World History › Section N · Crisis and new empires, 1300-1500 › Topic N.2
Famine, climate change, and migration
In the decades before the Black Death, a cooling and less stable climate met societies with little food to spare. Using tree rings, ice cores and old account books, historians can now trace how bad weather became hunger, and how hunger set people moving.
Weather that changed history
In the 1300s most people in Afro-Eurasia lived by farming, and a family's year depended on one harvest. A wet summer that rotted the grain could turn a hard year into a hungry one, and two bad harvests in a row could kill. Grain was costly to move overland, and few states kept large reserves. This topic asks how historians reconstruct the climate of the early 1300s, what it did to farming societies, and why so many people took to the roads.
Reading past climates
Historical climatology combines natural and written evidence. Tree rings grow wider in good years and narrower in cold or dry ones, giving a yearly record that can stretch back thousands of years. Ice cores drilled in Greenland and Antarctica trap layers of snow; spikes of sulphate in them mark large volcanic eruptions. Lake sediments, cave formations and pollen add longer-term signals. Written sources fill in the human side: chronicles describe storms and floods, and estate accounts such as those of the bishops of Winchester in England record harvest yields year by year. Each kind of evidence checks the others.
From warm to cool
Climate scientists call roughly 950 to 1250 the Medieval Climate Anomaly. Parts of the North Atlantic world were relatively warm, helping Norse settlers farm in Greenland, though other regions, such as western North America, suffered long droughts. A cooler, more erratic period followed, known as the Little Ice Age, lasting until about 1850. When it began is debated: some scholars date its start to around 1300, others to the 1400s, when the coldest phases came. Average Northern Hemisphere cooling was less than 1 °C, but the effects were uneven: more rain in one region, drought or early frosts in another.
Why the climate shifted
No single cause explains the change, and scientists still debate the mix. Volcanoes mattered: in 1257 Samalas, on the island of Lombok in Indonesia, produced one of the largest eruptions of the past thousand years, and further eruptions followed later in the century. Their sulphate clouds reflected sunlight and cooled summers for years. The sun was also less active, in a phase called the Wolf Minimum, from about 1280 to 1350. Growing sea ice and changes in ocean circulation may then have locked in the cooling. The historian Bruce Campbell argues that such natural forces, interacting with human societies, drove a "great transition" in the 1300s.
Europe on the edge
By about 1300 Europe's population had grown for three centuries. Farmers had ploughed poorer, colder or wetter land, and many peasant families held plots too small to feed them in a bad year. The economic historian Michael Postan argued that the population had outgrown its land, so a crisis was bound to come. Others, including Campbell, point to growing towns and markets that let people buy food, though markets also spread price shocks. Either way, many families had little margin when the weather turned.
The Great Famine, 1315 to 1317
In 1315 heavy rain fell across northern Europe from spring into autumn. Grain rotted in waterlogged fields, hay could not be dried and salt could not be made by evaporation. The harvest failed again in 1316, and grain prices rose to several times their normal level. The poor ate seed corn, sold their animals and wandered in search of food; chroniclers reported people eating roots, pets and worse. Northern Europe, from Ireland to Poland, was hit hardest, while the Mediterranean largely escaped. The historian William Chester Jordan estimates that perhaps 5 to 10 percent of the people in the worst-affected regions died.
Worked example: counting the dead at Ypres
Test a chronicle's horror stories against records. 1. The source: the city accounts of Ypres, in Flanders, record payments for collecting and burying bodies from the streets. 2. The figure: between May and October 1316, the town paid to bury about 2,800 people. 3. The scale: with a population of perhaps 20,000 to 30,000, that is roughly a tenth of the town in six months. 4. The pattern: the deaths peaked in summer, before the next harvest, when food stocks ran out. 5. The comparison: tree rings and harvest records confirm a cold, wet 1315 and 1316. 6. Conclusion: the chronicles exaggerated details, but independent records show a real mass mortality.
The cattle plague
A second disaster followed the first. From about 1315 a cattle disease, probably rinderpest, spread west across Europe, reaching England in 1319 and Ireland in 1321. The historian Tim Newfield estimates that it killed around three-fifths of the cattle in England and Wales. Losing oxen meant fewer animals to pull ploughs and less manure for fields, so harvests stayed poor; losing cows meant less milk for children. Some historians suggest that the children of these years grew into adults more vulnerable when plague struck in 1348. The bioarchaeologist Sharon DeWitte has shown that people whose skeletons bore signs of earlier stress were more likely to die in the Black Death.
People on the move
Hunger set people walking. In Europe, peasants left failing holdings for towns, where they begged or sought work, and towns sometimes expelled such strangers. In China, the Yellow River floods of 1344, described in the previous topic, drove refugees across the north. Most migrants travelled on foot, weak and far from kin, and were easily treated as outsiders. Others travelled by choice: merchants, pilgrims bound for Mecca or Jerusalem, and scholars such as Ibn Battuta, who journeyed from Morocco to, by his own account, China between 1325 and 1354. Both kinds of traveller moved goods, ideas and, soon, disease.
Worked example: why did the Ancestral Puebloans move?
Weigh causes for a migration in North America. 1. The event: by about 1300, Ancestral Puebloan farmers had left the Mesa Verde region and much of the Four Corners area of the southwestern United States. 2. Climate: tree rings record a severe drought from 1276 to 1299, which shrank maize harvests. 3. Society: archaeologists also find signs of violence, defensive cliff dwellings and strained, crowded villages. 4. The pull: many people joined growing communities along the Rio Grande and in Hopi and Zuni lands. 5. Descendants' view: Pueblo oral traditions describe planned journeys, not collapse. 6. Conclusion: drought pushed, but social choices shaped where and how people went.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, imagining the Little Ice Age as one steady freeze; it was a long, uneven period with cold and mild spells, and its start date is debated. Second, dismissing a fall of less than a degree as trivial; in farming societies near their margins it was enough to ruin harvests. Third, blaming climate alone; population pressure, markets, war and government choices decided who starved. Fourth, linking the great witch hunts to the 1300s; they peaked much later, in the 1500s and 1600s. Fifth, treating abandonment as disappearance; Ancestral Puebloans moved, and their descendants live on.
Key takeaways
Historians reconstruct past climate from tree rings, ice cores, sediments and pollen, together with chronicles and estate accounts. The Medieval Climate Anomaly, about 950 to 1250, gave way to a cooler, more erratic Little Ice Age, driven partly by volcanic eruptions such as Samalas in 1257 and by weak solar activity. In northern Europe, already crowded, the rains of 1315 and 1316 caused the Great Famine, and a cattle plague from about 1315 to the early 1320s prolonged the damage. Hunger forced people onto the roads in Europe and China, and drought helped push Ancestral Puebloans to move to new communities around 1300.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Reconstructing past climates from natural and written evidence
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What does a sharp spike of sulphate in a layer of a Greenland ice core usually reveal?
Question 2 of 5
What directly caused the Great Famine of 1315 to 1317 in northern Europe?
Question 3 of 5
Why did the cattle plague that began around 1315 prolong the crisis?
Question 4 of 5
Which explanation of the Ancestral Puebloan departure from the Four Corners area around 1300 fits the evidence best?
Question 5 of 5
Why could an average cooling of less than 1 °C cause famine in the 1300s?
