World History › Section K · The medieval West and the Crusades › Topic K.3
Patriarch, papacy, and the call to crusade
In the eleventh century, reformers in the Western Church set out to free it from lay control and to tame the violence of its own warriors. The same reforming popes drifted further from the patriarch of Constantinople, and in 1095 one of them answered a Byzantine plea with a call to holy war.
A Church in the hands of lords
After the Carolingian empire broke up, local lords treated churches and monasteries on their lands as property. They chose priests and abbots, collected church revenues and sometimes sold bishoprics to the highest bidder, a sin reformers called simony. Many priests were married. In 910 Duke William of Aquitaine founded the monastery of Cluny in Burgundy and placed it directly under the pope, beyond the reach of any lord or bishop. Cluny's strict prayer and independence inspired hundreds of monasteries to join its network, and its ideals spread to clergy who wanted the whole Church reformed.
The reforming popes
From the 1040s reformers took over the papacy itself. Leo IX, pope from 1049 to 1054, travelled widely, holding councils against simony and clerical marriage. In 1059 a decree gave the election of popes to the cardinals, the senior clergy of Rome, rather than Roman nobles or the emperor. Gregory VII, pope from 1073 to 1085, went furthest. He claimed that the pope could judge kings and even depose emperors, and he banned lay investiture: the practice of rulers installing bishops and handing them the ring and staff that symbolised their office.
Worked example: Henry IV at Canossa
Trace the clash between Gregory VII and the German king Henry IV. 1. The trigger: Henry, who relied on bishops to govern, kept appointing them. 2. Escalation: in 1076 Henry's bishops declared Gregory deposed, and Gregory excommunicated Henry, releasing his subjects from their oaths. 3. The pressure: rebellious German princes threatened to replace Henry unless he was absolved. 4. The scene: in January 1077 Henry stood as a penitent in the snow for three days outside the castle of Canossa until Gregory lifted the ban. 5. Aftermath: war resumed, Henry set up a rival pope, and Gregory died in exile in 1085. 6. Conclude: a compromise, the Concordat of Worms, came only in 1122.
Taming Christian warriors
Reformers also tried to control violence among Christians. From 989, church councils in France proclaimed the Peace of God, protecting clergy, peasants and church property from attack, and later the Truce of God, banning fighting on certain days. Christian thinkers had long followed Augustine of Hippo in accepting a just war: one called by a lawful authority, for a just cause, with right intention. Ideals of knightly conduct, later called chivalry, began to Christianise the warrior's life. Yet knights still fought constantly.
Two halves of one Church
Five ancient sees led the Church: Rome, Constantinople, Alexandria, Antioch and Jerusalem, each headed by a patriarch. Alexandria and Jerusalem had been under Muslim rule since the seventh century, which left the pope and the patriarch of Constantinople as the most powerful. Their churches had grown apart. The West used Latin, required priests to be celibate and used unleavened bread in communion; the East used Greek, allowed priests to marry and used leavened bread. Westerners added the word filioque, "and the Son", to the creed. Above all, popes claimed authority over the whole Church, while the East saw the pope as first among equal patriarchs.
Missions to the Slavs
In 863 the brothers Cyril and Methodius, Greek missionaries from Thessalonica, went to Moravia in central Europe and translated the liturgy into Slavonic, the language of the people. Cyril devised an alphabet for it, called Glagolitic; their disciples in Bulgaria later developed a simpler script named Cyrillic in his honour. In about 988 Prince Vladimir of Kiev was baptised and made Orthodox Christianity the faith of the Rus, binding the ancestors of Ukrainians, Russians and Belarusians to Constantinople rather than Rome.
Worked example: what happened in 1054?
Test the claim that the Church split in 1054. 1. The event: Pope Leo IX sent legates led by Cardinal Humbert to Constantinople. Talks with Patriarch Michael Cerularius failed; in July Humbert laid a bull excommunicating the patriarch on the altar of Hagia Sophia; the patriarch's synod excommunicated the legates in return. 2. A legal problem: Leo had died in April, so the legates' authority was doubtful. 3. The scope: the excommunications targeted individuals, not whole churches. 4. Later evidence: contacts continued, and Alexios I still sought papal help in 1095. 5. Conclude: 1054 became a symbol of a slow drift that the sack of Constantinople in 1204 made far deeper. In 1965 the pope and patriarch lifted the mutual excommunications.
Urban II at Clermont
Urban II, a former monk of Cluny, became pope in 1088 while a rival pope backed by Henry IV still held parts of Rome. In March 1095 envoys of Alexios I asked him at Piacenza for soldiers. In November, at a council at Clermont in France, Urban preached an armed pilgrimage to aid the eastern Christians and free Jerusalem. Those who went would wear a cloth cross and receive remission of the penance owed for their sins. The crowd is said to have shouted "God wills it." Our accounts of the sermon were written after 1099 by men such as Fulcher of Chartres and Robert the Monk, and they differ widely.
Why did Urban call a crusade?
Historians weigh several motives. Urban sincerely wished to help fellow Christians and to restore Jerusalem, the holiest Christian city. He hoped that aiding Byzantium would heal the breach with the eastern Church on papal terms. Leading a great Christian army would show that the pope, not the German emperor, led Christendom. And sending knights east turned their violence outward. The crusade fused older ideas, just war, pilgrimage and penance, into something new: a war called by the pope that counted as an act of devotion.
Crusade and jihad
Islam had its own tradition of sanctioned warfare. The Arabic word jihad means "struggle" or "striving". Muslim writers applied it to a believer's inner struggle against sin as well as to armed struggle in defence or expansion of Muslim rule, which jurists surrounded with rules, such as sparing non-combatants. When the crusaders arrived, many Muslim rulers were slow to respond. In 1105 the Damascus scholar al-Sulami wrote a treatise urging rulers to unite in jihad against the Franks, but his call won wide support only decades later. Like crusade, jihad was preached by religious authorities and used by rulers for their own aims.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, dating a clean split of the churches to 1054: it was one episode in a long drift. Second, thinking reform was only about money: it also concerned clerical marriage and who appointed bishops. Third, assuming Christianity had always taught holy war: just-war theory came first, and the crusade combined it with pilgrimage and penance. Fourth, reducing jihad to war alone, or claiming it never meant war. Fifth, treating the surviving texts of Urban's speech as a recording: they were written years later.
Key takeaways
Cluny's independence inspired a reform movement that captured the papacy, condemned simony and clerical marriage and, under Gregory VII, fought lay investiture, humbling Henry IV at Canossa in 1077. The Peace and Truce of God sought to restrain knights. Rome and Constantinople differed over language, celibacy, the creed and papal authority, and the excommunications of 1054 symbolised their drift. Byzantine missions converted Slavs. At Clermont in 1095, Urban II turned Alexios I's plea into an armed pilgrimage, while Muslim writers revived the call to jihad in response.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Buying or selling a church office
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What was lay investiture, which Gregory VII banned?
Question 2 of 5
Why is it misleading to say the churches split in 1054?
Question 3 of 5
What did Urban II promise those who joined the armed pilgrimage?
Question 4 of 5
A student reads Robert the Monk's version of Urban's speech as an exact record. What is the best correction?
Question 5 of 5
Which statement about jihad is best supported by the reading?
