World History › Section N · Crisis and new empires, 1300-1500 › Topic N.3
The Black Death from east to west
Between 1346 and 1353 a plague spread from the steppe to the Mediterranean, the Middle East and Europe, killing perhaps a third or more of the people it reached. Ancient DNA has transformed what we know about where it came from, while written sources show how frightened societies tried to understand it.
The great mortality
People who lived through it called it the great mortality or the pestilence; the name Black Death became common only in later centuries. Its first wave crossed western Eurasia and North Africa between 1346 and 1353, and plague then returned every decade or two for over three hundred years. The topic on the Byzantine Empire and Sasanian Persia showed that the same bacterium had struck the Mediterranean once before, in the 540s. This topic follows the second pandemic from its likely source to the Atlantic.
The disease
Plague is caused by the bacterium Yersinia pestis, which lives among wild rodents such as marmots and gerbils in the grasslands and mountains of Central Asia. Infected fleas pass it to animals and people. In bubonic plague the bacteria reach the lymph nodes, which swell into painful lumps called buboes in the groin, armpit or neck; untreated, perhaps 30 to 60 percent of patients die. If the infection reaches the lungs, it becomes pneumonic plague, which spreads from person to person in coughed droplets and is almost always fatal without treatment. Septicaemic plague, infecting the blood, kills fastest. Today antibiotics cure most cases caught early.
How did it travel?
The classic explanation runs through black rats. Rats lived in ships, barns and houses; when plague killed them, their hungry fleas jumped to humans. This explains why plague followed shipping and grain routes. Yet chroniclers rarely mention dead rats, and plague spread fast in cold northern regions where rats were few. A modelling study published in 2018 argued that human fleas and body lice, passing infection directly between people, fit the death patterns of several European outbreaks better than rats do. Many specialists now think several routes worked together, with trade, armies and refugees carrying infection along.
What ancient DNA revealed
For decades some scholars doubted that plague caused the Black Death at all, because its speed seemed unusual. Ancient DNA settled the question: in 2011 scientists rebuilt the genome of Yersinia pestis from teeth in a London cemetery of 1348 to 1350. Comparing ancient and modern genomes revealed a "big bang", when the bacterium split into several branches that still exist. The medical historian Monica Green argues that this split happened in the 1200s, as Mongol armies and their supplies moved across Eurasia; other researchers place it closer to 1340. Either way, the DNA points to Central Asia.
Worked example: the gravestones of Issyk-Kul
See how inscriptions and genetics combine. 1. The sources: at Kara-Djigach and Burana, in the Chüy valley west of Lake Issyk-Kul in today's Kyrgyzstan, Christian gravestones of the Church of the East, written in Syriac, record many deaths in 1338 and 1339, some from "pestilence". 2. The test: in 2022 a team led by Maria Spyrou extracted DNA from teeth in those graves. 3. The result: the bacteria were Yersinia pestis, of a strain sitting at the very root of the branches that later spread west. 4. The inference: the team argues that the Black Death strain arose in or near the Tian Shan mountains shortly before 1338. 5. The limits: the study shows where the strain lived, not the exact route it took to Europe.
Along the routes west
Russian chronicles record plague in the Golden Horde's cities on the lower Volga in 1346, while its khan, Jani Beg, was besieging Caffa, a Genoese port in Crimea. The notary Gabriele de' Mussis of Piacenza later wrote that the besiegers hurled plague corpses into the town. He was not an eyewitness, and most historians think rats, fleas or sick people would have carried plague out by ship in any case. In 1347 it reached Constantinople, Alexandria and, in October, Messina in Sicily. During 1348 it swept Italy, France, Spain, England, Egypt and Syria; by 1349 it reached Norway, and by the early 1350s Russia.
The plague in the Islamic world
Egypt and Syria suffered as badly as Europe. The historian Michael Dols estimated that Mamluk Egypt lost perhaps a quarter to a third of its people, and Cairo's death toll peaked in late 1348. Muslim scholars drew on religious teaching: plague was a mercy and martyrdom for believers, and people should neither enter nor flee an afflicted land. The poet Ibn al-Wardi of Aleppo described the plague in an essay before dying of it in 1349. In Damascus, Ibn Battuta saw Muslims, Christians and Jews march together in a procession of prayer. In Granada, the physician Ibn al-Khatib argued from observation that the disease was contagious.
How many died?
No one counted the dead, so every figure is an estimate built from tax lists, wills, manorial records and burials. For Europe as a whole, most historians propose 30 to 50 percent; Ole Benedictow argues for about 60 percent. Some cities, such as Florence, may have lost half their people or more. A 2022 study of fossil pollen from hundreds of sites found that farming collapsed in some regions after 1348 but continued or even grew in others, so mortality was very uneven. For China, India and sub-Saharan Africa, evidence that this plague struck at all is thin, and scholars still debate it.
Europe searches for answers
In 1348 the medical faculty of Paris blamed a conjunction of planets in 1345 that had corrupted the air. Those who could fled to the countryside. Italian cities set up health boards, and in 1377 Ragusa, today's Dubrovnik, required travellers from infected areas to wait 30 days before entering; the later 40-day rule gave us the word quarantine. Many saw God's punishment. Bands of flagellants marched from town to town whipping themselves in penance until Pope Clement VI condemned them in 1349. In Florence, Giovanni Boccaccio framed his Decameron around young people escaping the plague.
Worked example: Strasbourg, February 1349
Analyse the causes of a massacre. 1. The rumour: from 1348, Jews were accused of poisoning wells, using "confessions" taken under torture in Savoy. 2. The official answer: Pope Clement VI declared the charge false in 1348, noting that Jews died of plague too. 3. The local politics: Strasbourg's council defended its Jews, but craft guilds overthrew the council in February 1349. 4. The killing: on 14 February hundreds of Jews, perhaps as many as 2,000 by one chronicler's count, were burned, and debts owed to them were cancelled. 5. The timing: plague had not yet reached Strasbourg. 6. Conclusion: fear supplied the accusation, but politics and debt explain who acted; a local chronicler remarked that money was the real poison.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, saying the plague started in China; current evidence points to Central Asia, and Chinese records of the time do not clearly describe it. Second, treating the rat-and-flea route as the only one. Third, giving one precise death toll for Europe; estimates range from about 30 to 60 percent, and losses varied by region. Fourth, accepting the Caffa corpse story as proof of how plague reached Europe. Fifth, assuming Muslims simply resigned themselves; responses varied, and Ibn al-Khatib argued for contagion. Sixth, explaining the attacks on Jews as a reaction to infection; some massacres happened before plague arrived.
Key takeaways
The Black Death, caused by Yersinia pestis, swept western Eurasia and North Africa from 1346 to 1353 in bubonic, pneumonic and septicaemic forms, spread by rats' fleas and probably by human parasites too. Ancient DNA confirmed the cause, and graves of 1338 and 1339 near Issyk-Kul hold a strain at the root of the pandemic's branches. Plague moved through the Golden Horde and Caffa to Constantinople, Egypt and Italy in 1347. Europe probably lost 30 to 60 percent of its people, unevenly; Egypt perhaps a quarter to a third. Responses ranged from prayer and quarantine to flagellants and massacres of Jews.
Flashcards
Flashcard
The bacterium that causes plague
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What did the 2022 study of graves near Lake Issyk-Kul show?
Question 2 of 5
How does pneumonic plague differ from bubonic plague?
Question 3 of 5
Why do historians doubt that the Caffa siege explains how plague reached Europe?
Question 4 of 5
What does the timing of the Strasbourg massacre of February 1349 suggest?
Question 5 of 5
What did the physician Ibn al-Khatib of Granada argue about the plague?
