World History › Section V · World War I › Topic V.5
The war ends and the peace settlement
The First World War did not end with one side marching into the other's capital. It ended as empires cracked from within, first Russia's in 1917 and then Germany's and its allies' in 1918, and the peace made in Paris redrew the map of three continents.
A war ended by collapse
By 1917 no general had found a way to break the trenches. What finally ended the war was the failure of whole states under the strain of total war. Russia's monarchy fell first, and its new rulers made a separate peace. Germany then staked everything on one great offensive, lost, and watched its allies, army and home front give way within weeks. To understand November 1918, start with Russia, where the strain showed long before the war.
Tsarism under strain
Nicholas II ruled as an autocrat, answerable to no parliament. On 9 January 1905, by the calendar then used in Russia, troops in St Petersburg fired on workers led by the priest Georgy Gapon who were marching to petition the tsar. Estimates of the dead range from the official figure of about 130 to around 1,000. Strikes, mutinies and peasant risings followed. In his October Manifesto Nicholas promised an elected parliament, the Duma, which first met in 1906. Yet he kept control of ministers and the army, and he dissolved the first two Dumas within months.
The February Revolution
The war broke the old order. Russia lost millions of men killed, wounded or captured, and food and fuel ran short in the cities. In 1915 Nicholas took personal command of the army, so defeats were blamed on him, while the unpopular Empress Alexandra, advised by the healer Rasputin, stayed in the capital. In late February 1917, strikes and bread protests in Petrograd swelled into revolution when soldiers refused to fire on crowds and joined them. Nicholas abdicated in March. Power was split between a Provisional Government of Duma politicians and the Petrograd Soviet, a council of workers' and soldiers' deputies.
October and Brest-Litovsk
The Provisional Government, led from July by Alexander Kerensky, kept fighting, and a failed summer offensive cost it support. Vladimir Lenin, leader of the Bolsheviks, returned from exile in April with German help, Germany hoping he would take Russia out of the war. His slogan "Peace, land and bread" won workers and soldiers. On 25 October 1917, by the Russian calendar, the Bolsheviks seized power in Petrograd. They signed an armistice in December, and in the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk of March 1918 gave up Poland, the Baltic lands, Finland and Ukraine, territory holding about a third of the old empire's people. Civil war followed, and the Bolsheviks had largely won it by about 1921.
Worked example: why Russia left the war
1. Long-term weakness: a slow-industrialising economy and an autocracy that had conceded only a limited Duma after 1905. 2. War strain: huge losses, shortages of weapons, and food queues in the cities. 3. Trigger: the Petrograd mutiny of February 1917, when soldiers sided with the crowds. 4. Missed chance: the Provisional Government stayed in the war, letting the Bolsheviks claim the demand for peace. 5. Outside help: Germany eased Lenin's return. 6. Decision: the Bolsheviks accepted Brest-Litovsk because they believed peace was the price of keeping power. Conclusion: old weaknesses and wartime strain together pushed Russia out of the war.
Germany's last gamble
Peace in the east let Germany move divisions west. On 21 March 1918 it launched the first of a series of spring offensives, using small, fast groups of storm troops to infiltrate British lines. They gained more ground than any attack since 1914, but the advances outran their supplies and cost about as many casualties as they inflicted. Meanwhile American troops were arriving in large numbers, as the US History course explains. The Allies struck back on the Marne in July, and at Amiens on 8 August, a day Ludendorff called the black day of the German army. A string of Allied advances followed.
The Central Powers collapse
Germany's allies broke first. Bulgaria signed an armistice on 29 September 1918 and the Ottomans on 30 October. Austria-Hungary dissolved as Czechs, Slovaks, Poles and South Slavs declared their own states in October, and its army signed an armistice on 3 November. On 29 September Ludendorff told the emperor that Germany needed an armistice, and a new government asked President Wilson for peace on the basis of his Fourteen Points. When naval commanders ordered the fleet out for a last battle, sailors mutinied, and revolt spread from Kiel to other cities. On 9 November a republic was proclaimed in Berlin, and Wilhelm II fled to the Netherlands.
The armistice and the cost
Germany's delegates signed the armistice in a railway carriage near Compiègne, and fighting stopped at 11 a.m. on 11 November 1918. Germany had to leave occupied France and Belgium, let Allied troops occupy the Rhineland, hand over weapons and submarines, and send its surface fleet to be interned; the blockade continued until peace was signed. Because no Allied army had entered Germany, generals such as Hindenburg later spread the false "stab in the back" myth that the army had been betrayed at home. The war killed an estimated 9 to 10 million soldiers, among them about 2 million Germans and 1.4 million French, and millions of civilians. The 1918 influenza then killed an estimated 20 to 50 million or more worldwide.
The peace settlement
From January 1919 the victors met in Paris, led by Wilson, Clemenceau of France, Lloyd George of Britain and Orlando of Italy; the defeated powers and Soviet Russia were not invited to negotiate. Separate treaties dealt with each loser: Versailles with Germany in June 1919, then Saint-Germain with Austria, Neuilly with Bulgaria, Trianon with Hungary, and Sèvres with the Ottomans, later replaced by Lausanne in 1923. New states appeared, including Poland, Czechoslovakia and the Kingdom of Serbs, Croats and Slovenes. Ottoman Arab lands and German colonies became League of Nations mandates under Allied rule. When Shandong went to Japan, protests swept China, and nationalists from Egypt to Korea rose in 1919.
Worked example: the war-guilt clause
1. The text: Article 231 of the Treaty of Versailles had Germany accept responsibility, for itself and its allies, for causing the loss and damage of the war. 2. Its purpose: the American drafters meant it as the legal basis for reparations, and similar clauses appeared in the other treaties. 3. The reaction: Germans read it as a verdict of sole moral guilt and campaigned against it for years. 4. The early critique: the economist John Maynard Keynes argued in 1919 that the peace was vindictive and would ruin Europe. 5. Later views: historians such as Sally Marks and Margaret MacMillan argue the terms were less crushing than their reputation, and that enforcement failed. Conclusion: the clause's meaning is itself a historical debate.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, saying Germany surrendered unconditionally in 1918: it signed an armistice, a ceasefire on agreed terms. Second, believing the "stab in the back" myth. Third, dating the Russian revolutions by the Western calendar without saying so: February and October are Russian-calendar months. Fourth, treating Versailles as the whole settlement, when five treaties covered the five defeated powers. Fifth, quoting one exact death toll; give attributed ranges. Sixth, presenting Article 231 as settled proof of sole German guilt.
Key takeaways
Tsarism survived 1905 with a limited Duma, then cracked in the war: the February Revolution of 1917 ended the monarchy, and the Bolsheviks seized power in October and left the war at Brest-Litovsk. Germany's 1918 offensives failed, the Allies advanced from August, and Germany's allies gave up. Mutiny and revolution toppled Wilhelm II, and the armistice took effect on 11 November 1918. About 9 to 10 million soldiers died. The Paris treaties created new states and mandates, and historians still debate Article 231.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Troops fired on marching workers in St Petersburg
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What did Nicholas II do in response to the revolution of 1905?
Question 2 of 5
Why did the Bolsheviks accept the harsh Treaty of Brest-Litovsk?
Question 3 of 5
Why is the "stab in the back" claim about 1918 considered a myth?
Question 4 of 5
Which statement about the peace settlement of 1919 to 1923 is accurate?
Question 5 of 5
What do historians such as Sally Marks and Margaret MacMillan argue about the Versailles settlement?
