slave soldiers in Egypt and Turkic generals in Delhi, and it was these regimes that held the Mongols back.

Popes, heretics and inquisitors

Innocent III, pope from 1198 to 1216, is often seen as the most powerful medieval pope. His Fourth Lateran Council of 1215 required every Christian to confess once a year and ordered Jews and Muslims in Christian lands to wear distinctive dress. He also launched a crusade in 1209 against the Cathars of southern France, dualist heretics who rejected the Church's sacraments. In the 1230s Gregory IX appointed papal inquisitors, many of them friars of the new Dominican order, to hunt out heresy, and in 1252 Innocent IV allowed them to use torture.

Popes against emperors and kings

The emperor Frederick II, who also ruled the kingdom of Sicily, was excommunicated more than once and deposed by a church council in 1245. In Sicily his Constitutions of Melfi of 1231 put royal officials, rather than barons or bishops, in charge of justice. After his death in 1250 the popes helped destroy his family's power, and Germany went for two decades without an agreed emperor. In France, Philip IV taxed the clergy and quarrelled with Pope Boniface VIII, who in 1302 declared that every person must be subject to the pope. In 1303 Philip's agents seized Boniface at Anagni, and from 1309 the popes lived at Avignon, near French power.

Worked example: Magna Carta

In 1215 English barons, angered by King John's heavy taxes and military failures, forced him to seal a charter at Runnymede. 1. Its authors: rebel barons and churchmen, protecting their own rights first. 2. Its famous promise: no free man would be imprisoned or deprived of his lands except by lawful judgement or the law of the land. 3. Its limits: a large share of English peasants were unfree serfs, outside that protection. 4. Its fate: Pope Innocent III annulled it within weeks, but it was reissued in 1216, 1217 and 1225. 5. Its legacy: later kings had to seek consent for taxes, and under Edward I parliaments of nobles, clergy, knights and townsmen met often. 6. Conclude: a baronial bargain later became a symbol of limited government.

Iberia: Las Navas de Tolosa and after

Since the late twelfth century most of Muslim Iberia had been ruled by the Almohads, an Amazigh (Berber) reform movement from Morocco. In 1212, encouraged by Innocent III, the kings of Castile, Aragon and Navarre united and crushed an Almohad army at Las Navas de Tolosa. Almohad power then collapsed, and Castile took Córdoba in 1236 and Seville in 1248. Only the Nasrid emirate of Granada survived, paying tribute to Castile. Muslims under Christian rule, called mudéjars, could usually keep their faith and law but faced special taxes and dress rules. Later writers called the whole advance the Reconquista, a term historians now use with care.

The Fifth Crusade and Frederick II

Crusade leaders now saw Egypt, the richest Muslim state, as the key to Jerusalem. The Fifth Crusade took the Egyptian port of Damietta in 1219. During the siege, Francis of Assisi crossed the lines to preach before the sultan al-Kamil, who received him courteously. Al-Kamil offered to trade Jerusalem for Damietta, but the crusade's leaders refused, and in 1221 the Nile flood trapped their army, forcing them to give up Damietta. Frederick II, excommunicated for delaying his own crusade, sailed anyway and in 1229 obtained Jerusalem by negotiation in the Treaty of Jaffa, without a battle.

Worked example: who disliked the Treaty of Jaffa?

Under the 1229 treaty, Jerusalem passed to Frederick for ten years, but Muslims kept the Temple Mount with the Dome of the Rock and al-Aqsa. 1. Al-Kamil's motive: he faced rival relatives in Damascus and needed peace with the Franks. 2. Frederick's motive: he wanted a success to answer the pope who had excommunicated him. 3. Christian critics: the patriarch of Jerusalem placed the city under an interdict, and many saw a crusade without battle as shameful. 4. Muslim critics: preachers in Damascus lamented the loss of a holy city. 5. Outcome: apart from a brief loss in 1239, Jerusalem stayed in Christian hands only until 1244. 6. Conclude: diplomacy succeeded where war had failed, yet angered zealots on both sides.

Louis IX and the rise of the Mamluks

King Louis IX of France led a new crusade to Egypt in 1248. He took Damietta but was defeated at Mansurah, and in 1250 he and much of his army were captured and later ransomed. Egypt's armies were built around mamluks, slave soldiers bought as boys, often Kipchak Turks from the steppe. In 1250 they murdered the new sultan, Turanshah. His stepmother, Shajar al-Durr, briefly ruled as sultan before marrying the mamluk commander Aybak, and mamluk sultans governed Egypt and Syria until 1517. Louis died on a second crusade, at Tunis, in 1270.

Ain Jalut, 1260

After sacking Baghdad, Hulagu demanded that the Mamluks submit. In 1260, after news of Mongke's death and perhaps also for want of summer pasture, he withdrew most of his army east, leaving a smaller force under the general Kitbuqa, a Christian of the Church of the East. In September 1260 the Mamluk sultan Qutuz and his commander Baybars defeated and killed Kitbuqa at Ain Jalut in Galilee. Baybars soon murdered Qutuz, took the throne and captured many crusader castles. Ain Jalut is often called the battle that stopped the Mongols, but historians note that the Mongol force was much reduced and that later il-khans invaded Syria again around 1300.

The Delhi Sultanate

In the late twelfth century Muhammad of Ghur, from modern Afghanistan, conquered much of northern India. After his death in 1206, his former slave general Qutb al-Din Aibak founded a sultanate at Delhi. Iltutmish chose his daughter Raziya to succeed him; she ruled from 1236 to 1240, the only woman to hold the throne, before nobles overthrew her. Alauddin Khalji drove back repeated Mongol invasions around 1300, and Muhammad bin Tughlaq extended rule far into southern India by the 1330s. Conversion to Islam was gradual; Richard Eaton has argued that it owed little to force and more to slow social change.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, assuming the Mongols conquered everywhere: Egypt, western Europe and most of India held out. Second, imagining medieval popes always got their way: kings such as Philip IV defied them. Third, reading Magna Carta as a charter of rights for everyone: it protected free men, and serfs were not free. Fourth, treating Ain Jalut as the end of all Mongol threats to Syria. Fifth, assuming Islam spread in India mainly by the sword: historians stress gradual conversion.

Key takeaways

The war on the Cathars and the Inquisition enforced religious uniformity, while popes clashed with Frederick II and Philip IV, ending up at Avignon. Magna Carta and parliaments limited English kings. After Las Navas de Tolosa in 1212, Christian kingdoms took most of Iberia, leaving Granada. The Fifth Crusade failed, Frederick II won Jerusalem by treaty in 1229, and Louis IX was captured as the Mamluks seized Egypt. Their victory at Ain Jalut checked the Mongols, and the Delhi Sultanate repelled them in India.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Innocent III

Pope from 1198 to 1216

Called the Fourth Lateran Council and the crusade against the Cathars.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

What did the Fourth Lateran Council of 1215 require?

Question 2 of 5

Why is it misleading to call Magna Carta a charter of rights for all English people in 1215?

Question 3 of 5

What made Frederick II's crusade unusual?

Question 4 of 5

Why do historians qualify the claim that Ain Jalut stopped the Mongols?

Question 5 of 5

What did Richard Eaton argue about conversion to Islam in India?

← Previous topicNext topic →