World History › Section S · Latin American independence › Topic S.3

Independence in Spanish South America

Spanish South America won independence in fifteen years of war fought across deserts, plains and the Andes. Two liberators, Simón Bolívar from the north and José de San Martín from the south, converged on Peru, but their victories depended on people their own class often feared.

Venezuela's First Republic

Independence came on two fronts, the north led by Simón Bolívar and the south by José de San Martín, the libertadores, or liberators. In the north, on 19 April 1810 the creole council of Caracas removed the Spanish captain general and formed a junta in Ferdinand VII's name. Francisco de Miranda, a veteran of the French revolutionary armies, led the patriots, and on 5 July 1811 a congress declared Venezuela independent, the first such declaration in Spanish South America. The republic limited voting to property owners and kept slavery, so many pardos, enslaved people and plains cowboys backed the royalists. In March 1812 an earthquake devastated patriot-held cities, and royalist clergy called it divine punishment. Miranda surrendered that July and died in a Spanish prison.

War to the death

Simón Bolívar, the son of a wealthy creole family of Caracas, regrouped in New Granada and in 1813 swept back into Venezuela. That June he issued his Decree of War to the Death: Spaniards and Canary Islanders who did not actively support independence would be killed, while Americans would be spared. The aim was to turn a civil war into one of Americans against Europeans. In 1814 royalist llaneros, mixed-race horsemen of the plains led by José Tomás Boves, destroyed the Second Republic. In 1815 Ferdinand VII sent about 10,000 troops under Pablo Morillo, who reconquered Venezuela and New Granada.

Worked example: the Letter from Jamaica

Read Bolívar's best-known text as a source. 1. Context: in September 1815 Bolívar was a defeated exile in British-ruled Jamaica, writing to a British correspondent. 2. Grievances: he argued that Spain had kept Americans shut out of public affairs, so they had never learned to govern themselves, and that its cruelty had made reconciliation impossible. 3. Vision: he doubted that the whole continent could become one nation, hoped for a league of American states, and favoured republics with strong executives rather than loose federations. 4. Viewpoint: he wrote as a creole who believed the mixed and Indigenous majority unready for self-rule. 5. Purpose: he sought British sympathy and support.

Haiti, the llaneros and Boyacá

The tide turned in 1816, when Haiti's president, Alexandre Pétion, gave Bolívar refuge, ships, arms and money on one condition: that he free enslaved people in the lands he liberated. Bolívar decreed freedom for enslaved men who joined his forces. He then won over the llaneros under José Antonio Páez and recruited several thousand British and Irish veterans of the Napoleonic Wars. In 1819 his army crossed flooded plains and the Andes into New Granada and won at Boyacá on 7 August. In December the Republic of Colombia, later called Gran Colombia, was proclaimed; the victory at Carabobo in 1821 secured Venezuela.

Gran Colombia's constitution

In 1821 a congress at Cúcuta wrote a constitution for Gran Colombia, which joined present-day Venezuela and Colombia, and soon Panama and Ecuador. It created a centralised republic, with Bolívar as president and Francisco de Paula Santander as vice-president governing in his absence. It limited the vote to men with property or an independent trade or profession. On slavery the congress compromised in a separate law of July 1821: children born to enslaved mothers would be free, but only after serving their mothers' owners until the age of 18, and committees of local notables were to buy the freedom of others gradually. Slaveholders' interests had limited the promise Bolívar made to Pétion.

Río de la Plata goes its own way

In the south, Buenos Aires gained confidence when its militias defeated British invasions in 1806 and 1807. On 25 May 1810, after news that French forces held almost all of Spain, a cabildo replaced the viceroy with a junta that still ruled in Ferdinand VII's name. Other provinces resisted Buenos Aires. Paraguay became independent in 1811, later ruled by José Gaspar Rodríguez de Francia, dictator for life from 1816, who isolated the country. The Banda Oriental, today's Uruguay, followed José Gervasio Artigas against both Buenos Aires and Portuguese Brazil. On 9 July 1816 a congress at Tucumán declared the independence of the United Provinces.

San Martín and Chile

San Martín, born in the Río de la Plata, had served for years as a Spanish army officer against Napoleon's forces. Returning in 1812, he decided that independence could never be safe while royalists held Peru, and that the route there lay through Chile. He trained the Army of the Andes at Mendoza and in early 1817 led roughly 5,000 men over high Andean passes. With the Chilean patriot Bernardo O'Higgins, he won at Chacabuco in February 1817. O'Higgins became Chile's supreme director, Chile declared independence in 1818, and victory at Maipú that April secured it. Thomas Cochrane, a Scottish former Royal Navy officer, built Chile's navy.

Peru and the meeting at Guayaquil

San Martín landed in Peru in 1820, proclaimed independence in Lima on 28 July 1821 and took the title Protector, but royalists still held the highlands. Meanwhile Bolívar's general Antonio José de Sucre won at Pichincha in May 1822, freeing Quito. In July 1822 San Martín and Bolívar met in private at Guayaquil. No reliable record of their talks survives, but afterwards San Martín withdrew from public life and left for Europe. Bolívar entered Peru in 1823; patriot armies won at Junín in August 1824, and Sucre's victory at Ayacucho in December 1824 effectively ended Spanish rule. Upper Peru became Bolivia in 1825.

Worked example: why Peru came last

Explain the delay with causes at several levels. 1. Royal power: Lima was the seat of a wealthy viceroyalty, the empire's strongest royalist base, with a large army. 2. Elite fear: memories of Túpac Amaru II's rebellion made many Peruvian creoles fear that independence would unleash an Indigenous uprising. 3. Social structure: a small creole elite ruled an Indigenous majority and had much to lose. 4. Military geography: royalists could hold the vast highlands even after losing Lima. 5. Outcome: Peru was liberated largely by armies from Río de la Plata, Chile and Gran Colombia. 6. Conclusion: where elites felt most threatened from below, independence came latest and from abroad.

What independence changed

Bolívar's Congress of Panama of 1826, meant to bind the new states together, achieved little. Gran Colombia broke into Venezuela, Colombia and Ecuador by 1830, the year Bolívar died. Power often passed to caudillos, military strongmen allied with landowners. Formal caste distinctions were abolished, and Indigenous tribute was ended in some countries but restored in others for revenue. Slavery ended slowly: Chile abolished it in 1823, but most of the new republics did so only in the 1850s. Independence transferred sovereignty from Spain to creole elites more than it overturned colonial hierarchies.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, imagining one united movement: north and south fought separately, and Paraguay and Uruguay resisted Buenos Aires. Second, assuming the poor all backed the patriots; royalist llaneros destroyed the Second Republic in 1814. Third, forgetting Haiti's role: Pétion's aid and its condition on slavery helped turn the war. Fourth, dating independence to the first juntas of 1810; they still ruled in Ferdinand VII's name. Fifth, believing slavery ended with independence; abolition took decades. Sixth, treating Guayaquil as a documented agreement; what was said remains unknown.

Key takeaways

Venezuela declared independence in 1811, but royalists and popular hostility destroyed its first two republics. Bolívar's Letter from Jamaica set out a creole vision of strong republics, and Haitian aid, the llaneros and foreign volunteers carried him to Boyacá in 1819 and Gran Colombia, whose constitution freed slaves only gradually. Buenos Aires formed a junta in 1810 and declared independence in 1816, while San Martín freed Chile and took Lima. After Guayaquil, Bolívar and Sucre finished the war at Ayacucho in 1824. Independence brought caudillos and slow social change.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Libertadores

The liberators of Spanish South America, chiefly Bolívar and San Martín

They met in private at Guayaquil in 1822.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

What was the purpose of Bolívar's 1813 Decree of War to the Death?

Question 2 of 5

What condition did Alexandre Pétion attach to Haiti's aid for Bolívar in 1816?

Question 3 of 5

How did the 1821 Congress of Cúcuta deal with slavery in Gran Colombia?

Question 4 of 5

Why was Peru the last major region of Spanish South America to be liberated?

Question 5 of 5

Which statement about the Guayaquil meeting of 1822 is accurate?

← Previous topicNext topic →