World History › Section W · Between the wars › Topic W.1
Recovering from World War I
The peace made in 1919 tried to punish Germany, redraw Europe and prevent another war all at once. How those aims clashed, and how reparations, inflation and fragile treaties shaped the 1920s, explains much of what went wrong in the decades that followed.
A world counting its losses
When the fighting stopped in November 1918, an estimated 9 to 10 million soldiers had died and more than 20 million had been wounded, and estimates of civilian deaths from fighting, hunger and disease run to several million more. In Belgium and northern France, whole towns and wide stretches of farmland lay ruined. An influenza pandemic between 1918 and 1920 infected perhaps a third of the world's people and killed an estimated 20 to 50 million or more, probably more than the war itself.
Peacemaking in Paris
The victors gathered in Paris from January 1919. Four leaders dominated: Woodrow Wilson of the United States, David Lloyd George of Britain, Georges Clemenceau of France and Vittorio Orlando of Italy. The defeated powers were not allowed to negotiate, and Soviet Russia was absent. Wilson brought his Fourteen Points of January 1918, which called for open diplomacy, freedom of the seas, borders drawn along national lines and a League of Nations. Clemenceau wanted security and compensation for France. Each defeated state received a separate treaty; the one with Germany was signed at Versailles on 28 June 1919.
What Versailles demanded of Germany
Germany lost about 13 percent of its European territory and roughly a tenth of its population. Alsace-Lorraine returned to France, land in the east went to the revived Poland, and the port of Danzig became a free city under the League of Nations. The Rhineland was demilitarised. The army was capped at 100,000 men, conscription was banned, and tanks, military aircraft and submarines were forbidden. Germany also lost all its colonies. Article 231, holding Germany and its allies responsible for the war's loss and damage, became the basis for reparations, whose total was fixed in 1921 at 132 billion gold marks, about $33 billion.
New maps, old problems
Austria-Hungary, the Russian Empire and the Ottoman Empire had collapsed. The treaties with Austria, Hungary and Bulgaria in 1919 and 1920 confirmed a crowd of new or enlarged states: Poland, Czechoslovakia, the Kingdom of Serbs, Croats and Slovenes (later Yugoslavia), and a much smaller Austria and Hungary. Self-determination was the stated principle, but central Europe's peoples lived intermixed, so every border left minorities behind. About 3 million German speakers found themselves in Czechoslovakia, and Hungary lost more than two-thirds of its territory under the Treaty of Trianon. Nationalists would exploit these grievances for the next 20 years.
Disappointed allies: Japan, China and Italy
Japan proposed a clause affirming the equality of races. It won a majority on the drafting commission in April 1919, but after Australia and Britain objected, Wilson, as chair, ruled that it needed unanimity, and it was dropped. Japan did keep Germany's former rights in China's Shandong province, which outraged Chinese opinion. On 4 May 1919 students protested in Beijing, launching the May Fourth Movement, and China refused to sign the treaty. Italy, denied the Dalmatian lands it had been promised in 1915, complained of a "mutilated victory", a resentment Benito Mussolini exploited on his way to power in 1922.
Worked example: from the Ruhr to worthless money
How did the Weimar Republic's reparations bill become a collapse of the currency? 1. Trigger: when Germany fell behind on deliveries of coal and timber, French and Belgian troops occupied the Ruhr, its industrial heartland, in January 1923. 2. Response: the government urged passive resistance and kept paying idle workers while output and taxes from the region collapsed. 3. Mechanism: it printed money to fill the gap, so more marks chased fewer goods. 4. Spiral: people spent wages at once, pushing prices higher; by November 1923 a US dollar cost about 4.2 trillion marks. 5. Consequence: savings and pensions vanished, and in November Adolf Hitler's Nazis tried and failed to seize power in the Beer Hall Putsch in Munich, before a new currency, the Rentenmark, ended the crisis. 6. Check: inflation began during the war, so 1923 accelerated it rather than starting it.
Dawes, Young and a circle of money
In 1924 the Dawes Plan, named after the American banker Charles Dawes, eased Germany's yearly payments for a time and arranged a large international loan. A circle formed: American money flowed into Germany, Germany paid reparations to Britain and France, and they repaid their war debts to the United States. The Young Plan of 1929 lowered the total again and stretched payments over 59 years. The circle worked only while American lenders kept lending. When they pulled back after 1929 it broke: payments were suspended in 1931 and effectively ended in 1932. Germany paid only a fraction of the 1921 total.
An uneven recovery around the world
The United States, now the world's chief creditor, enjoyed a boom built on cars, radios and buying on credit, as the US History course explains. Japan's wartime export boom gave way to a postwar slump, the Great Kanto Earthquake of 1923 and a banking crisis in 1927. Latin American economies still rested on exports such as coffee, beef and, increasingly, Venezuelan oil, so they rose and fell with world prices. In Africa, Britain and France tried to make colonies pay, often reserving the most profitable crops and concessions for European settlers and firms.
Building a lasting peace
The League of Nations, based in Geneva, aimed at collective security: members would act together against an aggressor. It settled some small disputes, but it had no army, usually needed unanimity, and lacked the United States, whose Senate refused to ratify the treaty. The Washington Naval Conference of 1921 to 1922 fixed battleship tonnage in a ratio of 5 : 5 : 3 : 1.75 : 1.75 for Britain, the United States, Japan, France and Italy. At Locarno in 1925 Germany accepted its western borders, joining the League in 1926, and the Kellogg-Briand Pact of 1928 renounced war but had no means of enforcement.
Worked example: was the treaty too harsh?
Historians still disagree. 1. The case for harshness: the economist John Maynard Keynes, a British Treasury adviser in Paris, called it a "Carthaginian peace" in The Economic Consequences of the Peace (1919) and predicted reparations would ruin Europe's economy. 2. The case against: historians such as Sally Marks and Margaret MacMillan argue that Germany kept its unity and industry and could have paid far more than it did. 3. Check the timing: Keynes wrote before the 1921 total was fixed and before the 1923 inflation. 4. Conclusion: many scholars now see a treaty too severe to reconcile Germany yet too weak to restrain it, and they give later political choices as much weight as the terms.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, saying the Treaty of Versailles made peace with all the Central Powers; it dealt only with Germany. Second, assuming the United States joined the League of Nations; Wilson proposed it, but the Senate never ratified the treaty. Third, blaming the 1923 hyperinflation on the Great Depression, which began six years later. Fourth, thinking Versailles named the reparations figure; the total was set in 1921. Fifth, assuming self-determination reached colonised peoples; the peacemakers applied it mainly within Europe.
Key takeaways
Versailles took territory, colonies and most of the army from Germany, and Article 231 grounded reparations fixed in 1921 at 132 billion gold marks. New states arose, but their borders left minorities and grievances, and Japan, China and Italy felt cheated. The Ruhr occupation and money printing caused the 1923 hyperinflation; the Dawes and Young Plans built a circle of American loans that broke after 1929. The League, the Washington treaties, Locarno and Kellogg-Briand promised peace without the power to enforce it.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Wilson, Lloyd George, Clemenceau and Orlando at the Paris Peace Conference
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which of these was a term of the Treaty of Versailles itself?
Question 2 of 5
What triggered the May Fourth Movement of 1919 in China?
Question 3 of 5
Which sequence best explains the German hyperinflation of 1923?
Question 4 of 5
Which statement fairly describes the debate over whether Versailles was too harsh?
Question 5 of 5
The Washington Naval Conference set battleship tonnage for Britain, the United States and Japan in which ratio?
