World History › Section K · The medieval West and the Crusades › Topic K.4
The crusading movement
For two centuries after 1095, western Christians fought to win and hold the Holy Land. This topic follows the major crusades from the capture of Jerusalem to the sack of Constantinople, and looks at them through Latin, Muslim, Jewish and Byzantine eyes.
A city holy to three faiths
Jerusalem had been the site of the Jewish Temple, destroyed by Rome in 70 CE, and remained central to Jewish prayer and hope. For Christians it held the Church of the Holy Sepulchre, built over the place where they believe Jesus was crucified, buried and rose. For Muslims, the al-Aqsa Mosque and the Dome of the Rock on the Temple Mount marked the place linked to Muhammad's Night Journey, making the city Islam's third holiest after Mecca and Medina. Western Christians who answered Urban II's call spoke of an armed pilgrimage; the word "crusade" came into use later.
The first marchers and the Rhineland massacres
Ahead of the main armies, popular bands inspired by preachers such as Peter the Hermit set out in 1096. In the Rhineland, crusaders led by Count Emicho and others attacked the Jewish communities of Speyer, Worms and Mainz, demanding conversion or money and killing perhaps two thousand people, most of them at Worms and Mainz; the bishop of Speyer sheltered his city's Jews, but elsewhere bishops failed to protect them. Hebrew chronicles written in the following decades record the killings and the choice of some Jews to die rather than convert. Peter's followers, ferried across to Anatolia by Alexios I, were destroyed by Seljuk forces near Nicaea in October 1096.
From Nicaea to Jerusalem, 1097-1099
The main armies were led by great lords such as Godfrey of Bouillon, Raymond of Toulouse and the Norman Bohemond. Most swore to return former Byzantine lands to Alexios. Nicaea surrendered to the Byzantines in 1097, but after a gruelling siege of Antioch in 1098 Bohemond kept the city for himself, souring relations with Constantinople. In July 1099 the survivors, after walking barefoot around the walls in penitential procession, stormed Jerusalem, which the Fatimids had retaken from the Turks only the year before. They killed many of its Muslim and Jewish inhabitants; the scale is debated, since later chroniclers' figures are probably inflated and letters of the time show some captives were ransomed.
Worked example: why did the First Crusade succeed?
1. Muslim division: after 1092 rival Seljuk princes fought each other, and Sunni Seljuks and Shia Fatimids were enemies, so no united army met the crusaders. 2. Surprise: Muslim rulers at first took the Franks for Byzantine mercenaries, not settlers. 3. Byzantine help: Alexios supplied guides and food on the march through Anatolia. 4. Motivation: a penitential army far from home had little choice but to win or die. 5. Sea links: Genoese and other Italian ships brought supplies to the coast. 6. Conclude: crusader zeal mattered, but Muslim disunity was probably decisive.
Outremer: the crusader states
The conquerors founded four states, known to the French as Outremer, "overseas": the County of Edessa, the Principality of Antioch, the Kingdom of Jerusalem and the County of Tripoli, the last in 1109. Few Europeans settled, so a small Frankish elite ruled a majority of Muslim and Eastern Christian peasants, who paid taxes much as before. To defend it, new military orders of fighting monks, such as the Knights Templar and the Hospitallers, garrisoned castles like Krak des Chevaliers. Venetian, Genoese and Pisan merchants gained trading quarters in the ports, sending spices, silks and sugar to Europe.
Worked example: Usama ibn Munqidh on the Franks
Usama ibn Munqidh, a Syrian Muslim nobleman and poet, wrote his memoirs in the 1180s, in old age. 1. Identify the source: one aristocrat's recollections, told as instructive anecdotes. 2. Note the contempt: he mocks Frankish medicine and judges the Franks brave but lacking sense. 3. Note the contact: he calls the Templars in Jerusalem his friends, who let him pray in a small mosque beside al-Aqsa; when a newly arrived Frank forced him to face east, the Templars apologised. 4. Draw the distinction: Usama says Franks long settled in the East behaved better than newcomers. 5. Conclude: Outremer mixed hostility with everyday coexistence.
Zengi, Nur al-Din and the Second Crusade
Zengi, the Turkish ruler of Mosul and Aleppo, took Edessa in 1144, the first crusader state to fall. Preached by Bernard of Clairvaux, the Second Crusade (1147-1149) was led by Louis VII of France and Conrad III of Germany. Both armies were mauled in Anatolia, and an attack on Damascus in 1148 collapsed within days; many blamed the Byzantines. Zengi's son Nur al-Din then united Muslim Syria, built madrasas, and presented himself as a holy warrior. His general's nephew, Salah al-Din, known in Europe as Saladin, became ruler of Egypt.
Saladin and the Third Crusade
Saladin ended the Fatimid caliphate in 1171 and joined Egypt to Syria, surrounding the crusader states. In July 1187 he destroyed their army at Hattin, and in October Jerusalem surrendered; unlike in 1099, most inhabitants were allowed to ransom themselves and leave, though thousands who could not pay were enslaved. The Third Crusade (1189-1192) followed. Emperor Frederick Barbarossa drowned crossing a river in Anatolia, but Richard I of England and Philip II of France retook Acre in 1191, where Richard had about 2,700 Muslim prisoners executed. In 1192 Richard and Saladin agreed a truce: Jerusalem stayed Muslim, the Franks kept a coastal strip, and Christian pilgrims could visit.
The Fourth Crusade and a wider movement
Pope Innocent III launched a new crusade in 1198. Unable to pay the Venetians for their fleet, the crusaders attacked the Christian port of Zara for Venice in 1202, then agreed to restore an exiled Byzantine prince in return for money. When the deal collapsed, they stormed Constantinople in April 1204 and sacked it, setting up a Latin Empire that lasted until 1261. Innocent condemned the violence, and Orthodox Christians never forgot it. By then popes also called crusades against pagans in the Baltic, Cathar heretics in southern France and their own political enemies. Acre, the last crusader stronghold, fell in 1291.
Many perspectives
Anna Komnene, daughter of Alexios I, portrayed the Latins in her history as greedy and untrustworthy. Muslim writers usually called the invaders Franks and saw them as one danger among many; the Arabic term for "the crusades" became common only in the nineteenth century. Historians debate motives too. The old picture of landless younger sons seeking fortunes has been challenged by Jonathan Riley-Smith, who showed that crusading was ruinously expensive and argued that most went out of piety, while others stress plunder, family ambition and papal politics. Carole Hillenbrand has reconstructed Islamic perspectives on the whole era.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, picturing the crusades as one continuous war: they were separate expeditions, with long truces and trade between them. Second, thinking all crusades targeted Muslims: Jews in the Rhineland, Orthodox Christians in Constantinople, Baltic pagans and Cathars were also victims. Third, assuming Muslims were united against the Franks from the start: unity came slowly under Zengi, Nur al-Din and Saladin. Fourth, reducing crusaders' motives to greed or to piety alone. Fifth, assuming medieval Muslims saw the crusades as modern writers do.
Key takeaways
Jerusalem was holy to Jews, Christians and Muslims. The First Crusade began with massacres of Rhineland Jews and, helped by Muslim disunity, took Jerusalem in 1099 with great bloodshed. Four crusader states relied on military orders, castles and Italian merchants, and mixed hostility with coexistence. Zengi took Edessa in 1144; the Second Crusade failed; Saladin won at Hattin and took Jerusalem in 1187; the Third Crusade won back only the coast. In 1204 crusaders sacked Constantinople. Historians still debate motives and meanings.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Jerusalem church over the place of Jesus's crucifixion and burial
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which factor does the reading treat as probably decisive in the First Crusade's success?
Question 2 of 5
What does Usama ibn Munqidh's story about praying beside al-Aqsa suggest about Outremer?
Question 3 of 5
How did Saladin's capture of Jerusalem in 1187 differ from the crusaders' capture in 1099?
Question 4 of 5
Why did the Fourth Crusade attack Constantinople?
Question 5 of 5
What did Jonathan Riley-Smith argue about the motives of the First Crusaders?
