World History › Section L · The Mongol Empire › Topic L.3

The Mongol Empire fragments

After 1260 Chinggis Khan's grandsons fought each other, and the empire split into four khanates. Each took on the ways of the people it ruled: three turned to Islam, while in China Kublai Khan founded the Yuan dynasty. This topic follows the four successor states and asks what the so-called Mongol peace really meant.

Civil war and four khanates

When Mongke died in 1259, his brothers Kublai and Ariq Boke each had himself proclaimed great khan. Kublai won the civil war in 1264, but the unity of the empire did not return. Four khanates emerged: the Yuan in China and Mongolia, ruled by Kublai as great khan; the Il-Khanate of Hulagu's line in Iran and Iraq; the Chagatai Khanate in Central Asia; and in the western steppe and Rus lands the realm of Jochi's heirs, later called by Russians the Golden Horde. Only the Il-Khans regularly recognised Kublai as their overlord.

Worked example: why did the empire fragment?

1. Succession: there was no fixed rule, so every great khan's death led to rival claims, regencies and delay. 2. Distance: messages took weeks to cross the empire, and regional khans commanded their own armies and revenues. 3. Ways of life: Kublai embraced Chinese government, while Ariq Boke and many princes wanted to keep steppe traditions. 4. Religion and rivalry: Berke of the Golden Horde, a Muslim, was outraged by Hulagu's sack of Baghdad, and the two fought from 1262, the first war between Mongol khanates. 5. The end of expansion: with fewer conquests, there were fewer spoils to buy loyalty. 6. Conclude: structural weakness, not one quarrel, broke the empire.

The Il-Khanate in Iran

Hulagu's heirs ruled Iran and Iraq from Tabriz. Wars with the Golden Horde and the Mamluks of Egypt slowed recovery. Yet their courts were brilliant. In 1259 Hulagu founded an observatory at Maragha under the Persian scholar Nasir al-Din al-Tusi. Ghazan, who became il-khan in 1295, converted to Islam and reformed taxation. His vizier Rashid al-Din wrote the Compendium of Chronicles, a history of the Mongols and of peoples from China to Europe, often called the first world history. When the il-khan Abu Said died without an heir in 1335, the state broke apart.

Why Mongol rulers turned to Islam

Most subjects of the three western khanates were Muslims. Mongol rulers had long tolerated all faiths, but conversion brought legitimacy and the loyalty of Turkic soldiers, many already Muslim. Sufi mystics, who stressed personal devotion over strict law, moved among the steppe peoples and won converts. Berke of the Golden Horde converted in the 1250s, Ghazan in 1295, and Uzbeg, khan of the Golden Horde from 1313, made Islam its official religion. In the troubled Chagatai Khanate, the convert Tarmashirin was overthrown in 1334, partly for neglecting steppe customs; by the mid-fourteenth century that khanate had split in two.

The Golden Horde and the Rus

The khans of the Golden Horde ruled from Sarai on the lower Volga and kept a largely nomadic life. They governed the Rus principalities indirectly: princes travelled to Sarai to receive a patent, or yarlik, to rule, and collected tribute for the khan. The princes of Moscow rose by serving as reliable collectors, and the Orthodox Church, exempt from taxes, grew in wealth and became a focus of Rus identity. Later Russian writers spoke of a "Tatar yoke" that held Russia back; historians such as Charles Halperin have argued that Mongol influence was deeper and more mixed than that phrase suggests.

Kublai conquers the Song

Kublai built a new capital, Dadu, on the site of modern Beijing, and in 1271 proclaimed the Yuan dynasty, taking a name from a Chinese classic. Conquering the Southern Song took years, because rivers, walled cities and a strong navy protected it. The key fortress of Xiangyang held out from 1268 to 1273, until Muslim engineers from the Il-Khanate built heavy counterweight catapults for the Mongols. Hangzhou surrendered in 1276. In 1279, at the sea battle of Yamen, the last Song loyalists were destroyed, and an official leapt into the sea with the boy emperor.

Ruling Yuan China

The Yuan ranked subjects in four groups: Mongols; semu, "various kinds", mostly Central and West Asians such as Uyghurs and Persians; Han, meaning northern Chinese and Khitan; and southerners, the former Song subjects, the great majority. The exams were suspended, so many Confucian scholars turned to painting, drama and teaching. When the exams returned in 1315, half the degrees were reserved for Mongols and semu. Kublai patronised Tibetan Buddhism, making the lama Phagpa his imperial preceptor, yet he also employed Muslim financiers and Christian and Daoist advisers.

Worked example: did Marco Polo go to China?

The Venetian Marco Polo claimed to have served Kublai for about seventeen years. 1. The source: his book was written down in 1298 by Rustichello of Pisa, a writer of romances, while both were prisoners in Genoa. 2. The doubts: it never mentions tea drinking, footbinding or Chinese writing, and his name is absent from Chinese records; in 1995 Frances Wood questioned whether he went at all. 3. The defence: Hans Ulrich Vogel showed that his descriptions of paper money, salt production and revenues match Chinese sources closely. 4. The style: Rustichello added romance. 5. Conclude: most historians accept that Polo went to China but read his book critically.

Overreach and the fall of the Yuan

Kublai's wars beyond China failed. Fleets sent against Japan in 1274 and 1281 failed, and the second was wrecked by a typhoon the Japanese called kamikaze, "divine wind". Invasions of Dai Viet in modern Vietnam ended in defeat in 1288, and an expedition to Java in 1293 achieved little. After Kublai died in 1294, short reigns and court feuds weakened the dynasty. Governments printed paper money to cover costs, causing inflation; the Yellow River burst its banks and changed course in the 1340s; famine and epidemics spread. Rebels called Red Turbans rose from 1351, and in 1368 one of their leaders, Zhu Yuanzhang, founded the Ming dynasty, driving the Mongols back to the steppe.

A Mongol peace?

Historians use the term Pax Mongolica for the period, roughly 1260 to 1350, when Mongol rule linked Eurasia. Thomas Allsen showed how ideas moved under Mongol patronage: Chinese medicine and astronomy reached Iran, Persian scholars worked in China, and Persian cobalt helped create Chinese blue-and-white porcelain. Yet the peace was built on conquest that had destroyed cities, and the khanates often fought each other. The same routes may have carried plague westward in the 1340s, as a later topic explains. Whether the Mongols are remembered mainly as destroyers or connectors depends on which lands and which decades one examines.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, imagining the empire stayed united after 1260: four khanates went their own ways and sometimes fought each other. Second, thinking all Mongols became Muslims: the Yuan court favoured Tibetan Buddhism. Third, assuming the Mongols ruled the Rus directly: Rus princes collected tribute for them. Fourth, calling the Yuan a simple continuation of Song rule: it ranked subjects by origin and suspended the exams for decades. Fifth, dismissing Marco Polo as a fraud or trusting him entirely. Sixth, describing the Pax Mongolica as peaceful for everyone.

Key takeaways

After the civil war of 1260-1264, succession disputes, distance, rival ways of life and the end of expansion left four khanates. The Il-Khans and the khans of the Golden Horde converted to Islam, while the Horde ruled the Rus through their princes. Kublai founded the Yuan in 1271, conquered the Song by 1279, ranked subjects by origin and failed overseas; inflation, floods and rebellion led to the Ming in 1368. The Pax Mongolica joined Eurasia at great cost.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Four khanates

Yuan, Il-Khanate, Chagatai Khanate and Golden Horde

Emerged after the civil war of 1260-1264.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which cause of the empire's fragmentation does the war between Berke and Hulagu best illustrate?

Question 2 of 5

How did the Golden Horde govern the Rus principalities?

Question 3 of 5

Why did many Mongol rulers in the western khanates convert to Islam?

Question 4 of 5

How did Yuan rule differ from that of the Song?

Question 5 of 5

What is the most balanced conclusion about Marco Polo's book?

← Previous topicNext topic →