World History › Section N · Crisis and new empires, 1300-1500 › Topic N.4

Long-term effects of the fourteenth-century crisis

Famine, plague and war left fewer people sharing the same land. The result was not one single outcome but many: higher wages and failed revolts in England, harsher rule in Egypt, a split papacy, stronger kings, and new religious movements across Afro-Eurasia.

A world with fewer people

The Black Death did not end in 1353. Plague returned in 1361 and 1362, a wave that killed many children and young adults, and again every decade or so after that. Each return held populations down: England probably did not regain its population of 1300 until the 1600s. The same land, tools and towns now served far fewer people, and that new balance drove much of what followed. But societies did not all respond in the same way, and explaining why is a major debate of late medieval history.

Labour becomes scarce

With so many workers dead, those who survived could bargain. In western Europe, peasants left their lords for better terms elsewhere, landlords struggled to find tenants, and rents fell. Wage earners demanded more, and records of English building workers and farm labourers show real wages rising substantially between 1350 and the mid-1400s. Ordinary people ate more meat and wheat bread and drank more ale. The historian David Herlihy argued that the plague broke a long deadlock of too many people on too little land, encouraging labour-saving methods and new ideas.

Lords push back

Landowners and rulers tried to hold back the change. In 1349 England's Ordinance of Labourers ordered able-bodied people under sixty to work for anyone who needed them, at the wages paid before the plague; the Statute of Labourers of 1351 restated it with fixed rates and penalties. A law of 1363 even set what food and clothing each rank might enjoy. France, Castile and other kingdoms passed similar measures. Courts fined thousands of workers and employers, but the laws could not defeat the market for long: employers short of hands quietly paid more. They also bred deep resentment.

Revolts from below

Anger erupted in a wave of revolts. In 1358, after the French king John II was captured at Poitiers, peasants near Paris rose in the Jacquerie, attacking nobles they blamed for defeat and taxes; knights crushed them within weeks. In 1378 Florence's wool workers, the Ciompi, briefly seized the city government. In 1381 English poll taxes set off the Peasants' Revolt. Rebels entered London, and the preacher John Ball is reported to have asked: "When Adam delved and Eve span, who was then the gentleman?" The leader Wat Tyler was killed and the revolt suppressed, but the poll tax was abandoned, and serfdom in England faded over the next century.

Worked example: why did serfdom fade in the west but not the east?

Compare one shock and two outcomes. 1. The puzzle: western and eastern Europe both lost people to plague. 2. The west: in England and France, serfdom faded and peasants won freer tenures by about 1500. 3. The east: in Poland, Prussia and Bohemia, lords later tied peasants more tightly to the land, a "second serfdom" that hardened in the 1500s. 4. The problem: Michael Postan and others stressed population, but one population fall cannot explain opposite results. 5. Robert Brenner's argument: the outcome depended on the balance of power between lords and organised peasant communities. 6. Another factor: western demand for grain later gave eastern lords reason to tighten control. 7. Conclusion: demography set the pressure; social structures decided the response.

Worked example: Egypt and England compared

Test an explanation across two regions. 1. The shock: both lost a large share of their people to plague. 2. England: landlords lived on their estates and competed for scarce tenants, so terms improved and output recovered. 3. Egypt: Mamluk officers held the right to collect revenue from villages but lived in Cairo, and they responded by squeezing the surviving peasants harder. 4. The environment: Egypt's farming relied on dykes and canals that needed constant labour, and with fewer workers they decayed. 5. The historian Stuart Borsch argues that this is why Egypt's farming output stayed depressed long after England's recovered. 6. Conclusion: institutions shaped recovery.

War and royal power

The Hundred Years' War reshaped warfare and the state. English armies of longbowmen and dismounted knights beat larger French armies at Crécy in 1346, Poitiers in 1356 and Agincourt in 1415. France recovered after Joan of Arc helped lift the siege of Orléans in 1429, and French cannon helped win the final battle at Castillon in 1453, leaving England only Calais. To pay for war, kings taxed more regularly: from the 1440s the French crown kept a permanent tax and a standing army. Paid soldiers and gunpowder weakened the mounted noble's military role, and many historians see the war strengthening national identity in both kingdoms.

A divided Church

In 1378, soon after the papacy returned to Rome from Avignon, the cardinals elected Urban VI, then rejected him and chose a rival who settled in Avignon: the Great Western Schism. A council at Pisa in 1409 tried to end it and produced a third claimant. The Council of Constance, from 1414 to 1418, finally removed the rivals and elected Martin V in 1417, encouraging the idea that councils stood above popes. Critics went further. The English scholar John Wycliffe attacked clerical wealth and inspired an English Bible; his followers were called Lollards. In Bohemia Jan Hus took up similar ideas and was burned at Constance in 1415.

Living with death

Repeated plague changed how people faced mortality. Artists painted the Dance of Death, in which skeletons lead popes, kings and peasants alike. Some wealthy people chose tombs showing their own rotting corpse beneath an image of themselves in fine robes, and in the 1400s handbooks on the art of dying well, the Ars moriendi, became popular. Historians debate how far these trends were caused by plague, since several began before 1348, but recurring epidemics kept death at the centre of religious and artistic life for generations.

Beyond Europe

Across the Islamic world, Sufi brotherhoods and their lodges spread, offering personal devotion and community in uncertain times. The scholar Ibn Khaldun, who lost his parents to the plague in Tunis in 1349, wrote in his Muqaddimah of 1377 that the pestilence had swept away cities and dynasties as if the whole world had changed, and he built a theory of how states rise and fall. In China the Ming, covered in the topic on the Mamluks to Ming China, rebuilt rural order: the Hongwu emperor registered households and land, and the Yongle emperor sponsored a vast encyclopedia of Chinese learning between 1403 and 1408.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, saying the Black Death simply ended serfdom; in eastern Europe serfdom later grew harsher. Second, assuming the revolts succeeded; most were crushed, and change came slowly through the labour market. Third, treating 1353 as the end of plague; it returned for centuries. Fourth, giving one cause for everything; population, institutions, war and environment worked together. Fifth, dating Wycliffe and Hus to the Reformation; they were medieval critics, a century before Luther. Sixth, forgetting regions outside Europe; Egypt's slower recovery shows that the same shock could have different results.

Key takeaways

Repeated plague left fewer people on the same land. In western Europe labour grew scarce, wages and diets improved, and lords' attempts to freeze wages, such as England's laws of 1349 and 1351, bred resentment and revolts: the Jacquerie in 1358, the Ciompi in 1378 and the Peasants' Revolt in 1381. Serfdom faded in the west but later hardened in the east, which Robert Brenner explains by the balance of social power; Stuart Borsch shows Egypt recovering more slowly than England. The Hundred Years' War strengthened kings, the Great Schism weakened popes until 1417, and Sufism and Ming reconstruction reshaped Asia.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Recurring plague

Plague returned in 1361 to 1362 and roughly every decade after

It stopped populations recovering.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

What did England's Ordinance of 1349 and Statute of Labourers of 1351 try to do?

Question 2 of 5

What is Robert Brenner's explanation for why serfdom faded in the west but hardened in the east?

Question 3 of 5

According to Stuart Borsch, why did Egypt recover from the plague more slowly than England?

Question 4 of 5

How did the Council of Constance end the Great Western Schism?

Question 5 of 5

Why did real wages rise in western Europe after about 1350?

← Previous topicNext topic →