World History › Section U · Life and labor in the industrial world › Topic U.5
Reform and revolutionary ideologies
Faced with filthy cities, dangerous work and deep poverty, people answered in three broad ways: governments regulated, reformers campaigned, and socialists and anarchists called for a different society altogether. This topic weighs what each approach tried and achieved.
Three answers to the industrial age
The topics Life in the industrial city and Coerced and semicoerced labor showed the costs of rapid industrial growth. By the late 1800s few people believed those problems would solve themselves. Governments passed laws on public health, housing and working conditions, and began to insure workers against sickness and old age. Voluntary reform movements, many led by middle-class women, attacked drink, vice and poverty. Workers organised trade unions. And socialists and anarchists argued that only a transformed economy could end exploitation. These answers overlapped, competed and often borrowed from one another.
Cleaning and rebuilding cities
Britain's Public Health Act of 1848 created a General Board of Health, and a stronger act of 1875 required every local area to have a sanitary authority responsible for drains, water and nuisances. Early laws against factory smoke were weakly enforced. In Paris, Baron Haussmann rebuilt the centre between 1853 and 1870, with wide boulevards, new sewers and parks, but demolition pushed many workers to the outskirts, and critics argued the straight avenues also helped troops control the city. Reformers prized parks: New York laid out Central Park from 1858, and in 1873 Japan's government told its prefectures to turn temple and shrine grounds into public parks.
Factory laws and social insurance
Britain's Factory Acts were extended in the 1860s and 1870s from textile mills to most workshops, limiting the hours of women and children. In the United States, courts often struck down such laws as violations of freedom of contract: in Lochner v. New York (1905) the Supreme Court overturned a limit on bakers' hours, though in Muller v. Oregon (1908) it upheld one for women. Germany pioneered social insurance, with health insurance in 1883, accident insurance in 1884 and old-age and disability pensions in 1889, funded by workers, employers and the state. Britain followed with old-age pensions in 1908 and the National Insurance Act of 1911.
Worked example: why Bismarck insured workers
Explain why a conservative leader built the first national system of social insurance. 1. Threat: Germany's socialist party, formed in 1875 and named the Social Democratic Party in 1890, was winning working-class votes. 2. Stick: the Anti-Socialist Laws of 1878-1890 banned socialist organisations, meetings and newspapers. 3. Carrot: Chancellor Otto von Bismarck introduced sickness, accident and old-age insurance between 1883 and 1889. 4. Aim: by most accounts, he hoped to tie workers to the state and draw them away from socialism. 5. Result: the insurance laws lasted, but the strategy failed politically; by 1912 the Social Democrats were the largest party in the Reichstag. 6. Conclusion: reform could be a conservative tool as well as a progressive one.
Moral reform and women's activism
Many middle-class reformers blamed drink for poverty, crime and violence at home. Temperance movements urged moderation or abstinence, and prohibitionists sought to ban alcohol outright, through groups such as Britain's United Kingdom Alliance, founded in 1853, and the American Anti-Saloon League, founded in 1893. Women led much of this work: the Woman's Christian Temperance Union, formed in 1874, became a mass movement. Josephine Butler campaigned against Britain's Contagious Diseases Acts, which subjected suspected prostitutes, not their clients, to forced medical examination, and won their repeal in 1886. Such campaigns convinced many women they needed the vote, which New Zealand granted in 1893.
Explaining poverty
Reformers disagreed about why people were poor. Samuel Smiles's Self-Help (1859), which opens with the maxim "Heaven helps those who help themselves", taught that thrift and hard work were the road out of poverty. The housing reformer Octavia Hill provided decent homes at low rents but evicted tenants who failed to pay or keep order. Herbert Spencer, a leading social Darwinist, opposed state help altogether. Others moved in among the poor: university men founded Toynbee Hall in London's East End in 1884, and Jane Addams opened Hull House in Chicago in 1889. Settlement workers often concluded that low wages, not bad character, were the main cause.
Worked example: comparing two views of poverty
Compare Smiles's Self-Help with Charles Booth's survey of London, described in Life in the industrial city. 1. Claim: Smiles argued that national progress was the sum of individual effort, so character, not law, was the cure. 2. Evidence: he relied on inspiring life stories of self-made men, not on systematic data. 3. Booth's method: house-by-house investigation of a whole city. 4. Booth's finding: about 30 percent of Londoners were poor, largely because of low and irregular pay. 5. Effect: such evidence supported new laws, such as Britain's old-age pensions of 1908. 6. Conclusion: by 1900, the explanation of poverty was shifting from personal failing to economic structure, though both views survived.
Trade unions and labour parties
British unions of skilled craftsmen formed the Trades Union Congress in 1868; laws of 1871 and 1875 secured unions' legal status and allowed peaceful picketing. From the late 1880s a New Unionism organised the unskilled. After the matchwomen's strike of 1888, London dockers struck in 1889 and won their main demand, sixpence an hour. Unions then backed their own candidates, creating the Labour Party, which took that name in 1906, and a wave of strikes in 1910-1914 became known as the Great Unrest. In the United States, the American Federation of Labor, founded in 1886, organised skilled crafts and avoided party politics.
From utopias to Marx
Early socialists imagined ideal communities. The mill owner Robert Owen ran New Lanark in Scotland from 1800 with shorter hours, schools and decent housing, and in 1825 founded New Harmony in Indiana, which soon failed. Henri de Saint-Simon and Charles Fourier designed plans for cooperative societies. Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels dismissed such schemes as utopian. In The Communist Manifesto (1848) they argued that history is driven by class struggle, that the bourgeoisie who owned factories exploited the proletariat who worked in them, and that workers would overthrow capitalism. It ends: "Working men of all countries, unite!"
Socialists, anarchists and their critics
Socialists split over methods. In the First International, founded in 1864, Marx clashed with the Russian anarchist Mikhail Bakunin, who wanted to abolish the state at once; Bakunin was expelled in 1872. Germany's Social Democrats grew into a mass party, and Eduard Bernstein argued in 1899 that socialism could come gradually through elections and reform. Russia's Social Democrats, founded in 1898, split in 1903 into Lenin's Bolsheviks and the Mensheviks. Some anarchists turned to assassination, killing the French president in 1894 and US President McKinley in 1901. Defenders of capitalism replied that profit rewarded risk and that private property gave people a reason to work.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming reform laws worked once passed; many were weakly enforced or struck down by courts. Second, treating Bismarck's welfare state as a socialist project; he built it partly to defeat socialists. Third, merging socialism and anarchism; anarchists rejected any state, including a workers' state. Fourth, believing all socialists sought violent revolution; social democrats such as Bernstein worked through elections. Fifth, overlooking women's leadership in temperance, social purity and settlement work. Sixth, confusing Smiles's self-help argument with evidence from systematic surveys.
Key takeaways
Governments answered industrial problems with public health acts, rebuilt cities, parks, factory laws and, from Germany in the 1880s, social insurance, though enforcement was often weak. Bismarck combined insurance with anti-socialist laws. Middle-class reformers, many of them women, fought drink and vice and debated whether poverty came from character or wages, while settlement houses and surveys favoured wages. Unions grew, organised the unskilled from the late 1880s and founded labour parties. Socialists followed Owen's utopias, then Marx, and divided into revolutionaries, social democrats and anarchists.
Flashcards
Flashcard
British law requiring local sanitary authorities
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Why did Bismarck introduce health, accident and old-age insurance in the 1880s?
Question 2 of 5
What did Josephine Butler's campaign achieve?
Question 3 of 5
How did settlement workers and survey makers tend to explain poverty?
Question 4 of 5
What was the main disagreement between Marx and Bakunin in the First International?
Question 5 of 5
What was New Unionism in Britain from the late 1880s?
